Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The gold in the cracks

What hiking in Japan taught me about my leadership failures

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Mark Rickmeier

CEO · TXI

Once a year, I step away from my role as CEO of a software company to go long distance hiking with other executives from around the world. Rather than hosting a “workshop” on leadership development, we talk while walking out in nature (I call it the “Walkshop”). This year, I led 14 executives from Argentina, U.S., UK, Canada, and France on the famous 88 temple pilgrimage on Shikoku island in Japan. And halfway through our week-long hike, I asked each executive to do something uncomfortable: Tell the story of a professional moment that nearly broke them.

We’d been walking for days, visiting ancient temples along the Shikoku trail, when we paused to discuss the local custom of kintsugi—the Japanese art of repairing broken pottery with gold lacquer. Instead of hiding damage to precious pottery or china, the Japanese custom of kintsugi uses gold lacquer to bind the broken pieces back together. The repair becomes the most beautiful part of the object. The cracks are traced in precious metal, making the piece more valuable precisely because of what it survived. This became a metaphor for the difficult moments that have nearly broken us as leaders in recent years. And the conversation that emerged taught me something critical about how we approach failure in leadership.

THE STORIES WE HIDE

In software, we talk about failing fast and learning from mistakes. We have retrospectives after every sprint. We celebrate pivots. But when I asked each person on that trail to share a moment of genuine failure—not a pivot story or a “blessing in disguise,” but something that actually felt like breaking—the energy shifted.

One founder talked about laying off half their team during the pandemic. Another leader shared the moment they realized their leadership style was driving their best people away—isolating them from the rest of the company.

These weren’t the polished failure narratives we share on panels or in interviews. These were the cracks we usually hide.

THE DANGEROUS MYTHOLOGY OF RESILIENCE

As we walked and talked on this hike, we discovered the dangerous mythology around resilience. We tend celebrate leaders who “bounce back,” who are “antifragile,” who turn a setback into an opportunity. But this narrative does something insidious—it suggests that if you’re struggling with a failure, you’re somehow not resilient enough.

Kintsugi offers a different model. The pottery doesn’t bounce back to its original form. It doesn’t pretend the break never happened. The break becomes part of its identity, highlighted in gold, integral to its beauty and value.

As we discussed setbacks and failures, we resisted the urge to pivot quickly to learned lessons that led to eventual success. Instead, we talked about the months of doubt, the moments we questioned our own judgment, and the trust we often had to rebuild with those around us. The gold in those cracks wasn’t the quick recovery—it was the humility and caution we now bring to leadership decisions.

MAKING THE INVISIBLE VISIBLE

As leaders, we carry our failures invisibly. We reference them obliquely in advice to others—”I learned the hard way that…” But we rarely make the actual crack visible. We don’t trace it in gold for others to see.

In my software company, I’ve been experimenting with this. I’ve shared my biggest mistakes in all company meetings. In our leadership team offsites, we’ve made space for “what is keeping me up at night”—not post-mortems of resolved issues, but present-tense difficulty. These aren’t followed by solutions or advice. They’re moments that are witnessed and held. Something interesting happens when you make the crack visible while you’re still in it: Other people stop performing invulnerability.

THE GOLD TAKES TIME

The most important lesson from kintsugi isn’t just that breaks can be repaired—it’s that the repair takes time and intention. You can’t rush gold lacquer. You have to carefully trace each fracture line, allowing the adhesive to set, building up layers.

On that mountain trail in Japan, I realized that the executives who had the most wisdom to offer weren’t the ones who had failed and quickly rebounded. They were the ones who sat with their failures long enough to understand them, who had done the painstaking work of tracing each crack and understanding how it changed them. They each learned something from the moments that nearly broke them.

LEAD WITH YOUR CRACKS SHOWING

Back at my software company, I’m learning to lead differently. The question isn’t whether you’ll break as a leader. The question is whether you’ll trace those cracks in gold—making them visible, honoring what they taught you, and allowing them to become the most valuable part of who you are.

On the trail in Japan, after everyone shared their stories, I walked in silence for a while. I will admit, it was nice knowing I was not the only one wrestling with these moments of failure. I wasn’t concerned about any specific failure (we all make mistakes as leaders). Rather, the feeling of being broken and not being sure if I’d be whole again in the same way.

That’s the real gift of kintsugi thinking: not just that breaks make us stronger, but that showing our repaired cracks gives others permission to begin their own repair.

The gold is in the breaking. But it’s also in the slow, intentional work of putting yourself back together—and letting others see the seams.

Mark Rickmeier is CEO of TXI and founder of Walkshop.