Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

In a moment of relentless change, new CEOs face a test

What to preserve and what to let go of.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Jason Dressel

CEO · History Factory

As leadership transitions accelerate across corporate America, the real challenge revolves around preserving the core of what made a company great in the first place.

At a moment when CEO turnover is hitting record highs, a familiar playbook has taken hold: new leader, new strategy, new direction. Transformation has become the default expectation as everyone adjusts to a new era (Hint: It’s defined by two words that begin with “A” and “I”).

But what if the real job of a CEO today isn’t deciding what to change but what not to?

The sanctity of the superpower

Longitudinal research suggests founder-led companies outperform their peers, but many companies don’t have the luxury of bringing their founders back. What they often have is something just as powerful: A deep understanding of what made them exceptional in the first place.

Too many CEOs today lose sight of the forest for the trees. In the rush to transform, they forget their organizations’ true superpowers—the distinctive roles they play in the world—and fail to apply the discipline required to protect that.

Customers renew their Costco memberships annually not only for low prices but also because they trust that everything, including toilet paper, vacations and car tires are smart buys. Costco’s superpower is turning ruthless product curation into consistently superior value.

Center the business

At a time when every company is being forced to adapt to the transformative impact of AI, a more fundamental question is emerging: Who can change without losing what made them successful in the first place?

Different companies are adapting, particularly those with a long history of managing leadership transitions across generations and those still comparatively young. Many of our most consequential companies—including Amazon, Apple, BlackRock, Nike, and Starbucks—still must prove they can sustain performance across generations of leadership.

Howard Schultz returned to Starbucks three times to steady it. Since becoming CEO in 2024, Brian Niccol’s “Back to Starbucks” strategy has focused on reestablishing the “third place” experience, built on in-store connection, quality, and community. In other words, doubling down on the superpower that made Starbucks a phenomenon in the first place.

In this context, Disney is an interesting case. A legacy company that has navigated decades of change, yet in recent years has shown signs of strain—its stock now trading roughly where it was a decade ago, and the return of longtime CEO Bob Iger in 2022 to steady the ship. Since Josh D’Amaro took the helm in March 2026, Disney has faced its own version of this challenge: How to evolve without losing its center.

For Disney, that superpower is the ability to craft high-quality stories that create an emotional connection across generations, transcending time and place. Whether it’s legacy intellectual property (IP) like Mickey Mouse, the Disney princesses, and The Lion King; acquired franchises like Winnie the Pooh, The Muppets, and Star Wars; or acquired creative engines like Pixar and Marvel, Disney’s core is the ability to create characters and stories that endure—and can be endlessly reimagined.

Walt Disney understood this intuitively. In 1957, he sketched what became known as the company’s “Synergy Map.” This simple but profound model placed storytelling and imagination at the center and showed how it could scale across film, television, theme parks and more.

The lesson for modern CEOs is deceptively simple: What you put at the center of your business defines everything that surrounds it.

The lost plot’s cost

The question every incoming CEO should be asking is not just “What should we do next?” but “What belongs at the center of our map, and are we protecting it?”

The consequences of getting that wrong are visible across corporate America. Starbucks’ drift from the “third place” to a transactional beverage pitstop—and Nike’s shift from performance innovation for athletes to “sneakerhead” culture—offer cautionary tales of what happens when companies lose the plot of their own story.

In contrast, Disney’s $1 billion investment in OpenAI‘s Sora aligned with the Synergy Map mindset, though Sora eventually shut down. What matters now is how Disney applies that lesson while keeping its storytelling IP at the center of whatever comes next.

Institutional wisdom

In a period of pronounced leadership change, companies are taking divergent approaches. Some are turning to insiders, whether long groomed or not, while others are bringing in external leaders, with or without direct industry experience.

There’s no clear evidence that one approach is better than another, as there are simply too many variables when a new CEO steps in. Yet this is where insider leaders like D’Amaro and John Ternus, Tim Cook’s successor at Apple, may have an advantage in balancing transformation with continuity. They understand the organizations they lead more deeply and are more likely to recognize what truly makes them distinctive.

That distinction is only possible when organizations maintain strong institutional knowledge as a strategic asset. At its best, that knowledge begets institutional wisdom, creating a throughline between past, present and future.

It clarifies what is on or off—not just for the brand but also for the business itself. It reinforces what aligns with core principles and signals when a company has wandered from its path. Employees feel it. Customers sense it.

Protect what matters

Wise companies will adapt to new opportunities and challenges without diminishing their superpowers. That requires a different kind of leadership discipline—not just the courage to transform, but the judgment to protect. The job of a CEO isn’t just to redefine the future, but to ensure the company’s core remains strong enough to carry it there.

The challenge for its next CEO is not to reinvent that truth but to protect it.

Jason Dressel is the CEO of History Factory.