Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The danger of empathy-washing in a world that demands authenticity

Here is how to recognize the signs, along with some suggestions of ways that organizations may avoid coming under fire for making empathy a performance.

[Adobe Stock / Parradee]

Profile photo of Evan Nierman

Founder & CEO · Red Banyan

Empathy used to give brands an edge, but today it can expose weakness.

In the era of social media and political flare-ups, companies often respond with a familiar playbook: carefully worded statements, emotionally aware language, and declarations of solidarity. These messages are usually polished and sometimes sincere, but they are increasingly ineffective.

That is because the rules of engagement have changed. Today’s audiences are paying closer attention to what happens after the message goes live. They want to see alignment between what companies say and what they actually do. When that alignment is missing, empathy can turn into something else entirely: a liability.

This is the risk of what’s come to be called “empathy washing.” The practice involves using emotionally charged messaging to project care and values, but without delivering meaningful follow-through. Much like greenwashing, it is a reputational trap. And in a digital culture driven by real-time accountability, it is a trap into which more brands are falling.

Here is how to recognize the signs, along with some suggestions of ways that organizations may avoid coming under fire for making empathy a performance.

KNOW EMPATHY WASHING WHEN YOU SEE IT

Empathy washing can often start with good intentions. A crisis unfolds. A cultural issue gains momentum. Leadership may feel pressure to respond, both to express solidarity and to meet rising expectations from employees, customers, and the public. The result can become a message that on the surface sounds appropriate, but under close examination lacks real substance.

One recent example followed the crash of Air India Flight 171 in June. Air India CEO Campbell Wilson released a formal video apology, but much of his message drew criticism after observers noted it closely echoed a prior statement by American Airlines following its own deadly crash. Because large portions of the remarks appeared to be repurposed, this prompted strong backlash over its lack of originality and emotional authenticity.

This kind of disconnect is increasingly hard to overlook. Internet observers increasingly compare words with actions, and when a message doesn’t reflect reality, credibility can quickly erode.

WHY AUDIENCES EXPECT MORE

The modern consumer is brand-fluent. Gen Zs and Millennials, in particular, have grown up in an environment where language is constantly dissected, recontextualized, and compared to behavior.

Today, the public is less likely to take brand messages at face value. Instead, they compare them to hiring practices, internal culture, product decisions, and news headlines. If the message does not match the company’s record, then it runs the risk of being flagged as performative. And performative is not neutral. In fact, it is often highly damaging.

Empathy that lacks evidence can feel manipulative to observers. In a crowded, skeptical media environment, sounding thoughtful without being accountable is no longer a safe default.

EMPATHY SHOULD REFLECT INTERNAL CULTURE, NOT AN EXTERNAL STRATEGY

The most effective empathy often does not begin with messaging. It begins with culture.

Even the strongest communications strategy cannot compensate for a lack of internal alignment. For a brand to speak credibly about care, conscience, or inclusion, those values must already be part of how the organization operates. That means investing in people, building inclusive leadership, setting clear policies, and ensuring everyday behaviors reflect what the company says it stands for.

Messaging, in this context, should not be used to manufacture trust—but should reflect it. When empathy is lived inside the organization, then the public voice becomes not just believable, but durable. It doesn’t have to be reactive or polished to resonate, but it works because it’s real.

MAKE TRANSPARENCY PART OF THE MESSAGE

One of the biggest myths in brand communication is that a company must have all the facts and be perfectly polished before it speaks out. But today’s audiences do not expect perfection; they expect honesty.

If a brand hasn’t yet figured something out, then it is okay to say that—as long as it is backed by a plan. Admitting you are still doing the work, still learning, or still in progress builds more trust than pretending to have all issues solved.

The key is transparency with intention. Do not just explain where you are. Show where you are headed and how you will be held accountable along the way.

ORGANIZATIONS MUST COMMIT BEYOND THE MOMENT

Empathy washing often thrives within flashpoint communications—messages that appear during fleeting moments of peak attention and maximum media exposure. To avoid being accused of empathy washing, companies should think beyond the moment and focus on continuity.

What happens after the statement? Is there an appropriate form of follow-up? Are there updates that can be given on subsequent progress? Are the same values visible in quieter times?

Audiences do not assess a brand based on a single message. They assess it based on patterns. Short-term visibility without long-term consistency is one of the clearest signs that empathy was performative from the start.

TO NAVIGATE A CRISIS, AIM TO SAY LESS, BUT PROVE MORE

Empathy washing is rarely the result of bad faith. It is usually the product of urgency, pressure, or the instinct to say something in the face of public emotion. But in today’s media climate, that instinct needs to evolve and be carefully considered.

If empathy is not rooted in action, it runs the risk of being viewed as performance. And performance without accountability weakens credibility, no matter how carefully it is worded.

Companies that want to lead with empathy should ensure that they also lead with alignment. That means speaking from the inside out, showing more than they say, and treating empathy not as a message to craft, but as a value to prove.

Values-oriented statements devoid of credibility can undermine trust and invite scorn. Instead, organizations should strive to do more, and then point to their actions as proof of their integrity. Real empathy is best served up with self-evident action. After all, actions speak louder than words.

 Evan Nierman is CEO of Red Banyan, a global crisis PR firm, and author of Amazon bestsellers The Cancel Culture Curse and Crisis Averted.