What distinguishes a crypto token from a commodity or a security? That question weighs on the minds of many U.S.-based crypto and blockchain startups and established crypto/blockchain/Web3 companies. The answer to this question may in fact determine whether these companies decide to stay here or domicile offshore.
The recent civil suits filed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) against giant crypto centralized exchanges Binance and Coinbase have several allegations. The allegation that impacts most startups is the selling of unregistered securities. These include the big caps, like Cardano and Solana.
This concern reflects the public allegation by SEC Chairman Gary Gensler that, except for Bitcoin, most altcoins are actually unregistered securities. This assertion is hotly contested by the crypto industry as well as many pro-crypto members of Congress.
ARE ALTCOINS SECURITIES?
But how exactly does the SEC decide if something is a security or not?
In 1946, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in SEC vs. Howey Corporation that there are basically four factors that determine if something is a security. The four elements are as follows:
• An investment of money
• in a common enterprise
• with expectations of a profit
• to be derived from the efforts of others.
Gensler contends that this 1946 Howey Test is sufficient for him and his agency to decide that most of these large-market-cap cryptos are unregistered securities. The crypto industry disagrees for the following reasons.
One is that while some people do buy crypto to invest in or do short-term trading, others simply buy it to pay for the transaction (or “gas”) fee to use the blockchain network. Basically the argument is that although you can buy stock in an energy company as an investment, when you buy gasoline or electricity from this company, you are not investing in it. You are buying it because you need the gas or electricity to run your car or your house. The same goes with crypto. While some might buy to invest, many buy it because they need to pay for the network usage costs, not necessarily because they are investing in the token.
Second, many blockchain projects are open-source, developed by global teams who may not know each other personally. If there is ever coordination, it’s often done through a non-corporate entity called a Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO), where token holders worldwide vote on whether they want change proposals to be implemented.
The tokens give these developers and other holders ownership of the network, but in a decentralized manner. It is more of a community-owned network rather than standard corporation-type ownership with shares of stock.
THE EXTENDED CASE FOR WHY CRYPTO SHOULDN’T BE CONSIDERED SECURITIES
One additional problem: Most securities have extensive reportorial requirements, like audited profit and loss statements, pertinent disclosures, even ESG reporting requirements. In a decentralized blockchain network, there are really no management teams and boards who can be tasked to issue these required reports. Although certain personalities like Vitalik Buterin of Ethereum, Charles Hoskinson of Cardano, Anatoly Yakovenko of Solana and others are identifiable, they no longer really run or manage the development of the blockchain except as technical or even social influencers.
The Bitcoin founder Satoshi Nakamoto is a pseudonym. If you want Bitcoin to issue these reports, how do you find and communicate with them? You can’t. No one knows them, let alone knows where they are.
Declaring these tokens as unregistered securities also limits the market to accredited investors, who either have $1 million or earn $200,000 a year ($300,000 a year for married couples). I see a bit of a discriminatory angle here, like telling people “you’re not good enough to invest in crypto.” Crypto has a “power to the people” vibe. Declaring these as unregistered securities that only wealthy accredited investors can buy is the opposite of that vibe.
One has to remember that crypto and blockchain were developed as a solution to the corruption in the traditional finance system. The original Bitcoin white paper proposed a solution to the problem of third-party intermediaries that could not be trusted because they’ve led to events like the 2008 mortgage crisis, and Nakamoto felt that “code as law” might do better.
The SEC itself does not even demonstrate consensus on whether these digital assets are really securities. When asked by the House Financial Services Committee if Ethereum was a security, Gensler could not give a definitive answer. The recently released internal emails from former SEC Commissioner William Hinman show similar ambiguity. Even the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) declared in its testimony before Congress that Ethereum is a commodity, while the SEC claims it is a security. Ambiguity like that, if allowed to fester, just creates uncertainty for this sector.
WHAT DOES ALL THIS MEAN FOR TECH COMPANIES AND INVESTORS IN CRYPTO?
The U.S. Government is strong enough to force its rules on this new technology. But doing so may force innovation in crypto, blockchain, Web3 and DeFi companies to leave the U.S. I believe that losing leadership in crypto and blockchain is not in line with advancing America’s interests globally and at home. It is perhaps time to re-examine whether old benchmarks for evaluating whether something is a security or commodity are still relevant in this digital age.
Unfortunately for tech companies and investors in this space, this lack of clarity is already tempting some companies to relocate outside the U.S. If America wants to remain the global leader in this space, I believe government must work with the sector to establish a clear legal basis that reassures them that they are welcome to work here.
For those businesses and companies that want to use crypto as a means of funding, because of the recent Southern District of New York ruling on SEC vs Ripple XRP, I recommend doing any crypto or NFT sales only through public exchanges, and not via direct sales or Initial Coin or NFT Offerings. The impact of that recent ruling will be discussed in a future article.
Zain Jaffer is an active Tech & Real Estate investor who sold his last company for $780M in 2019 to Blackstone.