My first company was a booming three-figure business where I turned bandana strips into flip-flop straps, unrivaled in both adorability…and impracticality. A toes-out, indestructible water shoe became a sloppy, dirty mess of fabric that degraded by the day. Regardless, buyers loved the product.
I handled everything. I rode my bike to buy flip-flops at Old Navy and bandanas at Hobby Lobby, then measured, cut, and tied every pair myself.
Mid-summer, I realized I could save time and increase profit if I paid a friend’s siblings pennies to cut and tie. But I had integrity. I’d promised to fulfill every order myself.
I’m slightly older now, and my current business—The Colab, a business-to-business technology public relations firm —is slightly larger. But integrity still guides my day-to-day operations, especially in AI’s wake.
AI and integrity
Our AI-powered “anyone can do it” era has also brought a “just because you can, doesn’t mean you should” realization. So what does integrity mean in business today? I believe integrity means standing behind your actions, leading with honesty, and being unwavering in your morals.
In PR, that looks like open, honest, and transparent communication with your team, clients, and the media. It also means crafting your own articles and pitches, without AI.
AI expands integrity-related gray areas. People who swore they’d “absolutely never” touch AI now can’t answer an email without it. The ever-moving line keeps shifting, pushed a little further weekly without notice.
As a result, building a business with integrity is harder than ever. Shortcuts, loopholes, and efficiencies constantly tempt you to use AI, as you tell yourself nobody will notice and it won’t impact the final product that much.
But it does. A hundred concessions in a row will build something you hardly recognize and can barely stand behind. Where you draw the line is personal, and you have to decide it for yourself.
3 ways to preserve your business integrity
Here are a few baseline principles I think most of us can agree on, no matter how much AI we use.
1. Refuse to oversell and under-deliver
AI makes it dangerously easy to promise the world, because “everything by Friday” suddenly sounds reasonable. Imperative skills that used to take weeks—like researching, writing articles, crafting reports, and developing campaign plans—now take hours and can increase output tenfold.
But again, just because you can doesn’t mean you should.
Successful business owners prioritize quality over quantity. You can pump out 10 times the work, but your client or customer won’t necessarily get 10 times the value. One client would send us an AI summary of every call as soon as the line dropped. I can assure you that nobody read the 41-page recaps, and we all wasted time deleting them.
In addition, business owners should listen to their clients to understand their goals, what matters to them, and how they can help the client achieve those goals. But don’t overpromise something you’re not exceptionally skilled at, even if AI seems to make it possible.
We see prospective clients’ requests for proposals (RFPs) asking to bundle marketing and PR under one company’s umbrella, which can force agencies to offer things they may not be best at. While tempting for overachievers and figure-it-outers, if it’s not your bread and butter, it’s not something you should offer.
2. Be deliberate in how you treat the people you hire
Many companies treat employees like a line item they’ll eliminate the moment AI gets close enough to mimicking their job. If you’re trying to build an integrity-based business, that playbook won’t work.
Business integrity means you make a long-term bet on someone. This job is somebody’s rent, their family, their whole life. Not every hire works out. But the people who pour their weekdays into your business deserve your reciprocity.
At The Colab, we’re intentional about how and when we hire, and deliberate about the folks that we bring in.
For example, grit and determination aren’t easily conveyed through a resume or cover letter. When interviews unearth those traits, we gravitate toward those hires because they can’t easily be replicated with AI.
3. Preserve the talent pipeline
Companies believe they no longer need entry-level talent to do the entry-level work that AI excels at: first drafts, research, grunt work, and assignments. This work is how the next generation learns how to do small, unglamorous things badly, then a little better, then finally well.
Eliminate it, and at first, you’ll have a leaner team. But soon enough you’ll have no one who can mature into your future managers, account executives, and leaders.
I recently extended an offer to a candidate I had met with regularly over the past two years. She has this spark, this “zhuzh,” that I’d never seen before. I warned her that switching paths into PR would “be hell for two years.” She wanted it anyway. She’s one of our best-ever hires.
I know that cutting out the pyramid’s bottom leaves us with a structure sure to crumble. AI can’t fly to San Francisco to pitch a keystone client or take a customer to dinner. It can’t manage someone angling for a promotion. And it certainly can’t lead an organization.
That hire that I mentioned? She’s the one doing those things now. Not AI.
Business wisdom
My fuzzy flip-flops weren’t a good business model. They hardly lasted a few months, and by the end of the summer each resembled a dirty mop. By any reasonable standard, they were a bad product.
But people bought them anyway, summer after summer, because they could feel the work I tied into every strap. I couldn’t have handed that off to my best friend’s siblings in good conscience then, and we can’t hand it off now.
Of course, AI can do the work. The real question is whether it should, and how much of ourselves, and each other, we’re willing to leave behind for it.
Personally, I’m still tying every pair myself. Just in different ways.
Lizzy Harris is CEO and cofounder at The Colab.