Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Marketing has a self-inflicted trust problem

How to remedy the issue.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Maria Alonso

Head of Account Management · Fortune 206

For years, marketers chased a promise of more data, more precision, and more personalization. The simple idea was that if we knew enough about people, we could deliver exactly the right message at the right moment. In theory, it built relevance. In practice, it’s had the opposite effect.

Today, marketing has a trust problem. Consumers are more skeptical, more guarded, and more willing to disengage than ever before. It’s not because they don’t like brands. It’s because too many brands have confused access with intimacy and optimization with understanding.

Most Americans are concerned about how companies use their data, and 67% admit they understand little to nothing about what’s happening behind the scenes, highlighting a growing gap between personalization and trust.

The result? Campaigns that are technically impressive but emotionally hollow.

Personalization stopped feeling personal

Personalization used to feel thoughtful. A well-timed email. A recommendation that made sense. A message that acknowledged context. Somewhere along the way, it became intrusive.

Consumers now routinely ask, “How do they know that?” And not in a good way. Think about browsing a product once, like a pair of shoes, and then seeing that product follow you across every platform, from Instagram to news sites, within minutes.

Data collection outpaced transparency, and automation replaced empathy. We’ve optimized for clicks, opens, and conversions while eroding something far more valuable: credibility.

Marketing teams didn’t set out to break trust. But systems incentivized scale over substance. Dashboards rewarded efficiency, not resonance. And storytelling—the one thing that builds connection—was often treated as window dressing rather than strategy.

The performance trap

Performance marketing isn’t the enemy. But when every decision is filtered through short-term metrics, brands start making tradeoffs they don’t see until it’s too late. Think about how airline loyalty programs constantly push upgrades and credit card offers that feel more transactional than rewarding. What looks like performance on a dashboard often comes at the cost of trust in the real world.

Here’s what that looks like:

  • Messages that feel urgent but say nothing meaningful
  • Campaigns that follow trends without understanding culture
  • Brands speaking at communities instead of with them

A clear example of this dynamic appeared in Pepsi’s Kendall Jenner campaign. The ad attempted to tap into the imagery of social justice movements but lacked genuine cultural understanding. The backlash was immediate, and the campaign was pulled within 24 hours. What looked culturally relevant on paper ultimately failed because it prioritized trend alignment over real insight.

Marketing loses its center when the goal is performance instead of outcome. People feel targeted, not valued. Seen, but not understood. And once trust erodes, no amount of optimization can buy it back cheaply.

How trust is built

Trust is built on the stories told, who tells them, and which voices are entirely missing.

Patagonia offers a powerful example. In 2011, on Black Friday, a day defined by urgency and consumption, the brand ran its now iconic “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign. Instead of pushing more sales, it asked consumers to pause and consider the environmental cost of what they were buying, encouraging them to repair rather than replace.

That decision did more than capture attention. It showed a willingness to prioritize values over immediate revenue. The result was stronger credibility and deeper loyalty among customers who saw that the brand’s actions matched its message.

 Trust means asking harder questions:

  • Are we representing real experiences or just aspirational ones?
  • Are we simplifying stories to make them marketable?
  • Are we listening to feedback or just tracking engagement?

Storytelling still works

Too often, stories are reverse-engineered to fit a campaign instead of emerging from real insight. When that happens, audiences can tell. Authenticity isn’t a tone—it’s a process.

One example is Dove’s “Real Beauty” campaign. Instead of idealized imagery, Dove centered real women and real stories, challenging industry norms and building long-term trust through consistency.

When rooted in real values rather than performance metrics, storytelling creates alignment. And alignment is what makes a message last.

Real storytelling starts upstream with:

  • Teams that reflect the communities they serve
  • Space for nuance, not just punchlines
  • Patience to let impact speak before promotion

Brands that get this right steward stories, understanding that credibility compounds over time, while gimmicks expire quickly.

The changed role of marketers

Marketers act as translators between organizations and their target audiences, a role that comes with responsibility.

It means pushing back when a message feels misaligned, advocating for clarity over cleverness, and recognizing that trust is a long game built through consistency, honesty, and respect.

This shift requires leadership, not just creativity. The strongest marketing leaders today aren’t asking, “Will this perform?” They’re asking, “Will this hold up?”

Rebuilt trust

Rebuilding trust requires re-centering marketing on fewer, better-thought-through campaigns and on metrics that value retention and loyalty beyond acquisition. Communications acknowledge uncertainty instead of pretending perfection

For example, Duolingo’s social media strategy built a distinctive personality on platforms like TikTok through humor, storytelling, and community engagement. Duolingo prioritized cultural relevance and entertainment over constant conversion.

A different approach is evident with Airbnb, where campaigns like “Made Possible by Hosts” shifted the narrative from product to people, reinforcing trust by showing the platform’s human side. Both examples point to the same principle. Trust gets built through consistency, relevance, and a clear sense of who the brand is in the world.

It also means accepting that not every message needs to convert. Some messages exist to reassure, to explain, or simply to show up consistently. Those moments matter more than most dashboards can measure.

The future belongs to credible brands

In a crowded market, trust is the real differentiator. Not personalization, technology, or even creativity on its own.

Enduring brands treat people as participants, not data points. These brands understand marketing isn’t about extraction. It’s about exchange. Because when trust is present, people lean in. And when it’s gone, no amount of targeting can pull them back.

Maria Alonso is the head of account management at Fortune 206.