Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Is executive coaching worth the money: Six ways to maximize your investment

If you're thinking about hiring an executive coach, consider these six things to fully maximize your coaching's value.

Coach speaking to business professionals

[Images: fizkes/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Matthew Wride

BY Matthew Wride

When it comes to executive coaching, the barrier to entry is low. Often, anyone can hang a shingle and announce themselves as an executive coach. No questions asked. Among the variety, we find individuals that recently sold their businesses, former athletes, and other typical scenarios, such as retired HR leaders or former CEOs. Yet, what do we really know about coaching’s overall value in helping leaders? Testimonials range from glowing to disastrous.

When I first encountered executive coaching, I was skeptical. After all, good leaders should be able to figure things out on their own, right? Here is a sampling of the questions I had.

  • Is coaching just therapy with updated and modernized branding?
  • Am I paying a coach to fix me?
  • Why would I need a coach if I am performing well?
  • Are there rules or laws that govern coaching?

As an aside, this article touches on executive coaching rather than life coaching. Life coaches tend to involve themselves in all areas of a client’s life. Executive coaching, on the other hand, is limited in its focus. Executive coaching is a one-on-one process where an experienced independent facilitator collaborates with a business professional to help that person evaluate and improve their leadership, their career, and their overall professional and business performance.

COACHING IS EFFECTIVE, BUT…

Now that I have been in the process for many years, I can unequivocally state that I am a full-fledged advocate for executive coaching and its effectiveness. Coaching done the right way simply works. There is an important caveat, however: A good coach needs to be trained, possess real-life experience, and both the coach and the client need to have a clear understanding of how to maximize the process.

IS COACHING REGULATED? 

In many areas of the world, coaching is not regulated. Nonetheless, there are a few legal issues to consider. First, coaching is not therapy, and coaches that use therapeutic techniques run the risk of acting as mental health professionals without the required licenses. Various jurisdictions have strict rules regarding therapy, and executive coaches need to stay far away from those lines.

Second, there are general legal duties that may apply. A client will have a reasonable expectation that the coach will both be competent and act in good faith. Absent effective disclaimers, a coach may be legally liable if they offer bad advice or act in a way that is counter to a client’s interests.

If you’re thinking about hiring an executive coach, consider these six things to fully maximize your coaching’s value.

1. LOOK FOR A SYSTEM AND A FOCUS

The best coaches develop and follow a framework, whether that framework is self-created or established by a certifying body. Personally, I did not obtain a broad certification. Instead, I chose a specialty certification that is focused exclusively on 360-degree feedback. In either case, broad or focused, certification is helpful because it establishes:

  • reliable ethics to be followed 
  • standards of practice that ensure consistency and efficacy

Check with a potential coach on what system they intend to use, and consider whether they are bound by ethical and professional standards. 

2. SEEK PRACTICAL EXPERIENCE OUTSIDE OF COACHING

An executive coach needs enough practical (noncoaching) experience to be useful. As mentioned, if real-life business experience is not a requirement, then a life coach might be a good option. If, however, you need advice that is professionally oriented, look for someone who knows what it is like to be in your shoes. Consider, also, that broad experience may be more beneficial than focused experience. If sales executives only work with former sales professionals, then creativity might be dampened. You also run the risk of establishing self-perpetuating echo chambers.

3. SOME COACHES ARE FREE

A common belief is that executive coaches are expensive, and this is true for the good ones. If you take the time, however, to develop a meaningful relationship with a mentor, they can assume the role of an executive coach. Thus, regardless of whether you end up using a professional coach, it is always a good idea to develop a relationship with a trusted mentor inside your industry or organization.

4. COACHES ARE NOT CONSULTANTS

Have a clear understanding of what a coach can do for you. Hire a consultant if you want someone to tell you what to do. Retain a coach if you are looking for an objective set of “outside” eyes and ears to help you evaluate your leadership and performance. Coaches should always respect a client’s domain expertise.

5. DO YOUR DUE DILIGENCE

Do your due diligence in selecting a coach. Ask for references and review the coach’s profile and promotional materials. It is also helpful to request an exploratory, no-charge consultation to see if the coach might be a good fit. Define your criteria upfront, such as whether you need industry expertise, a special type of creativity, diversity, or a distinctive approach.

6. ASK FOR AN ENGAGEMENT LETTER

Even if you simply write down a few rules of the road in an email, it is always a good idea to use an engagement letter to memorialize your relationship with a coach. This is especially true if you are paying the coach for their time. An engagement letter will, among other things, outline the rules of confidentiality, working expectations for both the coach and the client, and how the relationship may be terminated. Simply put, take the time to define in writing what you expect from your coach. 

Effective coaching is a powerful tool that helps many professionals improve their performance at work. But as with any investment, the client should carefully oversee and define the process. Remember that the goal is not to fix you. Instead, an effective coach offers objective outside insights so that you, the client, can decide how you want to develop and grow, improve your performance, and find ways to help your organization win.  


Matthew Wride is the president of DecisionWise. He is a tech executive, author, consultant, and executive coach.