Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Signs your managers are amazing at developing and retaining people

How do you know if your managers are amazing at developing people? You’ll see signs like these.

Happy team

[Images: Krakenimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Tom Floyd

Founder · Flouracity

With the layoffs that continue to sweep many industries, it’s hard to believe we’ll face a talent shortage in the years ahead. However, according to many experts, that’s exactly what the future holds. A study from ManpowerGroup found in 2022 the global talent shortage reached a 16-year high, with three in four employers reporting they were having difficulty in finding the talent they need. The issue is particularly acute in industries like government, healthcare, IT, manufacturing, and tech, and it’s not just going to result in unfilled roles; companies are going to feel it in their bottom lines. Global organizational consulting firm Korn Ferry is calling it an “$8.5 trillion talent shortage,” reporting that 85 million jobs could go unfilled by 2030.

Declining birth rates, high unemployment levels, and a shortage of soft skills in the workforce are some of the many factors contributing to this. When you combine those with additional challenges like high turnover, low engagement, and burnout, you’ll start finding many leaders acutely feeling the pain of not having the talent they need to drive results.

Sound exhausting? It will be. And big companies will feel it the most.

For many leaders, the instinct will be to double down on recruiting and create cultures that focus on continuous learning. I’m particularly a fan of the latter: When people feel like they’re regularly growing in their roles, they feel fulfilled, stay longer, and feel energized by the opportunity to solve new problems.

However, most leaders will underestimate the importance of amplifying and rewarding the results of the people who play the most important role in ensuring employees have the skills needed to combat that looming talent shortage: managers. Managers are the leaders with the power to make learning a priority in their direct reports’ day-to-day to ensure employees are regularly getting feedback, and they possess the insight to determine where there are opportunities for people to reskill and move into new roles. 

Now more than ever, it’s critical that leaders at all levels ensure they have managers who have the desire to invest in developing that blend of soft and technical skills people will need in the future.

How do you know if your managers are amazing at developing people? You’ll see signs like these: 

THEY SEE DEVELOPING LEADERS AS ONE OF THEIR PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES

Becoming a manager isn’t just a change in what you do; it’s a change in how you think. These mindset shifts impact how managers spend their time. When it comes to leadership, managers aren’t just responsible for role modeling what it means to be an effective leader; successful managers believe a big part of their job is developing great leaders on their teams. And you’ll see this mindset show up in their actions. In one-on-ones, you’ll hear them talking about skill gaps they’re seeing; in team meetings, you’ll notice they proactively volunteer to lead initiatives focused on development; and in talent reviews, you’ll hear them articulate how high-potentials are demonstrating the capabilities your function will need in the future. 

THEY REGULARLY GIVE DEVELOPMENTAL FEEDBACK

While hearing the word feedback may make many of us cringe, the truth is most people want feedback at work. However, many managers will be the first ones to tell you they’re not great at giving feedback, with studies by Gallup finding only 14.5% of managers strongly agree they’re good at giving feedback. Most people value developmental feedback the most, which is that feedback that creates a conversation about the skills they’ll need to grow at the company. Managers who value feedback look for opportunities to talk about it regularly. You’ll see them focus one-on-ones on development conversations—not status updates. In engagement results, you’ll see positive themes about people getting meaningful feedback. And in your one-on-one conversations, you’ll notice them proactively asking you for feedback in specific areas on a regular basis.

THEY TAKE A COACHING APPROACH IN CONVERSATIONS WITH OTHERS

Managers at all levels frequently talk about the coaching they regularly provide their teams. However, in many cases, you’ll find some managers have gotten the definition of coaching a little twisted, confusing it with that specific direction and guidance we give others about how to solve problems. Coaching is one of the most effective tools in helping people develop awareness of their blind spots. And alarm bells should be going off when you see themes in recent reports like those from DDI that stress there has been a drop in the number of companies that report they rely on coaching to develop their leaders. Coaching can be a critical tool in ensuring your company’s success. You’ll notice managers who value coaching and listening for both what’s being said and not being said in conversations. You’ll hear them asking open-ended questions that get people exploring the issues they’re experiencing more deeply. And when you’re discussing the challenges keeping you up at night in conversations with them, you’ll notice them coaching you. 

In the end, the biggest indicators you’ll see that tell you if your managers are effective at developing people will be in your organization’s results. You’ll hear in skip levels that people are gaining new skills working for your managers. You’ll see low attrition in their teams. You’ll notice the creation of new roles filled by tenured workers who have reskilled themselves into new opportunities. And you’ll find you’re regularly recognizing the strong performance your managers’ teams continue to deliver.

Can you say your managers are amazing at developing people?

If you can’t say it today, you’ll need to be able to say it soon to not just survive but thrive in the talent shortage that’s ahead.


Tom Floyd is an executive coach and founder of Flouracity, a professional development company that arms leaders with the skills to flourish.