There is an outstandingly memorable moment at the end of the movie Casablanca. Rick (Humphrey Bogart) kills the German Major Strasser at the airport. Though Captain Louis Renault (Claude Rains) should have arrested Rick to gain respect from the Nazis, he chooses instead to stand up for what he believes is right, saves Rick, and directs his men to “round up the usual suspects.”
In our workplace worlds, far from that airport in Casablanca, we as leaders often choose to “round up the usual suspects,” even when we suspect people aren’t completely to blame for things going wrong. This solution may not be complete, but it seems right.
Beyond “rounding up” people to blame, there are other easy, quick-to-blame targets: a lack of desired resources, poor technology, lack of time, money, no control measures, market conditions, ineffective strategic approaches, weak analysis, critical thinking, and decision-making. They’re all so blameable.
But lurking in the shadowy, dark corners of our workplaces lie other hidden agents that can often be rightly blamed for killing growth.
FAULTY ORGANIZATIONAL DESIGN
One such culprit is your company’s organizational design.
A sign that faulty design is being ignored is when piling resources on a problem just doesn’t work. Heaping perceived assets on top of a faulty design structure just pushes the solution further and further out of sight and successfully keeps the destructive hidden agent in place and unrecognized. This thinking is exactly what any hidden agent would want in order to remain in place.
All organizational designs work—or worked—at some point. They often stop working when the complexities of a company increase beyond the organizational structure’s functional ability to support the demands of accelerated growth.
How can you determine if you have an organizational design issue? Here are a few first investigative steps toward finding out:
- Ask your people what’s getting in the way of more profitable and useful execution.
- Find out what restrictions and limitations are being complained about. This usually shows up through “If only we had more of . . .” statements.
- Challenge your people to isolate the root cause of the problem. Is it people? Processes? Or resources? Time? Waste? Budget?
- Look at the excuse patterns behind poor performance. The finger pointing tends to go quickest to people—often the easiest explanation, but not always the accurate one.
UNCLEAR LANGUAGE
Another shadow-lurking, shapeshifting hidden agent is the very language leaders and managers use to communicate roles, responsibilities, directives, incentives, approaches, initiatives, growth challenges, and objectives.
The lack of clear, concise, and explicit language is responsible for a wide range of misunderstandings. When communication is implicitly weighted rather than explicitly weighted, specific intended meaning gets lost in translation.
When leaders direct with implicit language, their directives are often vague and generalized. These leaders assume understanding when there is no evidence of it. We all know that we interpret what we hear through the biased lens of what we want to hear. For example, how often have you imagined an outcome only to discover it was nothing like you were certain it would be?
One sign that language is playing a role in restricting growth is when direction takes increasingly more time before it moves into a decision and then actionable execution. When your directional language is extrinsic, time creep doesn’t happen as much. When language is more explicit, readiness to execute rightly increases, and wasted time and frustration decrease.
When language is more generalized and vague, different interpretations multiply. Leaders then become arbitrators of what correctly intended meaning is and isn’t. When leaders yield to demands to arbitrate, rather than have their people arbitrate on their own, their people are leading and the leader is following.
Do you or your leaders have a language problem? Are your leaders spending too much time correcting wrong directions or approaches and then blaming their people for misunderstanding what they haven’t made clear yet?
Here are a few first steps in assessing if your leaders are professional communicators:
- Listen to how clearly, specifically, vaguely, or assumptively they speak when giving directions.
- Shadow your leaders when they present or direct their people. Notice how their direction is received. Is there mindless, bobble-headed nodding or respectful challenging?
- Are your people asking their people to re-state what they’re saying to determine the accuracy of their understanding?
- Are your people using generalized words that can be easily misunderstood?
- The most ineffective strategy is to not spend time listening to how your people are communicating.
Explicit language has its own set of hallmarks: clarity, specificity, detail, accountability, and measures. When these characteristics are in place, there is little room for doubt. Professional communicators know this. Lazy managers only think they know this.
So, while you may not be standing on an airport runway on a foggy Casablanca night, in a trench coat, next to an Algerian French police officer named Louis, you might benefit by paying closer attention to those hidden systemic issues causing the real problem.
Or, you may just need to get back to work really fast. And, of course, in that case, directing your people to “round up the usual suspects,” could work—in a foggy-Casablanca-night kind of way!