A parent asks an AI chatbot which car seat will keep their toddler safe in a crash. A customer types in a supplement’s name and asks whether it interacts with their prescription. A buyer about to spend $2,000 on a laptop asks whether the chip inside is the one advertised on the marketing page.
In each case, the model produces a confident answer in seconds. None of those answers carries an owner’s signature. After all, around 66% of AI users rely on AI output without evaluating its accuracy.
The AI economy hasn’t yet solved this due to a gap one layer down in the chain that fed the model whatever it returned. No institution sits inside that chain to certify the accuracy of what came out. No reputation is on the line if the answer is wrong. That’s a fiduciary, or someone legally obligated to act in your best interest and who bears the cost of being wrong.
I’ve spent 17 years building commerce infrastructure across the social era, the SEO era, and now the AI agent era. Across all shifts, the same pattern emerges—markets get fixed when a class of institutions emerges whose entire economic structure depends on accuracy.
Every mature industry has fiduciaries
In every successful economic system, a class of institutions emerges whose entire job is to be right. Accountants sign off on a company’s books and face license revocation if they sign off on a lie. Auditors stake their reputation on what a balance sheet reflects.
The publication Consumer Reports refuses advertising, so its product or service verdicts cannot be bought. Safety science company Underwriters Laboratories withholds its certification from products that fail testing. A Food and Drug Administration recall can lead to a drug being pulled from the market.
The names change across decades, but the function stays the same. Each one exists because someone decided the cost of being wrong was high enough to organize an industry around getting it right.
The AI economy has no equivalent yet. Builders race to ship AI features, and platforms routing products race to ship those features to users. It has agents now, too. And yet, the decisions AI is increasingly trusted with span the full range of consequences a consumer can encounter.
A wrong product recommendation can cost a shopper hundreds of dollars. An adverse supplement interaction can land someone in the emergency room. A wrong financial recommendation can compound into years of lost savings. The model produces the same confident answer no matter how high the stakes, and the same complete absence of consequence when it’s wrong. Models behave as designed. No institution signs its name to the verdict and bears the cost when the verdict is wrong.
Plausibility is the cheapest output a system can produce, while accountability is the most expensive. AI systems reward content that’s easy to pull up and present. Whether the content could survive an audit is a different question entirely.
Scale that dynamic up to product safety, ingredient claims, real-time inventory, or financial recommendations, and you have the real risk of the AI economy. The problem’s technical name is hallucination. The older diagnosis, the one every mature economy has eventually faced, is that no party in the chain owes a debt to truth.
The market won’t self-correct
A consumer-engagement platform cannot become a fiduciary by trying harder. The two business models pull in opposite directions. Platforms that earn when users stay longer are structurally biased against telling them to close the tab. Platforms that earn when users transact are structurally biased toward yes.
The institutions that became fiduciaries in older industries did so because accuracy eventually commanded a market premium high enough to fund the institution. That premium has not yet been priced into the AI economy.
There is a useful way to think about this in concrete terms. Most software talks to other software through APIs—connections that let one service request data or an action from another. An API that says something “might work” is worth a fraction of a cent per call. An API that says something “works, or we pay you” is worth orders of magnitude more. The premium is the willingness to take liability, which is what fiduciaries sell.
The internet today runs almost entirely on the first kind of API. The second kind is the gap.
We’ve been here before
Social media arrived faster than the institutions that could’ve made it trustworthy at scale. The companies leading the charge optimized for engagement. The institutions that should have audited the ecosystem did not exist yet. We are still living inside the consequences.
AI is a larger shift than social media was. The decisions companies make now about whose interests these systems serve will outlast any subsequent feature update.
We can avoid making that mistake twice. The infrastructure closing this gap looks more like an audit firm than a model lab. Its business model rests on accuracy, its economics survive only through accuracy, and its customers can verify accuracy independently.
Until a fiduciary layer emerges for AI, the cost of every confident answer falls on the user doing the verification work themselves. That hidden cost is compounding with every billion decisions a model makes. The institutional layer that finally absorbs it will be the most consequential infrastructure of the next decade.
Michael Quoc is founder and CEO of Product.ai.