Too often, I hear entrepreneurs say: “A new investor committed to funding nine months ago just backed out. He agreed to a non-binding term sheet to ‘get ahead of the competition,’ but now wants to re-trade the terms—valuation, liquidation preference, board composition—all terms my other investors had already agreed to.
“He said he believed in my vision, but he dragged things out so long that I’m now down to three months of runway. So what now? Layoffs? Cutting operating expenses to make payroll? He never wanted to support the business; he wanted the best deal for himself.”
WHEN INVESTORS ARE ONLY FOCUSED ON THEIR OWN GAINS
Something is wrong here. Bad-faith investors are getting away with mistreating founders and employees because of the way they wield their capital. I’m not talking about friends or family money; theirs is a personal risk, and they generally let the founders run the company.
What I’m referring to is institutions, particularly venture and growth equity firms that get their capital from limited partners (LPs) like pension funds, insurance funds, and university endowments. Some of these firms are stacked with former investment bankers, many with little to no operating experience and unlikely to be hired by a startup.
Knowledgeable, self-aware investors have the discipline to advise on only matters they have experience with. It’s the unaware investors who equate LP capital to their own, and believe the investment itself qualifies them to weigh in on complex management and operating issues. Their biases often force companies down ill-advised paths.
When a startup falters, you’ll never hear about an investor’s culpability. Failure lies at the feet of the entrepreneur, who couldn’t “see around the corner” or underestimated competition, mismanaged employees, and so on.
But let me be clear:
The U.S. mints the largest number of startups in the world, and talented investors are instrumental to their success. As an executive and advisor to some of the most innovative start-ups in NYC, I’ve seen up close the difference in outcomes between a balanced board of operators, independent advisors, and thoughtful investors, compared to a board dominated by unaligned members with little appreciation for the fundamentals of operating. The former can make a material contribution to future growth, while the latter can crush a startup’s momentum, no matter how good the idea.
WHO PAYS THE PRICE? EMPLOYEES, AND SOMETIMES FOUNDERS
What really bothers me is how often I see employees getting screwed. I’ve been lucky to witness invigorated staff, motivated by a mission they believe in, who sacrifice higher salaries for equity that will only be worth something if they succeed. But no one explains that even if their company is acquired, proceeds from the sale go to investors first, before— or if — any of it gets to them.
As for investor diligence, all an employee might be told is the dollar amount of the last raise and the portfolio companies their fund invested in. Oh, and the number of times their investor’s name appears on Business Insider, Midas List, or just good-old self-promotion LinkedIn posts beginning with “I’m honored...”
Employees — the ones building the product and representing the business and reputation — will never know that board decisions from their last funding round made their equity worthless.
A CALL FOR ACCOUNTABILITY
I believe the solution is an independent resource. Think of a Better Business Bureau that would cover investors so anyone could research their professional background, outcomes, and recommendations as reported by portfolio company founders and verified by this “BBB.”
According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, control of a startup board’s decision-making typically shifts from the entrepreneur (47% of firms at the first financing), to shared control between entrepreneur and VC (36% of firms at the second financing), to VC control (62% of firms by the fourth financing).
LEVELING THE PLAYING FIELD
But, where do changes in control leave employees who don’t know the makeup or dynamics of their board?
Founders who’ve experienced the process of pitching to investment to exit have a unique perspective on what makes a good board and what doesn’t. They could be immensely helpful, given the opportunity to share their experiences, to potential startup employees and future founders.
A BBB for investors can help solve information asymmetry between founders and investors. Investors share information about entrepreneurs all the time. They keep precise records of founder meetings. They purchase subscriptions that aggregate data on previous rounds, valuations, investors, board members, executives, and employees. They also do background checks, hire consultants to evaluate businesses, and employ accountants and regulatory folks to comb through financials and IP.
Founders, on the other hand, get a lot of unsolicited advice from industry professionals without specific knowledge of their business. They also often receive introductions to portfolio companies; all incented to say nice things, invitations to conferences with big-name speakers, and calls from general partners with the repetitive refrain, “We’re an extension of your team.”
TAKING ACTION WITHOUT A BBB FOR INVESTORS
In the meantime, here are a few suggestions for founders:
1. Review your board composition—balance investors with operators who support your objectives.
2. When evaluating a term sheet from a new investor, get an introduction to founders in their portfolio, and ask about their experiences.
3. Consider terms in addition to valuation; they will determine the waterfall and who gets what in a sale.
4. Have your team run scenarios at different exit values to understand the implications for each share class. And don’t be afraid to lay it all out for the board, including timing and cash runway.
6. If you’re not getting through, bring in a third party—lawyers and investment bankers are great at providing precedents and objective insights to help your case.
IT’S ABOUT IMPACT, NOT CAPITAL
If you’re a founder or looking to join a startup, what should define a “great” institutional investor? It’s not their return— that belongs to the founder, and the company’s management team. And it’s not the amount of capital they have—those funds belong to the investors’ LPs. The only way an investor’s “greatness” can be measured is by the people they’ve invested in.