Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Reasons why not to DIY

Call in a specialist, and you’ll thank me later.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Shani Harmon

Co-Founder, Chief Executive Officer · Stop Meeting Like This

When you’re referred to a gastro, rheum, or some other -ologist by your primary care physician, you rarely question the need for subject-matter expertise (SME). In fact, we consult specialists all the time in life, whether it’s a mechanic, a landscape architect, an interior designer, a colorist, or a tax professional.

But when it comes to management consultants, clients seem loath to trust their subject matter expertise. 

There’s certainly justification for some skepticism. For every high-integrity firm, an equal number of companies recycle generic insights and sell them to anyone and everyone. And even before AI, many of the consulting firms’ proprietary frameworks and processes were widely available on the internet and from former employees with their own shingle.

In my specialty—collaboration and organizational effectiveness—the challenge is even worse. Most professionals, from middle managers to members of the C-suite, consider themselves experts at prioritization, running effective meetings, delegating, and providing feedback to their team.

But then ask their team members. Or observe them in action. You’ll find meetings that meander without clear purpose and therefore don’t produce anything of value. Or a glut of update meetings, wasting time that could be used for collaborative problem-solving or individual focus.

You’ll find an unclear strategy, a laundry list of priorities, and stalled decision-making, all of which grind productivity to a halt. What you’ll realize is that they don’t know what good looks like, probably because they haven’t experienced it either.

4 ways subject matter experts (SMEs) add value

Given the speed at which most companies aim to operate, and the fact that many are trying to do more with less, it’s no wonder that the “what” of work leaves little room to worry about the “how.” That’s where outside leverage comes in. Here are just a few of the reasons to consider bringing in outside subject matter experts rather than DIY.

1. Broad experience and perspectives

Depending on how many organizations you’ve worked in over the course of your career, you may have limited insight into how other organizations operate. While some best practices are widely known, such as Amazon’s two-pizza rule and the reading period at the start of meetings, many are not public information.

Outside experts will have seen and evaluated a wealth of approaches and can offer you those most likely to succeed in your specific environment. My firm, for example, has worked with everyone from global pharmaceutical companies and biotechs to hospitality and retail, to growing start-ups and small non-profits on their collaborative capabilities. That’s a breadth and depth of expertise that’s tough to find inside any one organization.

2. Design and facilitation expertise

Designing a team offsite meeting may be something that you have done many times over the course of your career. If you hosted one every quarter for 10 years, for example, you would have taken 40 at-bats.

A professional facilitator is likely to lead an offsite every two weeks. In that same time frame, assuming a 40-week work year, they would have executed 200 events. In short, they’ve seen it all, and they’re well-practiced in adapting on the fly and navigating unexpected challenges.

In addition, they understand the instructional design and adult learning theory underpinnings of effective sessions, and they can play the kind of role that only an external resource can. With an outside facilitator, those who would otherwise plan the meeting and run sessions—often those with key insights of their own—can instead be full participants.

Recurring issues or tangents that tend to stop productive conversations in their tracks can be objectively managed by an outside voice without a personal stake in the matter. And all those ideas and next steps that tend to get lost as everyone heads to the airport? Your facilitator captures them and synthesizes them into something usable. That’s leverage.

3. Your own skills development

When you encounter a new kind of challenge or opportunity, such as how to train AI agents to take over routine tasks, it takes time to climb the learning curve before you can achieve the desired results.

Experts are performance-ready now. The best ones will partner with you and don’t just give you the fish but “teach you to fish.”

Your ability to handle the next learning curve should be significantly higher by the end of the engagement. Make your own capability building a specific deliverable in your scope of work so that you’re sure to get the double benefit.

4. Commitment and accountability

Holding peers and team members accountable for delivering on their commitments is notoriously difficult. And while SME contractors sometimes come up short, you have many more ways to hold them accountable, including withholding payment until the contract is satisfied.

Plus, in the world of external consultants, reputation is everything. There’s a strong disincentive to never disappoint.

SMEs as partners

Some organizations recognize external subject-matter experts as key to transforming their businesses, enabling leaders to focus on delivering today’s results.

Others, however, only bring on consultants as a last resort—when recurring conflicts have become intractable, key talent is lost, or the bottom line is measurably impacted. If you or your organization is hesitant or has been burned in the past, consider whether it’s the industry at large or just an individual, and what you could achieve with an influx of expertise.

Shani Harmon is the cofounder and CEO of Stop Meeting Like This.