Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Net Promoter Scores are dead—here’s a better way to understand what your customers think

NPS has fundamental limitations. There are now better ways to learn what your customers really think.

[Adobe Stock / Supatman]

Profile photo of John Mazur

CEO · Chatmeter

For years, marketers have relied on the Net Promoter Score (NPS) as the gold standard for measuring customer sentiment. But in recent years, as many brands have grown increasingly disconnected from their audiences (recent data from Forrester shows U.S. customer experience quality declined for three years in a row), it’s time to question whether NPS is still fit for its purpose. 

Today, AI-powered tools have unlocked far richer sources of customer intelligence, providing marketers with a more nuanced understanding of what customers want and need. There are now better ways to learn what your customers really think.

NPS has fundamental limitations. It relies on customers to actively self-report through a single question about referral likelihood, a process that’s unnatural and incomplete. NPS offers little nuance: It doesn’t segment by customer type or diagnose specific business strengths and weaknesses. Think of the last time a doctor asked you to rate your pain on a numerical scale—quantifying feelings is tricky.

So why are we asking customers to do so?

LISTEN TO THE STORY INSTEAD OF WATCHING THE SCORE

Traditional NPS surveys require customers to pause their day and quantify their experience. Few enjoy that chore. 

Meanwhile, customers enthusiastically share their experiences on Google Reviews and social media—channels chock full of authentic, unprompted feedback. Millions of these conversations happen every day online, yielding actionable insights and nuance that an NPS survey cannot deliver. This matters: A vast majority of peopleread reviews before making a new purchase.

Instead of relying only on solicited feedback, brands should tap into this enormous pool of unstructured data to build holistic customer intelligence. This approach enables real-time insights, especially for multi-location operations managing hundreds or thousands of stores. 

Of course, sifting through the sea of customer chatter is no small feat (the web contains trillions of gigabytes of data, and big brands can easily garner hundreds of thousands of reviews). Fortunately, modern technology like natural language processing and AI can make this more feasible by surfacing trends and cutting through the noise quickly.

STOP TREATING ALL CUSTOMERS LIKE THEY’RE THE SAME

NPS forces customers into broad categories by masking the diversity of motivations that drive their behavior. According to St. John’s University marketing professor Timothy Keiningham, NPS scores have “almost no relationship to how people divide their spending.” 

A customer who gives you a 9 may be passionate but sees your product as too expensive to recommend widely; a 6 might signal a critical but loyal advocate. NPS flattens these distinctions, leading to strategies that ignore real customer needs.

Unstructured feedback from online reviews, social media, and open-ended survey response questions can provide more authentic, contextual insights that allow you to better understand individual preferences, spending intentions, and aspirations.

FOCUS ON WHAT DRIVES CUSTOMER BEHAVIOR

Chasing a higher NPS can distract brands from core improvements that would improve loyalty and satisfaction. A single score reveals little; actual comments and reviews reveal a lot. Customers are often explicit about what works and what doesn’t in their online comments. That information leads their peers to make better-informed decisions. 

Brands that more actively listen can turn critical commentary into positive action. For example, when Rivian dropped its signature owl hoot car locking sound, candid feedback on Reddit led them to restore it. Dutch Bros recently launched new drive-through order preparation procedures to address feedback about its long wait times. Sephora recently moved its beauty stations away from store windows to give customers more privacy when trying out make-up. All of these changes stem from nuanced insights you’d never get from NPS. 

Reputation management isn’t about chasing a number. It’s about engaging in ongoing dialogue everywhere your customers are. NPS is an artifact of an era where feedback was rare and linear. Now, brands must harness vast streams of organic, unstructured feedback and transform those insights into action.  

A recent Accenture study found that 64% of consumers wish companies would respond faster to their changing needs. Brands listening in real time are best positioned to meet these demands and drive long-term growth. 

John Mazur is CEO of Chatmeter, a leader in multi-location customer intelligence.