Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The fix for the fictional enterprise brand

The four kinds of fiction to look for and how to make them real.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Daria Gonzalez

CEO, co-founder · Wunderdogs

Every brand starts out as a documentary: an account of a real product and company, edited to fit a specific narrative. Enterprise companies especially have the acumen and budget to build a brand deliberately, so they do. Yet, once the deliverables are signed off and the new brand launches to much fanfare, it settles into being an artifact, meant to be filed and occasionally admired.

Meanwhile, the company moves on, and the brand stays where it was. The people minding it sit a long way from where the product gets made. As a result, the brand can drift quite far from the company underneath it before anybody notices. The drift is slow at first: the brand looks a little dated but still resembles the same company. Past a certain point, though, the lag turns into contradiction, and a factual brand becomes a fictional one.

The fictional brand is a functional problem. A brand, especially at enterprise level, doesn’t exist as mere decoration. Its job is to make decisions for people who are not all in the same room: what to build, how to name a feature, and how to pitch a client. When the brand has drifted into fiction, every team overrides it in favor of the company they see. The brand stops being relevant to their decision-making at all.

There are four distinct kinds of fiction, and each has its own fix.

1. THE LEGACY NARRATIVE

The most common fiction is a mostly sentimental one. It’s the brand that still leads with the company origin story, the founding insight, or the flagship product that made the company’s name. The catch is that the flagship was sunset two years ago, and the revenue now comes from a part of the business the branding no longer reflects. Most likely the sales team already knows this, which is why they route around the brand and pitch the business as it now functions.

The fix is not to erase the history but to demote it. Re-anchor the narrative to what the company sells today. The founding story becomes emotional background rather than the driving headline.

2. PORTFOLIO INCOHERENCE

This one tends to creep up. It grows out of things that look like progress: acquisitions, diversification, and new products. A few acquisitions in, and the word “platform” starts to mask an array of products that share little beyond a naming taxonomy. The problem becomes visible when the one-liner bloats into five bullet points, and when the slide describing the company either turns vague or changes shape depending on who’s in the room.

The fix is the uncomfortable one. Either find the genuine through-line that makes the portfolio a platform or stop calling it a platform. The products should stand on their own.

3. THE FALSE PROMISE

This one grows out of a brand that is too aspirational about what the product can actually do. Buyers are the first to feel it. The brand promises “effortless” and “intelligent,” but the product only starts delivering any of that after a three-week onboarding, or only with a dedicated representative on the account. The tell shows up in the demo: the rep over-explains the experience or apologizes in advance for what the prospect is about to see. It shows up again, in plainer terms, in the win-loss notes.

The fix forces a choice most companies would rather avoid. Either the product rises to meet the promise—which usually takes real investment—or the promise comes down to meet the product. What you cannot do is keep overpromising at the first touchpoint and underdelivering at the demo.

4. AUDIENCE DRIFT


The fourth fiction is the quietest. Nothing about the brand is exactly wrong. What’s changed is who it’s talking to. The company has moved upmarket, or down market, and is now selling to a different kind of buyer, but the brand is still pitched to the old one. A prime example is the company that has grown into six-figure deals with enterprise procurement teams but still speaks in the friendly, founder-to-founder voice that won over its first few startup customers. The mismatch rarely produces an obvious error, which is why it survives so long. The brand simply feels a half-step removed from its own audience: a little too casual, or a little too stiff, for the new buyer.

The fix is to follow the buyer the company has now. Sometimes that means giving up a voice or an aesthetic the team views fondly.

THE FIX UNDERNEATH IT ALL

Each fiction is a version of the same mistake. Once a fiction is discovered, what follows is a rebrand-as-rescue cycle, which dilutes the brand’s value a little more each time around.

The deeper fix is to anchor the brand to the why—the conviction upon which the company stands. A product can be sunset. A conviction about why that product should exist can carry over to whatever replaces it. That is the difference between a brand that needs rebuilding every few years and one that keeps re-expressing the same idea as the company around it changes.

None of this makes the brand maintenance-free. In practice, everybody in the company must have responsibility for noticing, on a regular cadence, where the brand has come loose from what the company now does.

People in contact with buyers notice it first. They’re the early warning system. But if four people on a team simply correct toward their own sense of the brand, you’ve reproduced the four fictions in miniature. The why conviction gives every team a single fixed point to correct against. Adjustments compound into one coherent brand instead of fragmenting into several.

A product stays usable because reality keeps changing it. A brand stays factual by reflecting the company underneath it, and being treated, like the product, as something that is never quite finished being built.

Daria Gonzalez is CEO of Wunderdogs.