Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Leading through crisis in the boardroom

A crisis reveals what boards are really made of, and the first 48 hours define the outcome.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of maria-fernanda-cala-luque

I had been an outside board director for a company for nearly two years. I knew the CEO and CFO well and was often around the leadership team. But the first time a real crisis hit, we quickly learned more about the CEO and their team. In fact, it only took 48 hours to really see what leadership the company had.

It was 2008. Markets were collapsing. The company had 72 hours before violating a debt covenant that would trigger default and potential bankruptcy. The CEO was frozen. Two investor board members wanted his head. Another advocated immediate Chapter 11 from a legal standpoint. From my perspective, the CFO was updating her résumé.

I was watching what I’d later recognize as a “leadership vacuum.” The dangerous moment when everyone’s talking but nobody’s leading. That’s when I discovered crisis leadership in the boardroom isn’t about having answers. It’s about creating conditions where the right answers can emerge before time runs out. 

THE BOARDS’ UNIQUE CHALLENGE

Boards don’t manage operations. Management does. But in a crisis, the line between governance and management blurs fast. You’re not there to run the company—but you’re also not there to be passive while it sinks.

The failure mode I see most: boards either micromanage, stepping into operational details because they’re panicking, or they’re too hands-off, treating the crisis as “management’s problem.”

Think of yourself as a Formula 1 race strategist, not the driver. When conditions change—sudden rain, safety car, or tire degradation—the strategist doesn’t grab the wheel. But they make critical timing calls, provide data the driver can’t see, and keep the bigger picture in focus when adrenaline narrows vision. That’s the board’s role in crisis: strategic clarity when everyone else is in operational chaos.

THE FIRST 48 HOURS FRAMEWORK

In that 2008 crisis, we had 72 hours. Here’s what I learned about the critical first 48: You’ll be drowning in information—most of it useless or wrong.

Asking these three questions can cut through chaos:

  • What do we know for certain right now?
  • What decisions must be made in the next 24/48/72 hours?
  • Who specifically is making each decision, and what do they need from this board?

Those questions changed everything. Within 30 minutes, we’d identified two paths: renegotiating the covenant or finding bridge financing. The CEO owned the bank negotiation. The CFO owned bridge financing. The board opened our networks for both.

We divided—half working banking relationships, half working investor networks. Eighteen hours later, we had three bridge financing options and a bank willing to renegotiate. Now, they were not all ideal, but we had thwarted a major crisis and had optionality. But none of that happens if the board or leadership team members spend hours debating who is to blame. Accountability comes later. In a crisis, ruthlessly prioritize action over analysis.

HOW TO MANAGE FEAR IN THE ROOM

Nobody admits this: directors get scared in a crisis. They get scared of lawsuits, reputational damage, and being on the board when it fails. This fear drives terrible decisions.

I’ve watched board members push conservative moves that guarantee slow death because they’re more worried about being blamed than being bold. Fear turns boards into circular firing squads. And remember, most boards have more investors than operators.

In one crisis when I was the CEO, I said: “Everyone in this room is scared to some extent. I’m scared too. You’re scared. That’s rational and logical. But if we let fear drive decisions, we’ll make conservative choices that feel safe but guarantee mediocrity. Let’s acknowledge the fear and set it aside while we focus on what gives this company the best chance.”

Sounds simple, but it changed the room.

THE COMMUNICATION PROTOCOL

Biggest mistake: communication chaos. In one situation, board members were independently calling the CEO, CFO, and each other at all hours. Everyone was asking for updates and offering opinions, but nobody was coordinating. The CEO spent more time managing board communication than managing the crisis.

Having sat in her seat before, I suggested we implement a single board member as the primary contact with management, so we could let them operate. Everyone else went through them. Updates went out on a fixed schedule. The full board met daily throughout the crisis, with ad hoc communication when necessary.

This gave management space to work and ensured information flowed consistently to all directors. This approach eliminated unnecessary tension because it removed information asymmetry.

THE DECISION-MAKING FRAMEWORK

The most critical thing: clarify the decision-making protocols. What decisions does management own? What requires board approval? In stable times, these lines are clear. In crisis, they blur instantly—but that’s OK.

My framework: if it’s reversible and operational, management decides and informs. If it’s irreversible and strategic—selling assets, major layoffs, changing the business model—the board approves. If it’s in between, management proposes, and the board has 24 hours to object or approve. Speed matters in crisis. Clarity on decision-making creates speed.

4 STRATEGIES TO MANAGE YOUR CRISIS

I hope you never have a crisis in your boardroom, but if you do, I would like to leave you with these four takeaways.

1. Create a board crisis protocol now, before you need it: document decision-making, communication channels, and meeting frequency for different scenarios. Don’t wait for chaos.

2. Run a crisis simulation annually. Give your board and management a hypothetical crisis and 90 minutes to respond. You’ll learn more in that simulation than in 10 normal meetings.

3. Build your external crisis network now. Who can you call for money issues? Legal advice? PR counsel? Have those relationships before you need them.

4. Document lessons from every crisis in a living playbook. What worked? What didn’t? Update after each event so institutional knowledge doesn’t walk out when directors turn over.

Crisis leadership in the boardroom isn’t being the hero or the scapegoat. It’s creating the framework that allows the right people to make the right decisions fast enough to matter. Build that framework now, because when a crisis hits, you won’t have time.

Brendan Keegan is chairman and CEO of bFEARLESS Ventures.