Today’s additive manufacturing industry is leaps and bounds from where it started. In the early to mid-1990s, the industry was called the “rapid prototyping industry,” and there were only a handful of companies developing 3D printers that could be used for engineering and design verification. These systems were expensive—well over $100,000 each—so service bureaus were formed to offer rapid prototyping (RP) services to those who needed to access the equipment. Larger companies also purchased printers to operate in centralized locations.
Even with limited access, the systems created opportunities for engineers and product designers who needed to make prototypes faster and cheaper than traditional manufacturing methods, such as molding, machining or carving out of foam, would allow. The RP systems offered flexibility and created new ways to develop products. It was a disruption.
I was fortunate to be part of a wave of companies that came along in the late 1990s to offer less expensive, easier-to-use versions of the RP systems. Although parts were generally not as good as those made on the first RP systems, the machines were less expensive, roughly half the cost of their predecessors, and easier to operate. And this is when we first started to use the term “3D printer.”
The more affordable 3D printers created access to easier ways of prototyping. Schools and universities could purchase their own printers for students to use, and smaller companies were able to take advantage of the new technology, too. The number of machines sold across the industry moved from the hundreds to the thousands. This was the second disruption.
Fast forward to the early 2010s when the first desktop machines came to market. These printers were high-ticket items for general consumers, but considerably less than the 3D printers of the ‘90s. Parts were also of considerably lesser quality. This third disruption was perhaps the most well-known to those outside of the industry, with mainstream media dubbing 3D printing a game-changing technology. Many theorized that every household would own a 3D printer, ultimately giving manufacturing power to consumers on everyday items like dishes and screws, but it never lived up to the hype. Since then, we’ve seen further disruption in the desktop market with more material availability and technology that could create higher quality parts.
Disruption happens when either new technologies or services come along that offer the same capabilities at a lower price, better capabilities than the status quo, or a combination of both. In the prototyping industry, we’ve seen three decades of disruption that have impacted product design for both large and small parts across industries, such as aerospace, automotive, consumer goods and medical devices.
Today, the prototyping industry is moving to disrupt the manufacturing industry by moving into production, which is arguably more difficult as end parts require precision and accuracy that wasn’t a necessity in prototyping. Depending on their industry, engineers may also have to consider regulatory or quality guidelines for end parts, and cost per part is a consideration in almost every decision. New materials, enhanced computer processing power, software and advanced systems have all contributed to some penetration into manufacturing applications.
Disruption cycles are often bumpy—the industry may take a big step forward, but followed by a few steps back. It is common to have many new companies trying to push the envelope. Some will emerge as winners, but others will fall short. However, one big net effect is that the technologies and capabilities are collectively improving, in some cases, in very disruptive ways.
It’s been a bumpy journey in additive manufacturing. Many new companies have formed in the past decade alone, and there have been tremendous advancements in technology. However, to be commercially successful, companies need to have a technology or service that customers value and want to buy, and they need to have a business model that will allow for profitable growth.
It is not always obvious when these disruptive cycles are happening, but it is often during times of transition and tumult. Today, it feels like we’re on the brink of disruption and it’s critically important to recognize and celebrate the forward movement. While disruption may be difficult to navigate, it’s important to recognize that it will be impactful and gratifying for all those involved.