I’m writing this article on a MacBook I bought in March 2021. By corporate IT standards, it should already be gone. The warranty has expired. The refresh cycle has passed. A spreadsheet somewhere would say it’s time to replace it.
The problem is, my five-year-old laptop is performing beautifully.
Using a Digital Employee Experience (DEX) platform, I can see exactly how the device is behaving. Startup times are fast, application responsiveness is strong, and the overall user experience remains excellent. If I replaced it tomorrow, I wouldn’t be solving a problem. I’d simply be following a policy.
That may sound like a small observation, but it highlights one of the most expensive assumptions in enterprise IT.
THE SPREADSHEET IS DRIVING MILLIONS IN SPENDING
For decades, organizations have replaced endpoint devices based primarily on age rather than performance. Three- to five-year refresh cycles became standard practice because they simplified procurement, budgeting, and support operations. Eventually, the schedule became the strategy. Gartner estimated the average business laptop lifecycle at approximately 3.7 years, reinforcing how deeply fixed replacement timelines have become embedded in enterprise planning.
The financial implications are substantial. While most organizations focus on hardware costs, the true expense of a refresh extends to deployment, migration, support, and lost productivity. Industry estimates commonly place the fully loaded cost of replacing an enterprise laptop between $2,000 and $4,000 per endpoint, when labor and employee downtime are included.
For organizations managing thousands or even tens of thousands of endpoints, refresh programs represent millions of dollars in recurring annual spending. Yet many of those devices continue to deliver a strong employee experience when they are retired. The only thing that has changed is the date on a spreadsheet.
What’s interesting is that the opposite problem often exists at the same time. I’ve seen organizations replace perfectly healthy devices while employees continue struggling with performance issues on much newer systems. One company used endpoint analytics during a workplace modernization initiative and discovered that nearly 30% of the applications installed in its virtual desktop environment were unnecessary. Removing that software dramatically simplified management and helped reduce login times from 4.5 minutes to just 45 seconds. The lesson was about visibility. Once the organization had data, it could focus on what was actually affecting performance.
THE AI ERA IS CHANGING HARDWARE ECONOMICS
The economics behind endpoint refreshes are changing quickly. AI infrastructure, GPU deployments, and rising memory demand are placing new pressure on technology budgets. Every organization is trying to fund the next wave of AI, strengthen cybersecurity, automate operations, and modernize its technology stack with finite capital.
Against that backdrop, every unnecessary laptop replacement becomes a tradeoff. A laptop that gets replaced a year too early is a procurement decision, but also capital that isn’t available for AI infrastructure, security modernization, automation, or the platforms that will drive future growth.
That shift is causing many IT leaders to revisit long-standing assumptions about hardware lifecycle management. IT leaders are beginning to ask whether a device is still delivering a good experience rather than questioning how quickly devices should be replaced.
FROM SCHEDULED REFRESHES TO DATA-DRIVEN DECISIONS
This is where DEX is changing the conversation. Modern endpoint telemetry allows IT teams to continuously evaluate device health, application performance, resource utilization, battery condition, stability trends, and overall user experience. Organizations can make decisions based on actual operating conditions.
The same visibility that helps identify underperforming devices also highlights systems that continue to perform well beyond traditional replacement windows. We’ve seen organizations use this data to challenge assumptions about device health. In one global environment, endpoint data revealed that some of the oldest devices were delivering excellent user experiences while newer systems were generating a disproportionate share of support tickets. IT can prioritize investments based on performance and employee experience.
These examples illustrate a broader shift. Organizations are moving away from making decisions based on assumptions and toward making decisions based on evidence.
The benefits extend well beyond hardware budgets. Employees avoid unnecessary migrations and disruptions. Support teams spend less time managing large-scale refresh projects. IT leaders gain confidence that investments are directed where they will have the greatest impact.
There is also a sustainability benefit. Every device replaced prematurely carries an environmental cost. Real-time telemetry allows organizations to extend the life of healthy devices while targeting genuinely underperforming systems for replacement.
THE NEXT EVOLUTION OF ENDPOINT MANAGEMENT
The same visibility driving smarter refresh decisions is enabling a broader transformation in IT operations. Telemetry can identify emerging issues, predict failures, and automate remediation before employees are affected. This is the foundation of autonomous endpoint management, where systems actively maintain endpoint health rather than simply monitor it.
For years, IT organizations have measured success by how quickly they respond to problems. Increasingly, the goal is to prevent those problems from occurring.
A manufacturer with a relatively small IT team supporting distributed locations recently began automating common issues that previously generated service desk tickets. Tasks such as resolving workspace application problems, managing storage constraints, and maintaining endpoint configurations can now be addressed before users ever notice them. The result is fewer tickets and more time for IT teams to focus on higher-value initiatives.
Hardware refresh schedules have been a substitute for visibility. When you can’t see how devices are performing, replacing them on a predictable timeline feels like the safest option.
Successful organizations in the next decade will use data most effectively to maximize performance, control costs, improve sustainability, and deliver a better employee experience. In some cases, that means replacing devices earlier than expected. In others, it means keeping a five-year-old laptop in service because the data shows it is still doing its job.
My MacBook is an example of that shift, but the implications extend across every endpoint in the enterprise. The future of endpoint management is about understanding what is actually happening and making decisions accordingly.
Jed Ayres is CEO of ControlUp.