Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

It’s time to fix the social contract

The social contract between worker and enterprise is broken and has been for some time.

[Images: Adobe Stock / Freedomz]

Profile photo of Miles Everson

CEO · MBO Partners

I’m just going to put this right on the table.

The social contract between worker and enterprise is broken and has been for some time.

The traditional work model, which persists in the face of solid forces reshaping how work looks, clings to the old ways—“old” as in back six or seven decades when employees stayed with one company throughout their career and got a gold watch and a pension at retirement. In those days, a person who “job hopped” every three or four years was highly suspect.

MONEY TALKS

The “contract” that kept employees in place back then was a sort of quid pro quo: defined benefits plans were the norm. Today, fewer than 4% of companies offer a similar structure, and yet the expectation of loyalty persists—despite ample data to the contrary.

Employees adhered to their part of the contract, knowing their employer would come through when the time came.

But things have changed. Now, companies offer fewer benefits and often don’t keep workers for their whole careers. People today know that switching jobs can help them move up faster in their careers.

LOYALTY IS A SMOKESCREEN

Loyalty. We keep using that word. With apologies to Inigo Montoya, I do not think it means what enterprises think it means.

Executive and senior management, along with the business media, spend a fair amount of time and ink on “employee loyalty.” How did we lose employee loyalty? What do we need to do to encourage loyalty?

Here’s the problem: It was never about loyalty. We’ve talked about employee loyalty for so long that we’ve forgotten that the bond that once existed between worker and employer was based on a social contract that offered real rewards to both parties.

It has always been about employee engagement, which hinges on the social contract. Companies achieved long-term engagement, which they misnamed loyalty, with their defined benefit plans, stock plans, and other money-driven incentives. When companies broke the contract out of economic necessity and didn’t replace it with a mutually beneficial one, employees were no longer motivated to be “loyal.”

The result? Job tenure today averages 4.1 years (less for young employees, per the BLS), and the term “quiet quitting” was coined to articulate the loss of engagement. For what it’s worth, I’m not a fan of the term as it places the weight on the worker’s shoulders, ignoring that the company is failing to create workplace conditions that spur motivation.

MONEY STILL TALKS, AND SO DOES FREEDOM

How can a company create loyalty in its workforce? Or, more accurately, how can a company create a new social contract that again offers real rewards? Workplace research, including our own, offers clear clues. Top issues that influence workers, both employees and independents, include: 

  • Fair pay
  • Work-life balance
  • Work flexibility
  • Freedom to do the work one loves, the way one wants

Interestingly, these are four areas where many companies fall short. The tradition of expecting workers to produce results beyond their job descriptions creates a shortfall in the income they receive, and impinges on their personal lives. Companies that successfully set up remote work routines during the pandemic now demand a return to the physical office.

ENTER THE INDEPENDENT WORKFORCE 

Disconnects like these have spurred the growth of the independent workforce. With companies failing to create a social contract that addresses such priorities, many workers have taken matters into their own hands by going independent.

Our own research shows that independents are generally happier and healthier than their employee counterparts, another reflection of the broken social contract (and the freedom that comes with the 72+ million Americans who have chosen this path). These people are happy to take on business ownership so that they have control over earnings, work environments, and time allocations.

The independent workforce has grown steadily over the past couple of decades and shows no signs of stopping. Enterprises are learning how to benefit from this trend, from competing successfully for high-value skills only available from independents to establishing an optimized workforce, a purposeful split of employees and independents focused on achieving strategic goals.

HERE’S TO A NEW SOCIAL CONTRACT

It’s time to stop bemoaning the loss of loyalty and clinging to the shreds of yesterday’s social contract. Let’s create a contract that fully engages the total workforce—employee and independent—by supporting worker priorities. It may mean revising expectations, changing policies and processes, and shifting the organizational structure—and it will be well worth it.


Miles Everson is CEO at MBO Partners, building the future of work by connecting top independent professionals and enterprises worldwide.