Did you know diverse companies are 36% more likely to outperform their industry average? Despite contrary claims, diversity, equity, and inclusion are not buzzwords—they are vital to economic success in today’s marketplace. And demographic trends tell us that DEI’s impact will increase in potency as we journey into the increasingly diverse 21st century. That’s one of the reasons why all those ESG investors are submitting resolutions and pounding on your door, looking for metrics that prove your results.
Unfortunately, CEOs in companies today face significant challenges in diversifying their workforce. The good news is that you can address these challenges by getting your direct reports to employ the following three easy steps.
1. MAKE TARGETED-CULTURE-ADD YOUR GOAL
Broad goals like a 30% increase in females over five years are often too vague to be effective or enforceable. Assuming every team needs more females is unreasonable, as certain departments may already have a surplus. Additionally, holding all managers accountable for this type of goal is impossible to monitor and track. Instead, I propose setting culture-add as your top goal. But what does culture-add mean? First, it is important to understand cultural fit’s opposing philosophy to grasp this concept.
Cultural fit assesses a candidate’s ability to conform to an organization’s core values and behaviors. This concept originated in the 1980s with the idea that aligning personalities and values with an organization would increase employee satisfaction, dedication, and retention. Unfortunately, focusing on cultural fit led to sustaining workforce homogeneity and screening out diversity. Furthermore, current studies demonstrate that the true power to foster innovation and increase economic impact results from diversity, not perpetuating sameness. That’s where culture-add comes in. Culture-add brings individuals to the company who can contribute some elements of diversity that are missing or in short supply.
Now let’s look at an example of how culture-add provides a straightforward and practical approach to establishing corporate-level goals that you can leverage to hold every team leader and manager accountable for results. Suppose the head of HR oversees teams composed of 95% white women and 5% white men. The HR leader’s cultural-add objective might involve increasing racial and ethnic diversity (e.g., hiring Black and Asian candidates) and adding more male employees.
Conversely, the head of IT manages a team of 50% white males and 50% Asian males. Their cultural-add goal might focus on increasing female representation and incorporating other demographic categories. This process can be replicated with other department heads. In doing so, your organization can objectively allocate the goal of creating a diverse culture for the 21st century to every single people manager based on what they are missing and the dynamics of their respective areas of the business. This is something your HR department can easily incorporate into their systems.
Great! But what’s the best way to incentivize your team of leaders to act?
2. LEVERAGE THE POWER OF LOSS AVERSION
When organizations consider incentivizing leaders to support diversity, they often focus on the size of executive bonuses they will tie to meeting goals; however, there is a neglected alternative for incentivizing diversity. To comprehend this solution, let’s delve into the nature of two types of motivators: positive and negative incentives.
Positive incentives involve offering rewards or benefits for task completion or desired outcomes. These incentives can take various forms, like monetary rewards, recognition, promotions, bonuses, or tangible gifts. Positive incentives tap into an individual’s desire for gain.
On the other hand, negative incentives leverage the threat of loss or penalties to spur action. Negative incentives may involve fines, deductions, loss of privileges, demotions, or other punishments. These incentives exploit our instinctual aversion to loss.
People are generally more motivated to avoid loss than to acquire gain. Therefore, based on this, my advice is simple: Employ a combination of positive and negative incentives that encompass both aspects of human motivation. And, given the more substantial impact of loss aversion compared to the desire for gain, I suggest making potential losses heavier than potential gains.
In practice, a 5% deduction from a leader’s bonus can be implemented for failing to achieve their agreed-upon culture-add goal, while a 3% increase can be granted for exceeding it. (Again, HR can handle the details of scaling these percentages by increments using the usual failed-, meets-, or exceeded-expectations metrics).
Now you only need one more step to optimize this approach.
3. REMOVE FRICTION FROM THE PROCESS
A Chicago-based company faced a significant sales conversion challenge. Their target audience, millennials, would spend hours guiding the creation of their perfect personalized sofa but would disappear without making a purchase. The company initially thought they needed to increase incentives or improve the customer experience.
However, they discovered that the main obstacle to buying a new sofa was that customers didn’t know what to do with their current one. The solution was simple: The company started offering the removal of the old sofa upon delivery of the new one. This eliminated the resistance and solved the sales conversation problem without adding costly incentives.
New ideas or change efforts are often rejected because of those driving their focus solely on incentives, ignoring the power of resistance. Adding more features or enhancing messaging is not enough to sway others. Research highlights how various forms of friction can hinder the adoption of new goals.
To achieve your culture-add diversity goals, it’s essential to have your team identify and remove obstacles. This could include a lack of diverse contacts for recruiters or limitations due to in-office team requirements. Any impediment to success should be removed, reducing friction and making compliance with culture-add goals easier.
FINAL THOUGHTS
I believe DEI’s impact on corporate success will skyrocket as we journey into the 21st century. With this blend of clarity, incentives, and the elimination of obstacles, your company can be poised to soar as a triumphant champion in the ever-evolving, diverse landscape of the 21st century.
Joe Santana is a DEI strategist, author, speaker, Forbes Council member, and CEO of Joseph Santana, LLC.