Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Kick our baby, kindly: A guide to working with creatives

Creatives are an interesting bunch. We see the world differently—sometimes sideways, often upside-down. But this is our superpower!

Kick our baby, kindly

[loreanto / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Shannon Lee

“So that is the creative process. You start with a problem, forget the problem, the problem reveals itself or the solution reveals itself, and then you re-evaluate it. This is what you are doing all the time.” —Paul Rand

Creatives are an interesting bunch. We see the world differently—sometimes sideways, often upside-down. But this is our superpower! We’re the ones making connections that sometimes actually make sense. We’re problem-solvers who don’t just “think outside the box”—we don’t even see the box. We’re too busy turning it into an art installation.

Here’s a myth we need to clear up: We’re not just wandering around staring at clouds all day. Creatives thrive on purpose. We want to solve problems, make an impact, and—maybe—blow your mind. 

HOW CREATIVES WORK: FROM CHAOTIC THOUGHTS TO VOILA!

Creatives don’t have a magic tap to turn ideas on and off. Our process is a bit more… involved:

1. Understanding the problem: We start by digging deep. We’re like brand detectives, learning about your business, your goals, and the challenges we’re trying to solve.

2. Solo time: After initial discussions, we need time to let ideas marinate (read: daydream and refresh Slack). Eventually, ideas start forming, and we’re ready to share them.

3. The reveal (not to be confused with perfection): When we present our first draft, think of it as our precious (but rough) baby. Sure, it might be a little… weird. But it’s ready to be kicked around. That’s right—give it to us straight. We creatives thrive on critique. Like an art school critique, feedback isn’t personal—it’s a tool. And the more honest you are, the better the outcome will be.

GOOD, FAST, CHEAP: YOU CAN PICK TWO (NO, REALLY)

If I could attach a PSA to every creative brief, it would say this: Quality creative work takes time, money, or ideally, both. There’s a classic Venn diagram showing “good,” “fast,” and “cheap.” After 20+ years, I have yet to meet the mythical unicorn project that can be all three.

So if you’re asking, my advice is to prioritize good. Go for quality first, then see if we can tweak speed and cost. Creatives want your work to be as amazing as you do, but when pressured to go fast and cheap, the results end up… not great. Let us focus on the magic while account and project managers handle the rest (we love them for it).

THE KEY INGREDIENTS FOR CREATIVE SUCCESS

Creating strong work isn’t about pulling rabbits out of hats; it’s about having the right setup:

  • A clear, strong creative brief: With a focused brief, we know what success looks like. It saves time, energy, and rounds of revisions.
  • A great project manager: Creative minds tend to wander. A good project manager keeps us on track without stifling creativity.
  • Invested partners: We do our best work with clients and team members who are as committed as we are.
  • Clear goals: Fuzzy objectives lead to fuzzy work. Clear goals keep us aligned and inspired.

HOW TO GIVE FEEDBACK WITHOUT UNLEASHING THE DRAMA LLAMA

“Giving honest and well-intended feedback is often confused with being mean. It’s not mean; it’s nice.” —Robert Kiyosaki

Let’s talk feedback. Creatives may seem like we have thick skin, but there’s a way to give feedback that’s actually helpful. Here’s a quick guide for giving constructive feedback:

  • Start positive: Creatives need a little love to soften the blow, so start with a compliment.
  • Be honest and specific: We’re cool with criticism, but specifics matter. “This part feels off because…” is more helpful than “I just don’t like it.”
  • Stay in your lane: If you’re not a designer, try not to reimagine the layout. Comment on the content instead.
  • Focus on the work, not the person: Frame feedback around the work, not around the person, and keep the project goals in focus. “The design isn’t working because…” is better than, “You don’t understand our brand.”

THE CREATIVE “SAFE, EXTRA, BEYOND” STRATEGY

Here’s the thing about creatives: We love pushing boundaries, but we also know how to give you options. That’s why I recommend the “Safe, Extra, Beyond” approach when reviewing creative ideas:

  1. Safe: Think Ritz crackers and American cheese—solid, dependable, and budget-friendly.
  2. Extra: A little twist. Imagine gourmet crackers with brie and fig jam—a slight upgrade and a bit more flavor.
  3. Beyond: A charcuterie board overflowing with fine cheeses, crackers, fruits, and nuts. It’s edgy, indulgent, and sure to impress.

Most of the time, we’ll guide you to the “Extra” zone. But if you’re feeling bold and want to make a splash, we’re here to help you take the plunge.

A STORY OF CREATIVE RESILIENCE

During the 2020 lockdown, our team of 20 creatives—writers, designers, and video producers—found ourselves in a strange new world of remote work and isolation. Business slowed, morale was low, and uncertainty was everywhere. As a team, we needed purpose, connection, and, frankly, a little creative therapy.

So we created “In This Moment, I Am ____,” an interactive project where anyone could finish the sentence, “In this moment, I am ____.” Each response was transformed into a unique visual “card” by one of our designers, and the project grew from there.

Families, friends, and clients alike contributed, creating a communal space for expression and connection. Cards were added to the landing page each day, creating a visual timeline of the world’s feelings each week. Each card could be downloaded and shared on social networks.

This project became our creative lifeline, reminding us that our work wasn’t just about deadlines and KPIs. It was about using our talents to connect, uplift, and inspire. That’s why creatives do what we do—and why, when you support the creative process, the results can be truly impactful.

KICK OUR BABY, KINDLY

So the next time you’re working with creatives, remember: We’re here to bring your vision to life, and we’re in this together. Your honest feedback is crucial to making the work matter, so just be sure to kick our baby kindly—and show it some love in the end.