By now, it’s clear: Most return-to-office (RTO) mandates are failing. After years of flexibility, employees forced back to the office are feeling caged and resentful, if they haven’t already left for another company.
As a result, leaders who assumed RTO would solve culture or performance problems have instead seen them get worse. It turns out, tethering people to a chair doesn’t fix it.
Predictably, RTO has led to rampant “presenteeism”—people physically there but not fully engaged, or worse, fully checked out.
As a COO managing multiple locations across the country, I understand the problem: Real estate is expensive and having it largely unoccupied feels like a waste of money. And we know that many people are feeling lonely and depressed, so it seems logical that bringing them back to the office would solve both problems. But instead, it’s causing increased stress and anxiety, and poorer mental health.
RTO ADDRESSED THE WRONG PROBLEM
Return-to-office isn’t failing because people are lazy or don’t want to work. It’s failing because leaders didn’t ask why their culture or performance was slipping, and assumed proximity would solve it. Instead of asking what fuels their team, leaders defaulted to looming over their shoulders as a motivation tactic.
Leaders feared performance declines and cultural decay because they couldn’t physically see work happening. But the data tells a different story: Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows remote work increased productivity across 61 industries.
The office itself is also a problem. With flexible work, people can create their own space, enjoy a quieter, distraction-free environment, or set up shop on their deck in the fresh air and sunshine. Meanwhile, the open-floor plan at the office leaves people with no place to go for quiet and focus.
Finally, there’s the dreaded commute. The hours spent just getting to and from work have negatively impacted health and well-being. It has forced people to give up quality time with their families and for themselves.
And I don’t know about you, but when it’s five degrees and snowing, I don’t want to leave my warm home to go to the office either. Why should I expect my team to?
THE FUTURE OF WORK IS HUMAN.
In 2026 and beyond, companies must stop associating the number of days spent in office with success and let go of this “illusion of productivity.” Instead, they must focus on what drives their people to do incredible work, regardless of where it happens. It’s about treating them as humans, not as fixtures occupying square footage.
To get there, here are five questions leaders should ask themselves to build a workplace where people can thrive, regardless of location:
1. Do you want to work in your office?
If you’re working from home two or three days a week, but expecting your people to be in the office full-time, that’s a huge red flag. Why don’t you want to be there?
Next, ask about the office space itself. Are there spaces for focus, collaboration rooms for group work, and common areas for socializing? Does the Wi-Fi work seamlessly?
Your team can easily see what other workplaces are like on social media, so if your space is subpar, they know what they’re missing. Create your own FOMO with an office that feels like a destination instead of an obligation.
2. Are you mandating culture or designing one?
A great culture doesn’t just happen; it must be designed. Treat it like a product. Conduct user research to understand your team’s wants and needs. At Next PR, we do this through annual career conversations, where we ask our team what’s working, what’s not and what they want their future with our organization to look like.
Don’t be afraid to try something new and evaluate or adjust as needed. For us, hybrid work changes seasonally. When our summer interns come on board, we ask everyone to be in the office because it makes for a better experience. But we also take advantage of “no-meeting” Fridays and give everyone Friday afternoons off from Memorial Day to Labor Day.
Finally, establish a clear value proposition for the in-office experience. What does being there offer that working remotely doesn’t? For our agency, that means team-building activities, learning sessions, and group outings.
3. Do you understand their circumstances?
Your team wants to work where they feel respected and supported as a whole person, not just a performance cog. That looks different for every single person. Work with your team and HR to gather insights into individual circumstances and offer incentives. If coming to the office requires an hour-long commute, consider offering a Spotify or Audible subscription or a gas stipend. Empathizing with and minimizing their burden goes a long way toward creating a magnetic workplace.
4. Why do you care where they work?
The need to police proximity never made sense to me. Our team members are all adults, and we trust them to act accordingly.
Aside from the legal and tax ramifications, team members are free to work from their parents’ house, a beach house, or in their slippers from home. Does it matter if they landed our client that feature in TechCrunch while wearing gray sweatpants or a business suit? No. The results are what matter.
5. Do you value hours over outcomes?
I recently read about the 996 culture, aka the 72-hour workweek. My first thought was: “But is it actually worth it?” So what if your team spends every waking hour at the office? What do you have to show for it?
The future of work is redesigning performance around outcomes, not hours. If your team is exceeding targets, when does working more start to have diminishing returns for them and those around them?
A COMPETITIVE EDGE
In 2026, companies that thrive will treat flexibility as a competitive edge for performance optimization, not as a perk or privilege.
Leaders who cling to RTO have already lost the plot. No matter what the economic circumstances, success isn’t driven by mandates. It’s defined by leaders who choose trust and empathy over control and genuine culture over optics.
Geri Johnson is COO of Next PR.