In a fintech-mad world, the winning strategy for bankers is becoming a payments-first approach. When fintechs and financial institutions compete for traditional bank products, controlling accounts receivable income can help win the game in business banking.
If you control the payment, you control the entire relationship. Unless banks lead with a payments-focused strategy, they will likely watch as other banks and fintech companies take their most valued customers from them. A robust payments suite backed by trusted service and complementary solutions from a local banker can provide the winning combo for banks to leverage and drive significant growth (full disclosure: Celero provides this service).
BANKING’S BIG THREE
Traditionally, banks have focused on the big three paths to success: deposits, loans and lines of credit (LOC), and investments and insurance. Competition for these comes from national, regional, and community banks.
Consumer deposits are largely shifting toward larger online and national banks, partially driven by media narratives regarding the health of community banks. Recognizing this trend, community bankers are shifting their focus to the highly profitable small-to-medium business (SMB) space. That shift has led many to realize their payment solutions are one of the less competitive offerings they provide to customers.
Even with localized commercial and real estate lending expertise, community and regional players need a competitive edge in the SMB market. Many of today’s successful banks understand the competitive advantage payments bring, whether they lead with this service or ensure it’s part of the pitch package for a business prospect.
A strong payments strategy can boost retention and growth, given how central the solution is to the efficiency and health of small and mid-sized businesses.
THE FINTECH ASSAULT
Community and regional banks don’t just have to contend with large banks—they are also facing a full-on assault from fintech companies.
Online banks, specialty lenders, and wealth management players offer payment solutions. Financial management apps and embedded finance options with big-name recognition, like Intuit QuickBooks and Shopify Balance, have entered the arena. Additionally, digital payments companies like Stripe and Square are particularly worrisome threats.
These other players compete directly against banks for the Big Three revenue drivers while cross-selling their products and those of their strategic partners. Some have moved from simple acquirers to FDIC-insured banking institutions. Now is the time for banks to partner with a strong fintech company to remain the core relationship.
Banks need fintech themselves to stay relevant with customers. However, many fintechs take on banks directlyby offering traditional bank products to complement their core offerings. Finding a partner that complements your core offerings while not competing with them is key to creating that winning bundle.
It’s important to be incredibly selective when choosing a partner. You can find a partner who wants to work with you to protect and grow your business customers strategically.
You also don’t need friendly fire from your partners, so choose them wisely. When you allow a third party to process your customer’s payments, that partner has actionable data, including cash flow, credit score, and seasonality, which could all help them poach the deposit and lending relationship.
PAYMENTS TAKE THE LEAD
Commercial bankers have traditionally used loans and LOCs as lead products to lure relationships from competitors. The fintech era is upending this long-time pattern, as banks include payments in their packages to win business customers.
Many bankers are now choosing a payments-first approach. With a trusted merchant/payments partner, banks are tied into the A/R stream and can then move to commercial deposits and loans/LOCs.
The device formerly known as the “credit card terminal” has evolved from a device for accepting cards to a smart, SaaS-based device that unlocks the entire business—including inventory, payroll, rewards programs, employee management, and more. This evolution has shifted the merchant focus to think of this business management tool as the nucleus relationship most crucial to its success.
Commercial customers are often willing to pay more for the convenience of bundled services, revealing additional paths of non-interest income and core deposits for banks.
Banks should position the value that merchant services offer customers. Too often, bankers discuss what’s important to them. When you talk about payments and the associated business management tools bundled into the payments solution, you talk about what is important to your customers.
Payments also are about retention and customer stickiness. As the payments solution becomes the nucleus of the relationship, it can open the door to cross-selling other products, such as loans and depository relationships. Banks can protect and expand these hard-earned business relationships.
Banks should also study the recurring non-interest income a successful merchant program can generate. Look for examples of similar-sized banks that emphasize payments and the financial impact they create.
CHALLENGES AND CONSIDERATIONS
Some banks invest alongside their partners by creating a wholesale arrangement for the payments technology while building out all operations and support functions internally. This strategy requires meaningful internal investment but reduces external costs. Others enter revenue share arrangements, seeing the payments company drive sales, operations, and support functions.
This type of engagement all but eliminates internal investment expenses. A few large banks have acquired or built payments functions internally, which is extremely expensive to set up and maintain, but often logical for a top 10 U.S. bank.
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE
Fintech can either be a threat or an asset to banks today. The payments solution is fast becoming a dominant focus of business owners, and having a strong payments solution coupled with the proximity and trust of a community banker is a powerful combination that can help small to mid-sized businesses thrive.
Sitting on the sidelines allows other banks, and now fintechs, to leverage payments as an inroad for taking away valuable loan and deposit customers. A strong payments partner can help ensure that the future remains bright for community banks and that small and mid-sized businesses continue to have the combination of modern products and support to compete and win against big-box competitors.