For decades, just-in-time procurement was treated as a triumph of modern business. Inventory was minimized, capital was freed up, and global supply chains were optimized for speed and efficiency. If something was needed, it could be ordered. If prices moved, they could be hedged. If disruptions occurred, they were assumed to be temporary.
That model worked—until the energy transition exposed its limits.
The clean-energy economy was built on an assumption that proved dangerously optimistic: That critical commodities would always be available when needed, at predictable prices, through familiar market mechanisms. That assumption shaped everything from EV rollout timelines to grid-expansion plans to climate policy targets. And it was wrong.
The bottleneck in the energy transition isn’t technology. It’s materials.
The transition was planned like software, but runs on atoms
Digital thinking shaped the innovation culture over the past two decades. Software scales quickly. Capacity can be spun up on demand. Constraints are largely human or computational.
But the energy transition is not a software problem. It’s an industrial one.
Electric vehicles are powered by and run on lithium, nickel, copper, graphite, and rare earths. Wind turbines and transmission lines require enormous volumes of steel and copper. Solar panels depend on polysilicon, silver, and specialty metals. None of these materials is produced instantly, and most require years—often decades—of planning, permitting, financing, and construction.
Yet procurement strategies remained rooted in a world treating materials as commodities in the narrowest sense as interchangeable, liquid, and always available.
Just-in-time procurement and resilience
Just-in-time procurement depended upon a stable, globalized world with excess capacity and limited geopolitical friction. It assumed:
- Open trade flows
- Predictable supply growth
- Short lead times
- Minimal political interference
None of those conditions exists reliably today.
Critical mineral supply chains are increasingly shaped by geopolitics, export controls, resource nationalism, and domestic industrial policy. Processing capacity is concentrated in a handful of jurisdictions. Permitting timelines are lengthening, not shortening. Capital markets have underinvested in upstream supply for years.
The result was a structural mismatch: Demand curves driven by aggressive decarbonization targets collided with supply curves that simply couldn’t respond fast enough.
Procurement teams optimized for price volatility are now confronting availability risk—and those are very different problems.
The real innovation gap in materials plans
When clean-tech projects stall, we might reflexively blame execution, regulation, or financing. More rarely, companies step back and ask a more fundamental question: Did we ever have a realistic plan for securing the materials we need?
In many cases, the answer is no.
Materials planning gets treated as a downstream function, as something procurement handles after setting a product roadmap. But in an energy-constrained world, access to materials isn’t an input; it’s a strategic variable.
Forward-looking companies are beginning to recognize this shift and do the following:
- Engage earlier with suppliers and producers
- Lock in long-term supply agreements
- Take equity stakes in upstream projects
- Treat materials access as a competitive advantage
This is not about hoarding or speculation. It’s about acknowledging that physical supply chains cannot be managed with the same assumptions as digital ones.
Clean tech’s awkward truth
One of energy transition’s uncomfortable realities is that generating demand is easier than building supply.
Policy incentives, subsidies, and consumer enthusiasm accelerate adoption, but mining projects, refineries, and infrastructure expansions move at the pace of geology, engineering, and permitting—not venture capital timelines.
A false sense of progress arises, and while ambitious targets look achievable on paper, the underlying material foundations lag far behind. The transition becomes slower, more expensive, and more uneven than expected, undermining public confidence and political support along the way.
What leaders must rethink
A clear lesson for founders, operators, and manufacturing leaders is that procurement cannot be an afterthought.
Key questions need to move upstream:
- Which materials are truly critical to our product or system?
- Where does supply come from, and who controls it?
- What happens if availability, not price, becomes the constraint?
- How early do we need to engage in the supply chain to de-risk execution?
These questions can’t be entirely delegated to purchasing departments. They require coordination between strategy, finance, operations, and—increasingly—policy.
From efficiency to control
The next phase of the energy transition favors companies that optimize not just for efficiency but also for control.
That doesn’t mean abandoning markets or global trade. It means recognizing that resilience has value and that access to materials is becoming a defining competitive advantage.
Just-in-time procurement wasn’t a failure of intelligence or intent, simply a product of a different era. But the world has changed, and the energy transition is forcing a long-overdue reckoning with physical reality.
In the race to decarbonize, the winners may have the best technology, but also those who understood early enough that the future still runs on materials—and planned accordingly.
Anthony Milewski is the founder of The Oregon Group.