When it was time for me to take over the family business, my father didn’t just hand it to me, nor did he buy into the trial-by-fire strategy. Instead, he had me train under the interim CEO of the construction company he worked so hard to build. He believed it was his and other high-level executives’ responsibility to coach aspiring leaders, and it was my duty to earn my leadership position.
This careful and intentional succession planning was the key to my success. I didn’t always appreciate it at the time, but, looking back, I am grateful. My time training made me a better leader, allowed me to enhance my business savvy, and boosted my confidence. I believe this sort of succession planning can benefit every business.
Unfortunately, many companies put off the process of creating and investing in succession plans, underestimating the inevitable end to careers or the sometimes sudden need for replacements. This hesitation can cause companies to be reactive rather than proactive in their hiring processes. It can even result in CEOs staying in leadership roles for too long. According to Stanford’s Graduate School of Business, four out of 10 CEOs remain in their positions, despite years of bad returns, due to fear of change and poor succession planning.
Succession planning is not cheap, but failing to plan ahead can be more expensive. Replacing executives can cost businesses up to $1 trillion annually, and untrained external CEO successors face an 84% higher risk of poor performance and turnover. According to a Strategy& study, “CEOs who come in after a forced succession have shorter median tenures than those coming in after a planned succession”—which means companies are then required to hire again more quickly. Good succession planning can also support overall employee retention, an increasing issue in the era of the Great Resignation.
THE PATH TO PROPER SUCCESSION PLANNING
Proper succession planning requires time to build relationships, immerse new leaders in company culture, collectively determine strategic direction, and ensure business continuity. It’s an “all hands on deck” process that should involve everyone who will interact with the future CEO. I attribute my own company’s successful succession planning to my CEO predecessor, our CPA, attorneys, strategic advisors, our executive leadership team, and many others. Unfortunately, many companies leave succession planning solely to the existing CEO, putting the burden on busy leaders alone to find their replacement. This can contribute to a vicious cycle of hiring and resigning.
In contrast, my entrepreneurial training began as early as my teenage years. Instead of spending my summers hanging out with friends, my dad had me apprenticing with his colleagues. Working firsthand with tradespeople who believed in my potential contributed to my professional growth. While it’s not possible for every company to train future leaders this young, companies can see greater success by investing in future executives early, as my predecessors did with me.
It’s important to have young leaders with fresh and progressive ideas, but it’s also important to invest in the mentorship younger generations require to succeed. Too often, young founders fail when they’re thrust into the spotlight without adequate support. When I became CEO, I was only 30 years old, but I had received appropriate guidance for over a decade and had served a variety of key roles giving me the opportunity to learn the business from the ground up. This sort of training is vital for younger leaders. It’s also important for leaders from marginalized backgrounds who may be more likely to face barriers to success in the workplace.
THE GLASS CLIFF
The tide is slowly turning, but I am still among a mere 3.2% of Black CEOs. Succession planning can play a part in remedying this problem as well. There is an unfortunate pattern of companies extending opportunities to people of color hastily, without considering the support those future leaders may need. In these situations, minority leaders often find themselves falling off a “glass cliff”—as some have put it—rather than having adequate support to succeed.
The “glass cliff” theory posits that women, LGBTQ+, and BIPOC executives are often promoted during a company’s time of crisis and face almost inevitable failure. These sacrificial promotions are sometimes prompted by the company’s desire to impress stakeholders or manage public optics—often in the aftermath of bad press coverage. When these hires inevitably are perceived to have failed, companies sometimes double down on discriminatory hiring practices. This hurts everyone; research has shown that diverse leadership teams contribute to better business results by 60%.
IT’S TIME TO RETHINK SUCCESSION PLANNING
Rethinking succession planning should account for the way marginalized executives are often tokenized and set up to fail. Adequate, long-lasting, hands-on training should be provided to all future leaders, but especially those who may face racism, sexism, or homophobia in the workplace. In many ways, this means a shift away from hurrying to find the perfect company figurehead and toward prioritizing passionate, knowledgeable leaders with the potential to grow over time.
New technologies can also help streamline this process. Program management software can allow organizations to reduce hours spent on manual onboarding processes, and can open the door to a broader pool of trainees. These programs can increase profitability and productivity and ensure equal and equitable training, as well as remote access.
My father’s intent was always to prime his successors for long-term success. This redefining of legacy as sustainability has shaped our company’s succession plan and my own experience as CEO. As a VP prepping to advance, I observed, listened, and put in the work. I see my role as CEO as an example of why reforming leadership training is not only worth it, but easily achievable with the right mission and tools.
Apprenticeship, mentorship, and inclusion should be common vernacular in discussions about succession planning. When businesses plan to mentor rather than simply replace, they can set the building blocks for better long-term success—for the companies and for the people who lead them.
Larry Brinker Jr. is an award-winning entrepreneur, impact investor, and mentor. He serves as the Chief Executive Officer of Brinker Group.