Of all the levers you can pull to drive business success, one of the most critical is giving and receiving feedback. A perfect strategy can be undone by a poor executive, and motivated, engaged employees are key to strong execution.
As a leader, you have a huge opportunity to boost employee engagement, productivity, retention, and innovation by improving how you address feedback. So where do most companies stand when it comes to providing feedback to employees? Articles in Harvard Business Review reveal some pretty interesting (and surprising) facts:
- 37% of managers feel “uncomfortable having to give direct feedback about their employees’ performance if they think the employee might respond negatively to the feedback”
- 69% of managers often feel uncomfortable even communicating with their employees
- 72% of employees feel “their performance would improve if their managers would provide corrective feedback”
- 92% of employees say corrective feedback (delivered appropriately) is an effective way to improve performance
With managers reluctant to provide commentary and employees yearning for it, how can leaders reset the status quo and improve the feedback loop? I’ve always believed that the answer is through compassion, empathy, and honesty. Anyone can provide feedback that’s effective in the short term, but that feedback can be damaging to the employee. The challenge is to provide feedback that truly improves the person’s career and leaves them feeling better than they did before the conversation.
I’ve taken this opportunity to revisit how we at MoneyGram approach feedback to ensure we focus on making one another better. Here are six questions to ask yourself to help optimize your employee feedback strategy and ensure you’re providing feel-good feedback that lasts:
1. ARE MY INTENTIONS GOOD AND FOCUSED ON THE PERSON’S SUCCESS?
In many ways, I believe the most accurate parallels for leadership come from parenting. As with parenting, if you ask someone to course correct, make sure it’s because it’s important to that person’s career—not out of annoyance or a desire to change them. Throughout my career, I’ve had bosses provide feedback on everything from how my voice sounded to whether my colleagues liked me. This type of feedback is not actionable for the employee and is not clearly tied to a career impediment. Assess your motivations. When in doubt, keep quiet.
2. DO I EXPLAIN THE “WHY” BEHIND FEEDBACK DIRECTLY AND HONESTLY?
Use this tactic from the start to set the stage for all that follows. This can also help ensure your motives are driven by a desire to help. For example, rather than saying, “We need to work on your communication, especially in executive meetings,” instead try: “I want you to be successful in communicating your point because what you have to say is important. Here are examples where your point may have been lost, and I want to ensure you’re heard next time.”
3. DO I PROVIDE FEEDBACK AND HELP IN NEAR REAL TIME?
While its common practice to hold feedback sessions on a scheduled cadence such as quarterly or bi-annually, this can be far from effective if it is not supplemented with real-time feedback discussions. Give feedback as soon as possible after an event or behavior. Simultaneously, encourage employees to ask for comments in the moment from both managers and peers. This can help reinforce a compassionate feedback culture and let employees know immediately how they’re doing. Encourage your employees to ask their peers: “I’m working on better communication—how did I do in that meeting?”
4. DO I OFFER SPECIFIC HELP AND CLEAR NEXT STEPS?
Ensure that employees know you’re invested and can help with specific tactics and next steps. For the hypothetical person I mentioned above who needs to upskill executive communications, you could suggest practice sessions and pair them with someone who is gifted in this area. In addition to offering to help, consider asking them to provide one or two actions they’re going to take to improve, which puts some ownership in their hands. Discussing specifics accomplishes a number of things: your employee knows you care; your employee doesn’t feel alone; and your employee has clear and concrete next steps to take to act on the feedback.
5. DO I LISTEN AND SEEK COUNTER-FEEDBACK?
Receiving feedback can be a traumatic experience, especially if it flows in one direction. Feedback should be a two-way street: When you offer it, seek it in return. Two key questions to ask your employee are: “Is there anything I could be doing differently to help you succeed?” and “Would you like to meet again on this in a few days?” The second one is especially important, as I’ve realized that most people prefer to internalize and reflect before reacting. This question acknowledges processing differences and gives people the opportunity to gather their thoughts more effectively.
6. DO I FOLLOW UP TO ENSURE I’M NOT LEAVING THEM HANGING?
Everyone wants to produce good work and feel supported while doing so. When many people are given feedback, they try to adjust their behavior in response. Watch for this. As soon as they do it, recognize it and reinforce it. Even if you don’t personally see these changed behaviors in action, check in with them. Ask how they are doing and whether they feel successful in incorporating your feedback.
Finally, know that even the kindest feedback given with the best intentions still won’t always go well. In these cases, I tend to reflect on what may have caused the issue and what I can do differently next time. However, in most instances, I believe that if you can answer “yes” to the six questions above, the feedback given will energize both the giver and the receiver and set you on a path to building a culture of compassionate transparency that drives sustainable performance.
Anna Greenwald is the Chief Operating Officer at MoneyGram, a global leader in cross-border money transfers.