You probably know someone like Peter. Christened a “hi po” early in his career, he moved up the corporate ladder quickly, gaining the reputation of a leader who consistently solves complex problems and gets things done. After being promoted to an executive-level position, he was surprised by some tough feedback during his performance review: “You make several of your direct reports uncomfortable. They want off your team.” Peter was stunned. Since he was five years old, people have praised him for his charm and people skills. What happened? As Peter’s responsibilities had grown, he also found himself missing deadlines, appearing disorganized in executive team meetings, and getting into arguments with his peers.
His CEO sent Peter to a few classes: communication training, conflict resolution, and management skills. While he enjoyed the learning opportunities, the concepts didn’t stick. Peter committed to changing his behavior at the conclusion of each class, but would revert to old habits as soon as he was back on the job and under the least bit of pressure.
After failing to observe any significant change in Peter’s behavior, the CEO takes a different approach. He tells Peter that he considers him such a valuable leader that he is willing to invest in an executive coach to work with him. Peter is ambivalent and a bit uneasy about the offer. How will a coach help when the training courses didn’t? Is my reputation irreparably damaged within this company? Should I start looking for another job? Or should I take the CEO for his word and consider this an investment in me, like how a pro athlete works with a personal trainer?
Peter isn’t sure of the answers and is feeling uncomfortable, but he jumps into his coaching engagement with both feet, hoping to remove the tarnish from his previously stellar reputation.
This scenario describes a common experience facing many executives across countless industries, jobs, and countries. A leader is promoted because they have a particular skill, are charismatic, or can make things happen in their organization. And that is enough until their job grows so big that they can no longer keep underdeveloped areas hidden.
Coaching is big business, and it’s growing. A global study by the International Coaching Federation, a leading coach credentialing organization, estimated the number of coaching practitioners at 71,000 in 2019, a 33% increase from their 2015 estimate. The same study estimated the global revenue for coaching services at $2.849 billion.
Not all coaching programs are created equal. What difference-makers should you look for in a coach or a coaching program? What makes for a truly transformative executive coaching experience?
For the past three years, my team and I have deployed an annual leadership coaching effectiveness survey to leaders who have been part of a coaching program aimed to answer this question. Here is what we have learned.
First, coaching consistently improves leader performance. Specifically, with an average of 95% agreement over three years of data, leaders who have completed their coaching assignment report, “As a result of my leadership coaching, I am better equipped to utilize new behaviors required of me at work.”
But why is this?
After analyzing the data, we postulate that meaningful behavior change after executive coaching is correlated with improved leader confidence. In our study, an extraordinary 94% of leaders report that their overall confidence as a leader improved due to leadership coaching. When you believe you can, you can and you do.
The coaching process, grounded in regular coaching sessions using a cognitive behavioral learning process, allows coaches to tap into what makes the coachee unique and powerful as a leader. Coaches help leaders locate and reconnect with their authentic self and their unique gifts—and determine how to best use them within their company culture and the real-world challenges in their job. They can point the leader to tools and methods that enable them to master skills that don’t come as naturally. They encourage the leader to use their style and approach to create the inner change needed to sustain external behaviors. They assure the leader that they are “good enough” to succeed.
Another attention-grabbing statistic from this study is 81% of coachees reported that their overall well-being (stress, health, focus, and burnout) improved due to leadership coaching. With leader burnout rates continuing to climb and well-being challenges plaguing the workplaces, this coaching benefit should not be overlooked.
When a leader takes time to work with a coach to better understand and appreciate their gifts, they are provided with the opportunity to slow down and look at their work with a fresh set of eyes. When they have the time and headspace to create and follow through on new behaviors that get them excellent results, their well-being improves.
This leads me to the last important finding that deserves attention: seven out of 10 coachees report that coaching positively impacted their desire to stay with their organization. In our extremely tight labor market, organizations need to use all available tools to retain their top talent. When considering the value of high-potential leaders, it’s hard to ignore the cost/benefit of this important talent development tool.
I suspect you may have one or more Peters in your organization who would similarly benefit from removing barriers to performance, improving their confidence and well-being, and cementing their desire to stay with your company. To get there, consider utilizing leadership coaching.
Steve Dion is Founder and CEO of Dion Leadership, a leadership and organization development firm that builds strong leaders and cultures.