Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Takeaways from my first year leading a customer advisory board

Making CABs invaluable for both a company and its members demands constant refinement and a collaborative effort. Here's what we’re using to propel our CAB forward.

[Images: Adobe Stock / insta_photos]

Profile photo of Karen Budell

Chief Marketing Officer · Totango

BY Karen Budell

“Let’s kill the health score!” Bombshell dropped—not by a competitor, but by a valued member of our customer advisory board (CAB). 

And guess what? Despite including the customer health score as a core capability of our software, we loved hearing this hot take. 

Open, constructive feedback from our CAB members is welcome and necessary to success. Their willingness to challenge the status quo motivates us to keep innovating and delivering maximum value to customers. Plus, debates like this get all of the leaders in the room to explore industry topics more thoroughly and examine practices within their own teams.

Customer advisory boards (CABs) are an invaluable tool for emerging businesses, especially in the tech space. Yet making CABs invaluable for both a company and its members demands constant refinement and a collaborative effort. 

Between 2019 and 2021, the number of global organizations incorporating CABs into their governance structure increased by 52%—and since 2021, that number has increased another 20%. According to Pragmatic Institute’s research, within two years of starting a CAB, companies realize a 9% increase in new business from CAB versus non-CAB members.

Over the past year, I’ve had the pleasure of leading our customer advisory board. While I didn’t build it from the ground up, we did implement a few changes in our approach the past year—such as documenting a charter with our mission, objectives, and an outline of responsibilities that we asked members to accept as part of their commitment to the CAB. That commitment and active participation are foundational to the value exchange and success of the broader initiative.

Here are the major takeaways that we’re using to propel our CAB forward.

HELP THEM, HELP YOU

Unlike traditional CABs focused solely on company direction, our unique position in the customer success (CS) industry creates a fascinating dynamic. Our CAB members seek insights, examples, and ideas from each other and Totango just as much as our leadership team seeks insights from CAB members. 

For example, we send our members a quick survey from time to time, and the one survey we shared before our final meeting of the year revealed a big focus for customer success leaders in 2024: CS team structure, reporting, and role development within the entire organization.

Evolving an entire function and team is a monumental task, and I’ve repeatedly seen questions about this topic pop up throughout the past year. The CS industry is going through an evolution, with a great emphasis focused on protecting and generating revenue—being held accountable for driving customer outcomes and business impact. (It’s not unlike the transformation marketing underwent over the past decade with the pendulum swing from brand toward demand generation and performance marketing.) 

Our CAB provides an interactive forum with many opportunities for peer-to-peer learning and discussions on digital programs and data and tool integration. We’re not in a “one or the other” or “one, then the other” situation right now—as an industry, we’re in the middle of a simultaneous evolution of function, roles, and tools, and the trick is figuring out how to find alignment across the C-suite to make it happen.

MAKE IT YES, AND

The most valuable strategic insights often emerge from constructive dissent. Despite abundant agreement and alignment during meetings over the past year, those who challenged ideas and respectfully debated moved the needle on the overall conversation. For example, that customer success executive who proclaimed the health score is dead sparked a lively debate at our annual in-person meeting. It led us into conversations about how CS has to evolve to own a key metric like NRR or GRR to demonstrate its value and business impact. 

CAB members have a responsibility to bring new ideas to the table and ask contrarian questions. When proposing and debating controversial topics, like eliminating health scores or monetizing customer success as a service, members can (and should) prompt follow-up discussions to explore these topics further. 

CABs must nurture this “yes, and” culture, enabling all members to comfortably interject respectful counterviews. That culture may include a rotation in discussion formats to accommodate members who prefer small workshops over large forums, virtual break-out rooms over a large Zoom room, or in-person versus virtual meetings. Sidebar: The hybrid setting is awkward for all involved, and I’d recommend avoiding it if possible to ensure you provide a quality experience.

Healthy debates stem from greater participation—and you never know what ideas those spirited conversations might generate. In an earlier meeting, for example, one of our members initiated a conversation about customer success qualified leads (CSQLs). This topic prompted a multi-view discussion (and, ultimately, a new deep-dive meeting) on the definition and value of the CSQL metric, incentive and compensation models, and how you can use your customer success software to track it. 

REDEFINING CUSTOMER SUCCESS

Customer advisory boards act as a unique mechanism, facilitating a collective effort inspiring and enabling all members to ask for the examples and ideas they need to make decisions and changes over the next year—and encouraging members to brainstorm ways technology can help drive predictable growth for their customers and business. 

Our CAB has been more than a sounding board—it’s been a crucible for forging innovative solutions and redefining the role of customer success in the enterprise. By fostering a culture of mutual learning, embracing healthy debate, and actively seeking diverse voices, our CAB has sparked transformative change—for us and for our members.


Karen Budell is Chief Marketing Officer of the leading customer success platform Totango.