Last year, we couldn’t escape terms like “the Great Resignation” and “quiet quitting.” And while the job market and economic climate have undoubtedly shifted in recent months, business leaders would be remiss not to heed lessons from the past and ensure they’re creating a positive environment for employees before the next major job shift occurs. In fact, even in industries like tech that have experienced turmoil in recent months, reports still find that job opportunities remain strong.
Organizations should aim to create an environment that fosters a sense of employee belonging through increased trust, autonomy, flexibility, and purpose, or they risk that employees will eventually vote with their feet and start looking for an organization that does.
A PERIOD OF REFLECTION
The pandemic changed a lot, including sparking a period of reflection on the nature of work and its role in our lives. This impacted all groups, whether they be leaders, managers, or individual contributors. Factoring in that people were being bombarded from all directions with opinions on how they should be thinking about work, it’s no wonder that movements like the Great Resignation and quiet quitting cropped up.
The impacts of this reflection vary depending on the individual. Some changed careers or shifted industries, while others went back to school or moved to a new region. Now, three years into the pandemic-induced workplace shift, we’ve arrived at another inflection point.
With economic uncertainties continuing to impact businesses, and many companies requiring employees to return to the office in at least a hybrid capacity, workers are being forced to navigate a more volatile environment. But this doesn’t mean they’re willing to completely abandon the flexibility and new ethos towards work that was developed over the past several years.
What we’re seeing now is mismanagement of or a complete change of face from many companies on their remote and hybrid work policies. While this might not have an immediate impact thanks to rising economic uncertainty, as we’ve seen from the past, the tables can turn very quickly.
HYBRID MISMANAGEMENT
The shift to hybrid work—and for some a full-time return to the office—has been poorly managed, and has left employees feeling unmotivated and unengaged. Performance has never been monitored more closely than it is now. With employees working from anywhere, many companies are struggling to trust that employees are working efficiently—even though productivity has stayed the same or increased.
This has led to some unfortunate outcomes, with employee surveillance at an all-time high. In some extreme cases, companies have pursued drastic measures, procuring productivity tracking technologies as a key tool in assessing employee performance—illustrating an antiquated interpretation of the “ideal employee.”
While the leaders and businesses who implement these surveillance tools are correct in believing that technology will enable greater productivity in this hybrid era, they’ve missed the mark on which technologies are best suited to do this.
Technology should elicit a positive experience from employees, not a negative one. Technologies should empower and enable rather than punish and coerce. There’s no better way to breed resentment amongst employees than to show that you don’t trust them by scrutinizing their every move. On the other hand, procuring the right kinds of technologies can signal that you recognize an employee’s presence and the value they add to the organization.
For example, Jabra’s Hybrid Ways of Working 2022 Global Report found that 61% of employees globally say they feel more included and present in meetings when everyone has their camera turned on. When employees feel that they’re part of something larger than themselves and that they’re part of a cohesive group built on a culture of trust, they feel empowered to contribute to it. Clearly, video technology can play a positive, empowering, and inclusive role at work.
If businesses want to spark a sense of commitment and help prevent the next employee exodus, they must adapt by making choices that build trust rather than undermine it.
MACROECONOMIC TRENDS TAKE THEIR TOLL
The current economic turbulence—characterized by rising inflation and stagnating wages—is only serving to deepen the concern among employees and employers alike. Many employees report feeling overworked, with employers hyper-focused on productivity, structure, and cost. This is doubly true for Gen Z and Millennials, who have not seen the same early career wealth growth that many Gen X and Boomers experienced.
Further contributing to the issue is the plateauing economy and slowing job growth. Employee confidence in the labor market is shrinking, making seeking out a new job a more difficult and riskier endeavor than it was a year ago. While we expected that many people would “vote with their feet” to look for better opportunities, we’re instead seeing employees recalibrate their lives within their current circumstances.
Ultimately, the growing wave of employee resentment has been brewing for years thanks to poor transitions to remote work during the pandemic that turned into failed hybrid work policies and forced returns to the office that aren’t well justified beyond the preferences of executives.
To prevent the next wave of employee dissatisfaction and turnover, businesses need to step up. We know that employees want increased autonomy and flexibility to structure their lives in a way that works best for them. We know that leaders and managers need to leverage technology to keep employee inclusion and performance high. And we know that the post-pandemic economic fallout is difficult on everyone. If employers want to keep employees engaged and foster loyalty among employees, they need to boost trust through increased autonomy, lead with empathy, and make the right technological investments.
Kelly Nagel is the President and General Manager of Jabra, a leader in personal sound and hybrid work solutions, North America.