Across industries, the battle for top talent is increasingly looking less like a hiring cycle and more like an arms race. In AI, Meta recently lured a 24-year-old researcher away from his own startup with a $250 million package. But you don’t have to be in tech to feel the squeeze. From healthcare and manufacturing to consumer goods and retailers, leaders are competing for a limited pool of executives who can navigate disruption, drive innovation, and steer companies through uncertainty to drive growth.
The drought is real. Baby boomers are retiring in greater numbers, shrinking the pipeline of seasoned leaders. Executives who could make a move are often risk-averse, waiting to see how the economy shakes out. And leaders with proven expertise in emerging technologies, supply chain resilience, or managing through shifting regulations are few and far between. The result is a classic supply-and-demand issue: Multiple companies chasing the same finite, high-caliber, candidate pool.
So how does a company that doesn’t have “Meta equity” compete? As the managing partner of an executive search firm, I see it every day: The winners know compensation matters, but they also know it’s only part of the equation.
IT’S NOT JUST ABOUT THE MONEY
Few companies can offer an eight-to-nine-figure compensation package. But offering average pay in today’s climate isn’t enough. To be sure, there’s a place in this world for compensation surveys. But it’s important to view them in context; they’re a data point, not the data set. Clients don’t often seek out 50th percentile talent. So why then look at 50th percentile benchmarks as a baseline framework?
To say the quiet thing out loud: The most relevant compensation data that you have is of those candidates that are most interesting and qualified to you. Chances are they’re in the top quartile or higher because of their track record. What you’re wanting them to do for your company; they have already done—or they’re doing it—for their current organization.
Thankfully for most, it’s not just a coin-operated equation. Those that are winning the war for talent highlight what today’s executives value most: autonomy, visibility, purpose, and flexibility. Many candidates want to lead transformation efforts, shape culture, build things, and leave a legacy. Others are drawn to companies that encourage innovation and view hybrid or remote work as a strategic asset rather than a concession. Smart companies put those intangibles on the table early, weaving them into the entire package.
EXPERIENCED VETERAN VERSUS UP-AND-COMER
When boards think about a senior hire, they often picture a veteran with decades of industry-specific experience. And often, that’s the right choice. But in a market this competitive, expanding the aperture can be game-changing.
Sometimes the best hire is the number two who’s ready to step into the top job. Or it’s a high performer from another sector who can bring fresh thinking and fewer entrenched assumptions. When a company already has deep industry experience on its leadership team, an unconventional choice can inject energy, challenge the status quo, and unlock new opportunities.
In a competitive market, perfection is the enemy of great. Too often, companies create a laundry list of requirements for the ideal candidate, only to stall the process when no one checks every box. Meanwhile, the business doesn’t pause, and competitors don’t wait.
In today’s talent market, decisiveness is an advantage. Be clear about your four to five must-have requirements versus nice-to-have. Calibrate your assumptions early with real profiles. And make sure you’re receiving complete and accurate market data. Unicorns may not exist—but great talent certainly does. Those who act with confidence tend to win the race.
THE FUTURE OF WINNING
The companies coming out ahead in the talent wars aren’t necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets. They’re the ones listening carefully to what matters most, moving at pace, and shaping roles where leaders can thrive.
Money will always matter, but not at the expense of culture, flexibility, and purpose—as we’ve seen with some very public boomerangs. In a world where every business is fighting for the same elite talent, the sustainable advantage isn’t just how much you’re willing to pay, but it’s how well you align opportunity with what great leaders value most.
Bryan Buck is the managing partner at ON Partners.