When I joined a previous company, management was on their (second or third) attempt to “save” a star employee. Each time this employee told the company they were offered a new position with a different company, management offered more money, and he agreed to stay. About 12 months after we saved this employee for the last time, they accepted a management role elsewhere.
As it turns out, the whole time the company was offering more money, this person just wanted to become a manager. Management and the employee were on different pages entirely and a high-performing employee was lost because management was not listening to what they needed to stay.
This story is nothing new. Data from CEB (now Gartner) shows that 50% of employees who accept a counteroffer leave within 12 months. If we want to retain top talent, we should act before the counteroffer.
So why do companies wait until an employee is already considering leaving to offer incentives to stay?
IDENTIFY TOP PERFORMERS
Companies don’t wait to offer incentives out of malicious intent. Many organizations do not have a programmatic approach to identifying and managing talent. If we do not know who our top performers are, how can we expect to keep them on board? Before anything else, we need to build a system to identify talent and classify our employees.
One basic way to do this is to walk yourself through a lifeboat exercise that immediately classifies employees. Ask yourself three questions:
- If your ship was sinking, which employees would you take in the lifeboat with you?
- Who are your steady eddies (A.K.A., the people who are doing good work but are not those you couldn’t bear to lose)?
- Who is in your bottom 10%?
Some companies may already have such systems in place—such as nine-box exercises or performing calibration exercises with employees—but then fail to take steps to help their high-performers actively grow within the company. Retaining top talent requires we both know who they are and what they need to succeed.
ASK EMPLOYEES WHAT THEY NEED
A leader once asked me, “How do I know what motivates my employees?” My response was simple: Ask them. Motivating our employees does not need to be overcomplicated or turned into rocket science. If we want to know how to convince an employee to stay or go, all we have to do is ask them.
During annual performance reviews, I ask employees to rank what motivates them (family, work-life balance, money, location) and why. With this information, I can better understand what motivates them and tailor their experience accordingly. It’s also important to ask these questions every year, no matter if an employee has been with you for two months or 20 years. As we age, what motivates us will change: A 24-year-old engineer might not have “family” in their top-five list, but in 10 years, it might be number one.
There is no one-size-fits-all to motivating employees, and if we assume all employees are motivated by cash, we will find ourselves sorely mistaken. We have to have ongoing conversations with our employees and understand that people’s circumstances change with time. By directly asking employees what motivates them, we can create an environment they want to work in now and in the future.
LEVERAGE FRONT-LINE MANAGERS
Our frontline managers are an extension of the leadership cadre and are the first line of defense in retaining our high performers. I call this group our “force multipliers”—they often have more touchpoints with an employee than the CEO and thus have great power to tailor the employee experience.
Because of this, managers can be our strongest troops or weakest links. If management breaks down, employees may end up feeling unheard and unappreciated. In a survey from Ten Spot, 46% of workers said their manager is why they want to quit their job, and close to 80% of managers say they need more training. However, when we leverage management effectively, they can optimize each employee’s experience and help us incentivize our top performers to stay.
Managers should know who is performing well and who is falling behind. If they sense an employee is struggling, they can step in and steer them in the right direction. If they can tell an employee is eager to grow, they can talk to leadership about giving them new opportunities. By working closely with their team, they can determine what makes each employee tick—whether it’s more money, mentorship, or training—and use that knowledge to improve the workplace environment and employee experience.
YOU GET OUT WHAT YOU PUT IN
By the time we come up with a counteroffer, it’s often too late to save a treasured employee. They may say yes to the offer and decide to stay, but for how long and at what cost? Accepting a counteroffer can feel like zapping leftover take-out in the microwave—we don’t really want to eat it anymore, but we figure we might as well get the most bang for our buck before we try something new.
We must create a programmatic approach to identifying high performers to avoid last-ditch counteroffers. Once they’re identified, we must be proactive, cultivating ongoing conversations about what they need to succeed. These efforts may require a lot of time to put in place, but they will still likely be much less expensive than trying to outbid a competitor or replacing an employee.
Being intentional in your employee retention efforts is much more likely to cause your staff to be enthusiastic about staying in your team, not just settling for it. That enthusiasm translates to production, morale, and greater mutual trust. Your top performers likely know what they need: Ask them. You might be surprised at the result.
Michelle Arieta is the Senior Vice President of Human Resources at MediaLab.