Tech headlines and industry commentators warn of the imminent death of the creative field, with sweeping claims that artificial intelligence will eliminate artists and render human imagination obsolete.
Additional corporate pressure to adopt AI fuels fear-mongering and uncertainty, especially for those of us who work in creative spaces or industries. But the truth of the matter? The narrative is completely false.
This is the best, most transformative, and most exciting time in history to be a creative visual professional. Yes, the tools and approaches are transforming, but the future of the creative is, and always will be, dependent on human creativity. We can’t let fear and propaganda halt progress and innovation in a moment when we should be ramping up.
The halt in progress is in the numbers: One study by Carnegie of professional visual artists reveals that 99% of those surveyed dislike GenAI. This sentiment has directly translated into usage statistics. In that same survey, 85% of artists completely abstain from using genAI, and 88% refuse to use AI to generate images during their creative processes.
To see past the propaganda plaguing creative visual work, the market must stop treating creative work as a single, monolithic effort shrouded in mystery. Creative work and output must be split into two distinct categories: creativity and creative production. Once that distinction is clear, the entire argument that AI kills creativity flips on its head.
Creativity as ideas, concepts, and invention
The idea that the best new creative concepts will come from artificial intelligence is preposterous. Generative AI, by its very nature, will never create something new, in my opinion. It operates entirely on what already exists, synthesizing past data into a polished output.
Because these tools train on everything that has ever been produced, everything they generate is, by definition, based on existing work. They offer a look back at the past by aggregating, correlating, and combining historical inputs, but they produce nothing net new, and regurgitation isn’t creativity.
The human advantage lies in this limitation. Original ideas require a human soul, involving deep intuition, lived experiences, and emotional nuances that a machine simply cannot replicate.
For instance, I can sit down on a couch, know how shampoo works on my hair, or know how a kitchen utensil works when I’m making my favorite food.
What someone wants to say, and the profound truth of how to say it, will always originate from human creators who imagine new possibilities with their hearts and minds. AI is the advanced engine waiting to implement that vision.
Creative production as mechanics
When it comes to creative production, disruption is coming, but it’s overwhelmingly positive. Asking creative teams how technology can optimize workflow requires reviews of daily processes to separate production’s grueling mechanics from the pure spark of creativity.
When leaders frame AI as a way to give a creative department better tools rather than replace people, the entire outlook changes, and fear can dissipate. Instead of fearing technology, artists can use technology to uplevel output by optimizing the repetitive, time-consuming parts of the job.
For instance, AI has changed the way we create images. Physical photo shoots are no longer needed to create realistic lifestyle images and video that our team would have otherwise spent countless hours preparing for, producing, shooting, and then in post-production to achieve.
In my experience, the cost of an entire year of GenAI imaging is a fraction of the expense of just one photo shoot. Further, the range of environments we achieve by using AI would be impossible to do with traditional photography in a year, even with many photo shoots. AI has added spectacular creative capabilities and removed the time and budget photo shoots previously required.
3 ways AI empowers visual creatives
Here are a few other ways I’ve seen AI enable visual creatives to work smarter.
1. Accelerated prototyping
Rough layouts or prototypes for complex projects like large murals, detailed product designs, or brand packaging can drastically speed up the testing phase.
Teams can generate dozens of options in minutes instead of spending days sketching variations. By front-loading experimentation, teams save significant time and resources during production.
2. Pre-production simulation
Video or photo teams can use AI tools during pre-production to create virtual environments or storyboards before production begins. Teams can simulate camera angles and blocking in a space that mirrors the physical location before anyone steps onto set. Solving these problems virtually means less stress on set and maximum efficiency for every hour on location.
3. AI testing panels
Getting diverse feedback is crucial, yet I’ve found traditional focus groups are often cost-prohibitive. Teams can bridge this gap by creating AI-generated persona models that represent their target demographics, and use these panels for preliminary feedback on marketing campaigns, user interfaces, or product designs.
This lets creatives catch blind spots and refine messaging for different audiences without the massive budget required for market research. In today’s world of huge audiences, the more “eyes” on something, the better.
These new tools and methodologies don’t isolate the creator. Creativity, especially the ideation phase, still happens with a team of humans, but ideation is different from creation. AI handles the mechanics of creation, leaving your team to own the ideation.
The human advantage
Anyone claiming that algorithms will eventually replace artistic vision simply fails to understand creativity’s fundamental nature— the human ability to experience. Even among the loudest AI proponents in tech leadership, the stark reality remains that true creativity is the one business area that will never transform away from humans. Technology is an engine waiting for orders, incapable of taking risks, feeling emotion, or finding a way forward without human ingenuity.
Those waiting for software to replace human storytellers will be waiting forever. The industry must stop publishing obituaries for human art, discard the safe corporate consensus, and demand environments where the human spirit thrives. There has never been a more exciting time to be a creative, and AI won’t kill that spark: it will ignite it.
Benjamin Spiegel is the chief digital officer at Polywood.