It’s a common assumption that being a leader requires a certain level of extroversion. Extroverts tend to come across as more confident and charismatic, so they stand out, which can elevate their position within the workplace. But being an extrovert isn’t and shouldn’t be a requirement for leaders.
Especially in careers like sales, marketing, and public relations, it’s often assumed that to rise through the ranks, you need an outgoing personality. In fact, there are many, many advice columns recommending and instructing introverts on how to be more extroverted in order to succeed. As both an introvert and an executive, I think this is a huge mistake.
Telling introverts they need to be extroverted to experience career growth not only forces someone to be something they’re not, but can be exhausting and contribute to burnout—something we should all be actively trying to avoid. Instead, we should accept one another—and ourselves—as we authentically are. Bring the beautiful variety of experiences and traits that make you who you are every single day, and that’s how an organization finds true success.
For my fellow introverts, a few reminders:
LEAN INTO THE FACT THAT YOU BELONG HERE
There’s a reason you’re in this position. You’re an expert and you’ve proven to be effective and valuable. Imposter syndrome can run very deep within introverted leaders, so when it flares up, remind yourself that you earned this spot, and you deserve it.
ACCEPT YOUR INTERSECTIONALITY
As a leader, I’m more than just an introvert. I’m a female, queer person of color. All these aspects of my life have shaped me, and in some ways, made me a better leader. There have been times in my career I’ve felt pressure to show up as someone or something else because that’s what I assumed I had to do to be successful. A lot of this comes from our childhood development—we learn that leaders are expected to look, dress, or act a certain way. But none of that’s true. You can be a great leader and still be your authentic self.
TAKE CARE OF YOURSELF MENTALLY
Even though it often feels contrary to my nature, I still need to rise to the occasion in public settings. That might mean standing up for a team member with a difficult client or sitting through meetings all day when I’d rather be alone. It can often leave you feeling exhausted at the end of the day, regardless of whether something traumatic or dramatic took place. Just the feeling of being “on” can take a mental toll. That’s why introverted leaders need to make time to decompress, to unplug, and to find ways to replenish our social batteries. Whether that’s meditation, going for a walk alone, or putting down the phone at the end of the day—carving out time to recharge is essential.
As I mentioned, too often the advice on how to succeed as an introvert focuses on changing your personality to be more extroverted. Instead, as leaders, we should strive to make our workplaces more inclusive for all personality types and provide more equitable opportunities. Here’s how:
DON’T MAKE ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT INTROVERTS
Don’t fall into the trap of assuming that extroverts are better for certain roles, or you could be missing out on great talent. While introverts might not talk as much or strike up a conversation first, they often tend to be more insightful, listen intently, and think before speaking, and those are all extremely valuable traits in sales, marketing/PR, or any leadership role.
CREATE SPACE FOR YOUR TEAM TO POWER UP/POWER DOWN
Like me, many people need time to mentally prepare for or recover from social situations, including business meetings. Be mindful when booking meetings to allow some space between appointments. Most of us aren’t conducting life-saving brain surgery, so it’s probably okay to ease up on the false sense of urgency that we often create for ourselves. Even taking just five minutes to decompress and shift gears between interactions can be incredibly helpful—not only for introverts, but for everyone.
ADOPT INCLUSIVE MEETING ETIQUETTE
Meetings tend to revolve around those who talk first, most, and loudest, which leaves introverts holding their tongues. Instead, create space for others by following better meeting etiquette, which includes sharing the agenda in advance so people can come prepared. Encourage participants to raise their hands (digitally on video calls or physically when in person) and wait to be called on to speak so everyone has a chance. Monitor the chat and read the room to make sure you’re not ignoring input. Most importantly, pause. We tend to fear silence and fill gaps with words, which means you could be shutting down the space for someone with a brilliant idea to jump in. Instead, pause to give people a chance to consider what they’ve just heard.
CHECK YOURSELF ON CELEBRATION
Pay attention to what you’re recognizing, acknowledging, and praising as good work. Make sure it’s not only the extroverts and their outgoing behaviors. A lot of great work happens without a lot of noise. Make sure that gets celebrated, too.
Welcoming introverts to the leadership bench is part of being an inclusive organization, where diversity in all its forms is welcome and encouraged. As leaders, we can set the tone by modeling vulnerability and authenticity to demonstrate that everyone on our team is valuable and worthy of their seat at the table.
Geri Johnson is the Chief Operating Officer at Next PR.