Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Nowstalgia: The smartest brands are building for memory

AI can simulate the future, but it can't feel the past.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw

CEO & Communicator-in-Chief · First and Last PR

Surprise! Your marketing budget is probably funding its own irrelevance.

While 77% of senior marketing decision-makers are shifting spend toward AI-generated images and content, consumers are moving in the opposite direction. A recent study found that just 7% of consumers share that AI-generated marketing leads to them trusting a brand more while 31% share that it actually makes them trust the brand less. Canva’s 2026 State of Marketing and AI report states that seven in 10 consumers say it feels like AI-generated ads are missing something. They are, and the trouble is that most marketing teams don’t know what it is.

What they are missing is nowstalgia. It is different than nostalgia, the sentimental word often used to describe a 90s mixed CD or vintage colorway brushed over a campaign. Nowstalgia is intentional. It is the deliberate use of memory, ritual, and human presence to reimagine what’s familiar through the lens of who consumers are today, not who they were before. It’s not about recreating the past. It’s about unlocking the feeling the past carries and building something around it that algorithms cannot generate and consumers cannot easily scroll past. In a market flooded with synthetic perfection, the brands succeeding right now understand something their competitors don’t: When everything looks perfect, the only thing that breaks through to consumers is something that feels real to them.

LEAN INTO NOWSTALGIA

I’m seeing some of my clients leaning into nowstalgia, eschewing the AI image generation that consumers don’t trust and is less effective. One client, BEVEL, is a men’s grooming brand created to solve the unique needs of men of color. When launching its body cream, the brand tapped actor, producer, and director Larenz Tate as the campaign’s face, instead of a generic model or AI-optimized face. Why? “He surpasses anything AI could generate because he carries a deep sense of familiarity rooted in culture, timelessness, and memory,” Josef Adamu, BEVEL’s creative director shared with me. “In a world of AI-generated sameness, what cuts through is lived experience and authenticity. Larenz represents an expression of Black masculinity that algorithms can’t replicate.” 

Another client relied on the power of scent to introduce nowstalgia, when creating and marketing her product. Scent is one of the most documented phenomena in neuroscience and one of the most underused tools in marketing. LEIƏR founder Bria Bryant understood the power of scent while playing beauty chemist at age four, mixing her mother’s fragrances with water and baby powder to create something entirely her own. That passion to deconstruct and rebuild from memory never left her. When creating LEIƏR, she didn’t start with an AI algorithm report. She started with the fragrance she remembered from her mother’s collection, took it apart, and built four distinct compositions from it—a form of nowstalgia. “Familiarity is one of the strongest trust signals we have,” Bryant told me. “It lets people place something quickly, assign meaning without friction, and believe it.”

NOWSTALGIA AS AN IMMERSIVE EXPERIENCE

Where BEVEL and LEIƏR bring nowstalgia into the home, The Iconoclast Dinner Experience (IDE), another client, makes nowstalgia the event itself. Founded by Lezli Levene Harvell, IDE is a culinary platform that brings underrepresented chefs, sommeliers, and spirits professionals to marquee venues to create immersive, multicourse experiences. “The algorithm craves the perfect shot, but humans crave authentic moments and connection,” Harvell told me. “We protect the soul of our events by curating for the person in the room, not the person on the feed.”

While data marketers track impressions, click-through, and reach, they don’t track what people carry out of the room. Harvell calls it the half-life of an experience: how long it stays active in someone’s system after they leave. A piece of content has a half-life of hours, maybe days. A dinner where a chef narrates a dish’s origin while you’re tasting it, where a sommelier’s story about a vineyard becomes part of how you remember the wine, and a spirits expert shares a cocktail with ingredients that remind you of your roots—that has a half-life of months or potentially years. “A press release can be deleted, and a post can be scrolled past,” she said, “but you cannot un-taste a memory.”

This is the distinction every marketer needs to reckon with: the difference between being a content creator and being an experience architect. A content creator fills a pipeline. An experience architect builds something in the room that engages the senses, demands presence, and produces the kind of memory that circulates without a distribution budget. AI can optimize a pipeline, but it cannot engineer a half-life.

BUILD FOR THE HALF-LIFE

In a March 2026 Gartner survey of 1,539 U.S. consumers, half of those surveyed said they would actively prefer to give their business to brands that don’t use generative AI in their consumer-facing messages, advertising, or content. The consumers choosing products and experiences from the companies I highlighted are rejecting the hollow, meaningless version of modernity, not modernity itself. Consumers are responding positively to the nowstalgia elements that AI cannot create.

Right now, the smartest brands are using AI to efficiently scale operations while protecting human connection like a strategic asset. In a world where the feed is infinite and attention is fractured, the only thing that actually breaks through is the thing that feels like it came from somewhere and someone real.

Build for the half-life.

Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw is the founder and CEO of First and Last PR.