Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Pointing fingers: Why victim-blaming for security failures will never be the answer

Security professionals and the organizations they protect need to rethink how they approach cybersecurity.

[Images: David/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Steve Won

When it comes to cybersecurity, you shouldn’t treat people like the problem; you should treat them like part of the solution. It is estimated that more than 80% of data breaches involve human interaction in some way. However, a victim-blaming mentality fails to address the root causes of security vulnerabilities and can lead to a cynical security culture where you expect the worst from people.

I recall a story from several years ago of a global financial institution that was reluctant to roll out multifactor authentication because they were concerned about their employees’ ability to handle the process. These were bright, well-educated, tech-savvy employees, yet IT was concerned about implementing a simple protocol that is now commonplace for just about any app you download.

I suspect that in any security rollout, there is reasonable trepidation about the level of support needed during implementation. And while it may be a valid concern, it likely furthers this line of cynical thinking and shows an implicit lack of trust that people will make the effort to do the right thing.

So often, this skepticism is misguided, and it overlooks the crucial role that individuals play in defending against cyber threats. Rather than viewing users as adversaries or liabilities, organizations should recognize employees as crucial partners in the fight against evolving cyber threats. 

In my experience, the formula that works best is:

  1. Treat people like adults.
  2. Build security the right way.
  3. Inform people why and how to do the right thing.

I think many more “traditional” companies can learn from the permissive ethos of Silicon Valley’s work culture. By empowering employees with the knowledge and freedom to find creative ways to think about and solve security problems, leaders can serve as allies and enablers rather than mandating policy from the top.

THE COMMUNICATION GAP AND USER EXPERIENCE

Ultimately, communication issues are what undermine even the best-intentioned security professionals. All of the cutting-edge technology and world-class protocols can’t help if they don’t understand the “why” behind it or how it benefits employees. 

I often use the example of credit card companies to demonstrate this point. What works better: an 85-page PDF of disclosures, or a simple brochure explaining “This is what we are doing. Here’s why. And here’s what you can expect.” The second begins by explaining the value of the process and treats you like a partner in the solution. Ultimately, this contributes to a significantly better user experience.

Apply this same logic to communicating security information to your employees, and take a user-experience approach that prioritizes clarity, simplicity, and transparency. Plain language and intuitive interfaces empower users to make informed decisions about their security practices and encourage dialogue between IT departments and end users. Ideally, this open exchange of feedback becomes cyclical, and these insights lead to iterative improvements in security protocols and user experience.

The need for swift and transparent communications is even more significant in the case of a breach disclosure. Breaches are inevitable, but a company that takes accountability and swiftly communicates with its customers can more easily regain trust. Notifying customers quickly with clear language around what happened, as well as actionable steps to move forward and resecure their accounts, can go a long way. Organizations that delay external responses or put out vague and cavalier messaging risk further damage to their brand.

PUBLIC HEALTH AS A MODEL FOR SECURITY

The security community needs to remember who we’re trying to protect and focus on the people rather than the infrastructure. Rather than focusing on exceptional cases, perhaps we should treat security as a public health problem. We can make it our goal to raise the baseline of safety by helping people understand incremental habits to protect themselves, their families, and companies.

The most effective public health intervention of the last 100 years is getting people to wash their hands. In the same way, security industry leaders can point to simple but extremely effective habits such as using biometric passcodes and multi-factor authentication. When we get people to think about sharing passwords the same way they would about sharing handkerchiefs, we might begin to have a real impact. 

Public health programs, as effective as they may be, often get overlooked because they are just not sexy or exciting enough. You’re not going to see an NBC primetime series about people going around promoting good hygiene. Cybersecurity follows much the same path. On one end of the spectrum, some amazing technological breakthroughs can be used to thwart the most insidious cyber threats. But at the ground level, a more egalitarian approach of raising the security floor will be more effective in the long run.

MAKE THE SECURE THING THE EASY THING

Security professionals and the organizations they protect need to rethink how they approach cybersecurity. Implementing a user-experience-focused approach with straightforward and effective communication can help ensure everyone in the organization understands and adheres to security protocols. 

And the more we can build security right into the product as an industry, the better. Security and productivity should always be equally prioritized. Let’s strive to remove this burden from the end user—just like HTTPS on browsers, touch ID, and disk encryption have done in the past, and what passkeys are doing now. 

Businesses should also start at the ground floor and foster a culture of collaboration and empowerment where they view employees as partners in security, not liabilities. Treating employees as stakeholders in cybersecurity initiatives can enhance morale, increase productivity, and improve overall organizational resilience.


Steve Won is the Chief Product Officer of 1Password.