For years, the message from venture capitalists was simple: Grow at all costs. This mindset is softening, but the damage has been done. Too many founders are still chasing new customers as though it’s the only metric that matters, sacrificing profitability and, more importantly, retention.
It’s a costly mistake, and one that many leaders refuse to solve.
THE LEAKY BUCKET PROBLEM
Picture a business pouring money into customer acquisition. The company seems to be thriving, with new logos arriving every week. The growth chart trends upward, and everyone’s feeling great.
Now, look at the other side of the bucket. Customers are leaking out the bottom almost as fast as they pour in. This is the part that never makes it into the pitch deck.
I know founders who don’t have a viable business model because their churn is so high that they need to replace their entire customer base every couple of months. Think about how exhausting that is. It’s like running on a treadmill, sprinting just to stay in the same spot. This type of business is fragile and incredibly hard to run. One bad quarter of customer acquisition can throw everything off balance.
CUSTOMER ACQUISITION IS GETTING MORE EXPENSIVE
The cost of acquiring new customers keeps climbing. From 2023 to 2025, customer acquisition costs in the ecommerce sector rose by 40% to 60%. Paid channels grow more crowded and expensive every year, pushing customer acquisition costs higher.
When you build your entire strategy around acquisition, you’re betting your business on the most expensive and unpredictable input. Meanwhile, you’re ignoring the cheaper, more reliable solution that’s sitting right in front of you.
Retention is typically far less expensive than acquisition. It’s also much more predictable. Renewals are generally much easier to model than new customer growth from paid media.
BriteCo is a renewal-driven business. We sell specialty jewelry and watch insurance, and like many insurance products, it isn’t a one-time purchase. Policies renew year after year. When I’m planning the year, our renewal base is our foundation because it’s something I can count on.
RETENTION COMPOUNDS
The power of retention is that it compounds. If you get retention right, the economics are incredible: Every customer you keep this year is one you don’t have to re-acquire next year. The existing customer base continues to grow.
There’s a second retention benefit that many people miss. Customers who stay with you the longest become your best advocates. They’re the ones referring their friends and family and leaving positive reviews. They help drive down your customer acquisition costs without you spending a dime. A loyal policyholder who’s been with us for years is worth far more than the premium they pay, because they’re actively helping to bring in the next customer.
This creates a compounding market effect. Strong retention leads to lower acquisition costs. That savings can be poured into acquiring and then retaining more customers. It’s a continuous cycle, but it only works if the bucket holds water. However, if you get your retention strategy wrong, you’re back to the leaky bucket scenario and endlessly refilling your customer base.
WHY CUSTOMER SERVICE IS A GROWTH STRATEGY
Many companies treat customer service as a cost to be minimized. This mindset is exactly how you end up with a leaky bucket.
Customer service directly influences retention. And retention drives net growth. The two shouldn’t be seen as separate objectives within the organization.
In insurance, the defining moment is the claim. When someone loses an engagement ring or has a watch stolen, how we respond determines whether they renew, refer, or leave. As a third-generation jeweler, I understand what that ring means to the person who owns it. We built BriteCo around treating those moments with the care they deserve, because a claim handled well is the cheapest, most durable retention tool.
If you’re not optimizing your customer service in moments that demand care, you’re effectively optimizing for churn, whether you admit it or not.
LOOK AT NET GROWTH, NOT NEW LOGOS
The metric to prioritize is net growth. The number you need to track is new customers minus churn. You can add 1,000 new customers this month but still go backward if you lose 1,200. Plenty of companies never look at it this way. Then they’re surprised when the growth they thought they had fails to materialize.
So, start with your churn rate first, and be honest about it. If you’re replacing customers every few months just to stand still, you have a problem with your business model, and no amount of spending on acquisition will fix it.
The goal should be to have a rock-solid foundation: a strong customer base with low churn that compounds year after year. This is the kind of business that’s worth building. It’s more profitable, more predictable, and a lot less stressful to run.
This week, calculate your real net growth. Then decide whether your next dollar belongs at the top of a leaky bucket or if it should be spent making sure the bucket holds.
Dustin Lemick is the founder and CEO of BriteCo.