In late June 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court nullified a 40-year-old legal doctrine called Chevron deference. The “Chevron deference” doctrine was based on a June 1984 SCOTUS ruling, Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council. It required lower courts to let federal agencies interpret in detail what laws meant. Generally, Congress or state legislatures pass laws, but these are often general statements of intent and do not necessarily mention implementing detailed rules and regulations.
So as of June 2024, SCOTUS has reverted the interpretation of ambiguous laws that affect businesses back to the courts and away from federal agencies such as the SEC, EPA, and others.
Personally, I have mixed feelings about this ruling. Federal agencies have many experts who are likely more technically equipped than courts to handle the nuances of laws in fields such as public safety, health care, environment, finance, and commerce. However, these agencies are often led by appointees of the incumbent administration who need to advance its agenda, unless they have an independent mandate, like the Federal Reserve.
EXPANDING FEDERAL POWER
Because of Chevron deference, the past four decades have seen federal agencies expand in scope and power, increasing the number of regulations businesses need to comply with, such as DEI and ESG. In court, the two parties (e.g., U.S. federal government vs. industry/companies) are generally viewed as equal by an unbiased jury and judge, even if it is a David business versus the Goliath U.S. government. However, a federal agency, if given the right to interpret the law to its advantage, acts as both plaintiff and judge, creating inherent bias.
For example, during the Biden administration, the SEC has brought various lawsuits against crypto entities such as Ripple, Binance, and Coinbase, unilaterally determining if tokens are commodities (outside the SEC’s scope) or securities (within the SEC’s scope). While some cases, like aspects of the Binance lawsuit, had merit, others seemed capricious and arbitrary. The SEC has lost several high-profile lawsuits, particularly against Ripple, and Congress has criticized it for “regulation by enforcement.” The SCOTUS Chevron deference decision highlights many instances of federal agency overreach across various industries and sectors.
On the other hand, courts, as part of the independent Judiciary, are expected to render fair and impartial decisions based on the evidence and arguments presented. However, their technical expertise in specific regulatory issues is a different question altogether.
BUSINESS AND OVERREGULATION
For business, which is often challenging enough, it becomes even harder when there are too many regulations that need to be complied with. There are added expenditures, additional hiring to comply with non-core rules, and additional compliance documents and requirements that really have nothing to do with the core business.
If a company is involved in making donuts, tires, airplanes, cars, or other products, they should have more employees to do those jobs on a permanent basis, rather than required permanent DEI specialists, tort lawyers, gender specialists, or the like.
WHERE DOES AMERICAN BUSINESS GO FROM HERE?
The Supreme Court’s decision to nullify Chevron deference marks a pivotal shift, reducing the regulatory power of federal agencies and returning interpretative authority to the courts. While this change can help enhance American business competitiveness by allowing companies to focus on core operations rather than excessive compliance, I believe there are instances where courts still need expert advice and opinions from federal agencies or technical experts.
This ruling could lead to a more competitive American industry, especially against countries like China, whose homegrown giants want to compete but are not hobbled by the kinds of regulations American businesses have seen in the past few decades.
Business leaders must stay informed and adaptable in this evolving legal landscape. Large corporations can leverage substantial legal resources, but smaller firms should seek support from industry associations to navigate this new regulatory environment effectively.