Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The death of the cookie is a wake-up call for growth

The real question is whether you’re willing to move beyond automated targeting.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Tony Gonzalez

CEO & co-founder · Mundial Media

When you walked into any ad tech conference over the last couple of years, everyone was talking about cookies going away. Then Google flipped the script in July 2024 and said, never mind, we’re keeping them.

Whether cookies stay or go misses the point.

Less than 40% of the total U.S. audience is reached by targeting with cookies. The remainder blocks cookies, opts out, or simply isn’t addressable through standard programmatic solutions.

We have been using cookies as a crutch, a substitute for knowing our audiences. Cookies never gave us what we thought they did. We automated everything and convinced ourselves that tracking pixels could replace human insight.

Sure, a robot knows someone visited a site. But does it know why? Not a chance.

Cookie-based tracking misses what matters most: identity. 

Cookies can track someone across the web, but they cannot tell you they are part of a community that controls trillions in spending.

Consider these recent consumer statistics:

  • Hispanic buying power surged roughly 46% between 2019 and 2023.
  • Black consumer spending increased by 33% between 2020 and 2024.
  • Asian American consumer spending was up 38% during that same time period.

Combined, these audiences now control trillions in buying power, according to eMarketer. Yet only 5.3% of total U.S. ad spending goes to multicultural media, according to PQ Media. Brands allocate the smallest budgets to their fastest-growing audiences because behavioral data does not reveal cultural identity.

For instance, cookies know someone bought running shoes but they don’t know whether that person responds to identity-based messaging. Cookies see the clicks, not the cultural moments and conversations that drive purchases. Understanding cultural context means knowing what resonates right now and which issues matter.

When you rely solely on cookies, you optimize for what people do, not for who they are.

WHAT TO FOCUS ON INSTEAD

Some brands get it and win big. Consider Google’s 2024 Super Bowl ad Javier in Frame. Google could have used cookie data to target technology fans or smartphone buyers. Instead, they focused on a community: people with visual impairments and their families. Directed by blind filmmaker Adam Morse and featuring the Pixel 8’s accessibility features, the spot followed a blind man as he documented his life. It garnered over 36 million views by February 2024. Google has shown that understanding a community’s needs outperforms behavioral tracking.

State Farm gets this, too. Cookie data would have suggested targeting auto insurance shoppers or homeowners aged 35-54. That is the problem with behavioral tracking. It cannot identify the cultural influencers who shape decisions.

State Farm’s 2025 “Batman vs. Bateman” campaign went a different route. They got smart about casting: Jason Bateman for Gen X, SZA as Catwoman for the music crowd, Kai Cenat with his massive live audience for younger viewers, and social creator Jordan Howlett. Originally eyed for the Super Bowl, they pivoted to March Madness and let Cenat debut it on his stream. Each creator brought their community, amplifying the message across TV, streaming, social, and digital channels. The campaign generated massive organic engagement. It proved you do not need the biggest budget or the most sophisticated tracking when you understand which voices actually move culture.

Bottom line: The old playbook is not cutting it. Following people around the web with ads for things they already bought? That is not personalization. Meeting them in places they trust, with messages that fit the cultural context? That is. Cookies tell you where someone has been. They cannot tell you why or what that place means to them.

Technology can process massive amounts of information. It finds patterns, detects shifts in tone, and identifies cultural moments. What it can’t do is explain why any of it matters. You need people from those communities for that. Lived experience turns signals into understanding.

The debate about cookies was always the wrong debate. The real question is whether you are willing to move beyond automated targeting and embrace approaches that prioritize cultural context, privacy-safe data from trusted sources, and genuine audience insight. Do that, and you stop settling for less than half the audience and capture the entire growth-driving audience.

Tony Gonzalez is CEO of Mundial Media.