As the CEO of a growing real estate operating company, few decisions that reach my desk are simple.
Earlier this year, I thought I had finally found one.
I was wrong.
The details are unimportant. What I thought would be a simple, logistical change was anything but. It was a classic leadership blind spot. The gap between my perception of a decision and my team’s experience of it was wider than I realized.
I had lost touch with my team.
This is common in leadership. Good intel can be elusive when everyone has something to prove or when they want to wield influence.
The experience inspired me to close the gap. I decided to implement the single most powerful tool for leadership growth I’ve ever encountered: A formal, 360-degree review where my employees would anonymously evaluate me.
THE UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTH ABOUT FEEDBACK
People want feedback. At least, they want to want feedback. Hearing it and acting upon it is a different story.
After all, once you ask for feedback, you never know what you will learn. It could be an affirmation of your leadership style and logistical acumen. It could reveal a painful disconnect between your perception and your team’s reality.
For example, one workplace survey found that while 70% of managers reported having a great relationship with their workers, only 58% of employees shared this sentiment.
Nobody wants to be on the other side of that feedback dichotomy.
I’ll admit, the prospect of having five of my team members review me was nerve-wracking, but the goal wasn’t to get a perfect score. I wanted a true one.
HOW TO GET FEEDBACK THAT ACTUALLY MATTERS
Getting useful feedback isn’t as simple as just asking for it. People may be reticent to share information with leaders because they worry their candor could be used against them.
For instance, a survey of HR leaders and their teams found that only 39% of employees feel comfortable sharing honest feedback about their work experience, afraid their insights won’t truly be anonymous or that the company’s culture makes them unwelcome.
If you want good, honest information, you must create a process built on trust and clarity.
As the data scientists say, “garbage in, garbage out.”
To get the information you need, here’s what we learned:
#1 ANONYMITY IS EVERYTHING
If you want honest feedback, people need to know their identity will not be revealed and will be protected. It is the foundation of effective feedback.
Without a rock-solid guarantee of anonymity, you will get filtered, polite, and ultimately useless feedback. Your team needs to feel safe enough to be completely honest.
#2 ASK THE RIGHT QUESTIONS
People are inundated with surveys and feedback requests.
With satisfaction surveys accompanying everything from a trip to the grocery store to an app experience, feedback fatigue is inevitable.
When asking your team for feedback, you can’t overwhelm them with volume. A 50-question survey will get you rushed, thoughtless answers.
We found that about 15 questions are the sweet spot. Critically, about one-third of the questions need to be open-ended to provide the qualitative context behind the scores.
#3 DEFINE THE SCALE
Make sure everyone knows the rules of the game.
Often, this means clearly communicating to all participants how to use the 1-to-5 rating scale.
For example, if a reviewer has a personal rule that they “don’t give fives,” they’ve just lopped off 20% of the scale and skewed the results. We explicitly tell our team to use the entire scale to get the most accurate data.
#4 USE A NEUTRAL THIRD PARTY
How you collect and deliver feedback is not a minor detail. The platform you choose will have implications for everything from data accessibility to privacy protection, so choose wisely.
We used our HR software program, which has templates for this. Then, to ensure impartiality, our HR director collected the anonymized data and reviewed the results with me.
TURNING FEEDBACK INTO GROWTH
Asking for feedback is a great first step to personal growth. However, asking is just the first step.
My feedback was a clear mandate to communicate more transparently. So, I started holding regular forums not only announcing decisions but to explain the rationale behind them.
Will it be enough? Time will tell.
The next time I ask for feedback, I’m sure I will learn more about the impact of these initiatives and new growth areas will come to my attention.
We all have flaws. Feedback helps us identify and fix them. These lessons help ensure that the next time you ask your team for feedback, you get information that actually matters, making you and your team better.
Richard Ross currently serves as Chief Executive Officer of Quinn Residences.