Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

My horrible bosses were a gift

When somebody notices what I'm doing and lets me know that they appreciate my leadership, I just say to them, "Thanks! I learned from the worst."

Stressed employee

[Images: Donson/peopleimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Scott Menter

The admirable person learns from their mistakes; the truly great person learns from the mistakes of others.

You’ve no doubt heard some variation of that adage from a parent or boss, probably delivered in a manner you found incredibly annoying. Still, it’s a hard principle to deny: If the dude marching ahead of you trips on a rock, you can expect little sympathy from onlookers if you then proceed to trip on the same rock.

I spent a chunk of my early career on Wall Street. Trading is a zero-sum business—I can only profit by your loss—and corporate leaders viewed everything through that lens. Employees, too; there was a fund for year-end bonuses, and it was widely accepted that the amount was fixed, so a dollar earned by you as a bonus came from the pockets of everybody else in the pool.

If you’ve read Michael Lewis’ awesome memoir of his work in an investment bank, then you have some idea of the weird—and ultimately, unsustainable—management culture that existed back then. And I was part of it. Worse, I was very young, just learning what it meant to be a boss. At 27, I had roughly forty employees and a capital budget of something like $25 million (keep in mind that back then, $25 million was real money!).

I’d hate to admit how long it took me to figure out that the people I worked for were not model managers, but rather the opposite. In my defense, their bad management didn’t seem ineffective, in the sense that the firm was virtually printing money. People around me were getting rich; who was I to say they were doing it wrong?

That 100-plus-year-old white-shoe (or is it blue chip?) firm failed in the 2000-aughts—and it’s widely agreed today that it was killed by poor management. Here are some examples from my time at the company, illustrating why I didn’t find that surprising:

  • The CIO held an all-hands meeting in which he strongly encouraged people to raise issues that concerned them. I did that, only to find myself on the receiving end of my boss’ tantrum the next day—not for what I’d asked, but rather because I’d asked.
  • Sexist and antisemitic language was everywhere; indeed, the atmosphere was often generally misanthropic. I was once in a meeting in which my boss referred to workers doing low-level tasks as “monkeys” (to my happy surprise, he was immediately chastened by one of the senior leaders in attendance).
  • I was made a manager (for the first time) after having been provided with no training whatsoever. Within weeks, one of my employees was already threatening to quit. (I’m convinced that if I end up in the Bad Place after I die, my punishment will be that I have to work for my 27-year-old self.)
  • Do I need to remind you that they gave a 27-year-old a staff of 40 and $25 million to play with?

Once I’d matured a bit as a leader, I came to understand that my bosses were not superheroes, but rather evil overlords. I committed myself to learning from their mistakes. I worked out that the best way to make your employees feel like you care about them is to actually, you know, care about them. And it seemed obvious, once I noticed it, that a zero-sum approach was not only ineffective, but counterproductive. Why invite the headache of the everybody-versus-everybody mindset, when you could instead be coaching teams of people who want to work together—and are more successful for it?

I’ve been managing for many, many years at this point. I do so according to my values—some of which I developed in the wake of experiencing their polar opposite. Sometimes—on an especially good day—somebody notices what I’m doing and lets me know that they appreciate my leadership. I just say to them, “Thanks! I learned from the worst.”


E. Scott Menter is a writer, entrepreneur, and COO at Infocap • Living at the intersection of AI and Intelligent Process Automation