Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Preparing teams for branding: A guide to agency selection and project success

The prep work you do before hiring a branding agency will ultimately prove to be the backbone of your branding process.

Team having a meeting

[Images: Courtney Haas/peopleimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Daria Gonzalez

CEO, co-founder · Wunderdogs

BY DARIA GONZALEZ

Launching a branding project in any organization often involves a lot of internal push and pull. We’ve worked with a broad variety of clients at Wunderdogs—from seed-level startups to corporate teams who have long been out of the fundraising game. As a result, we’ve seen a great number of attitudes and approaches to branding projects and we know which ones can make or break the process.

While every team is different, the ones who are able to set up their branding workflows successfully all share certain similarities. Laying the groundwork and following clear procedures is important—especially if the team in question is technically-minded and has little experience in more “creative” endeavors.

To secure success in executing a branding project, key players must be identified, budgets outlined, and expectations made explicit. Identifying budgets and stakeholders is typically fairly easy for most teams, however, expectations may prove more challenging to consolidate.

SETTING THE SCENE: HELPING PEOPLE MAKE SENSE OF BRANDING

While making the decision to launch a branding project is an exciting time in a company’s life, some internal stakeholders may have misguided expectations when it comes to branding, so setting the scene is vitally important.

Make sure to address precisely what you expect branding to do for you—and what branding isn’t geared to do. For instance, while branding can contribute to an organization’s growth and make it more attractive to investors, it’s not a replacement for technical superiority or product innovation. It’s also not an alternative, or a synonym for marketing. As the project pioneer, you need to make sure that all project stakeholders understand the purpose of branding, its goals, and limitations.

Similarly, some teams may be reluctant to engage in branding at all, but they may feel they need to update their website or be discouraged about how their content is performing. To avoid futile conversations, explain why building a brand is an essential step in reaching their desired outcome. When done well, branding can be a vibrant, forward-thinking process that will position an organization and help it develop an engaging consumer dialogue for the long term.

BRIEFING LIKE A PRO

Once you have an intention set, it’s time to get into the specifics. Writing an agency brief may be a daunting task, but the clearer the brief, the more likely it is to successfully meet the project goal. Like most things in the branding workflow, creating a brief should be a collaborative process, but one person should own it from start to finish. To get your technically-minded team engaged, ask them to employ their analytical mindset to identify what dissatisfies them about where they are, where they would like to end up, and potential pathways to reach this destination.

If the initial impulse that led you toward considering hiring an agency was dissatisfaction with your website, try to build upon this dissatisfaction by asking very specific questions. Is the website not converting as it should? Do you feel that it’s not representing your team or your values correctly? Have you outgrown it as a company? Do you feel you’re not comparing as favorably as you should against competitors?

In workshopping the answers to questions such as this, you’re likely to get to the main constituent parts of your brief: the what, the why, and the results you’re looking to achieve. Remember that developing a structured brief isn’t only for the agency’s benefit. It also helps stakeholders stay focused on the goals and understand the scope of the project from beginning to end—and good alignment is crucial for project success.

AGENCY BUDGET AND SELECTION

The next priority is to select a branding agency with whom to partner, and to outline the budget to be allocated to the project. The size of the budget should be decided before any agency is contacted, so that there’s more transparency in the process and fewer chances of it spiraling out of control. For your first branding project, choosing quality with no corners cut is probably a safer bet to ensure project success.

Again, internal alignment and collaboration is key at the agency selection stage. You will need buy-in from all project stakeholders on the type of agency you want. Branding agency descriptions can feel vague and “fluffy”—especially to technical founders, so being very specific in your search criteria is crucial. Ask questions like, “Is having deep experience in our particular sector important to us?” and “Do we want an agency that will build our brand and we’ll take over website building and implementation? Or do we want an agency that will take us through the whole journey?”

When you’ve clarified your criteria, it’s time to build your shortlist of 10 agencies with which to get in touch. Most people advise you to go with recommendations. It’s always a good idea to ask brands and founders you like for their agency contacts, but branching out is also useful, notably because it gives you space for comparison. Websites such as Clutch (an agency ranking service) are very useful for initial research, but keep in mind that—as with any review-based service—some of their ratings may not reflect reality.

FINAL STEPS

After putting together your thorough brief and your agency criteria, you’re now in a good position to start talking to agencies. Remember, however, that finding a great agency is a two-way street. They need to know that you are a great client, and you need to know that they are the right match for you. The agency may look perfect on paper, but if your teams have vastly different communication styles, the relationship may become strained, jeopardizing the success of your project. So, listen to your gut as well as your brain when making the final decision.

Remember, all the preparatory work you’ve done up until this point will be the backbone of your branding process. If your team comes prepared, they’re likely to find the process rewarding, insightful, and useful for years to come.


Daria Gonzalez is CEO at Wunderdogs, a brand consultancy and digital studio for tech companies taking on the world’s biggest challenges.