The way a company prepares to appoint its next CEO says a lot about how it thinks about long-term planning and performance. Strong leadership pipelines are intentionally designed, rigorously maintained, and closely aligned with business strategy.
Data from Heidrick & Struggles found that 63% of CEOs are promoted internally, underscoring the critical importance of well-developed succession pathways for sustaining strong organizational performance.
Yet confidence in those pathways is faltering. In Heidrick’s recent CEO & Board Confidence Monitor, which surveyed nearly 2,000 CEOs and directors globally, only four in ten expressed confidence that their CEO succession planning positions their organization well for the future.
While leaders are growing more optimistic about other aspects of the future, such as economic uncertainty and AI, confidence in sustained leadership has not kept pace.
3 problems with the leadership pipeline
How did we get here? The current pipeline challenge results from three concurrent shifts at the top, middle, and entry levels of organizations.
1. Top-level generational handoffs
The youngest Baby Boomers will turn 65 by 2030, accelerating retirement across senior executive ranks. Historically, Gen X has filled many of those roles. But the Gen X cohort is smaller and insufficient to fully replace outgoing leaders, according to our research.
As a result, organizations could need millennial executives at earlier stages in their careers. This shake-up compresses traditional development timelines and places far greater pressure on organizations to identify and accelerate talent sooner.
2. Middle-management erosion
Management roles long served as the crucible in which future executives are tested and developed. Today, however, those roles are under strain.
A recent Zety survey examined generational leadership trends and found that nearly half of workers are uninterested in becoming managers—citing the role’s stress, work-life imbalance, and the emotional toll of people leadership.
Similar concerns are surfacing across other C-suite pipelines. If fewer leaders aspire to management, the traditional stepping stone to executive readiness weakens. If this layer continues to thin, companies will have to redesign how leadership capability is built, not just how it is identified.
3. Entry-level foundations shrink
In the earliest stages, AI and automation are reshaping—and in some cases eliminating—entry-level roles that have historically served as training grounds. Foundational learning experiences must be acquired through other means or later in one’s career.
When the first rung of the ladder narrows, the long-term pipeline inevitably constricts. Together, these trends raise a fundamental question: Who is next?
From succession plans to leadership assurance
The traditional approach to leadership planning—treating attraction, retention, development, and succession in distinct siloes—no longer works. Today’s pressures require a continuous, enterprise-wide, data-driven approach tightly aligned with business strategy.
The payoff of a well-executed succession strategy is tangible. Heidrick found that among CEO succession and executive pipeline planning leaders, 76% report their companies outperform peers financially. That drops to 48% among those confident in only one category, and just 33% among those confident in neither. Leadership continuity is a value driver.
3 imperatives to rebuild the pipeline
So, what must organizations do differently?
1. Prioritize retention and development
Leadership readiness begins long before a succession decision. Executives consistently cite learning and development as one of the most effective levers to strengthen succession planning, yet many development programs remain disconnected from actual executive pathways.
Organizations must explicitly link development to succession outcomes. That includes cultivating the capabilities most critical for next-gen leaders—curiosity, humility, agility— while creating rotational experiences that expose high-potential talent to diverse parts of the enterprise.
2. Use data for leadership visibility
Too often, succession planning reaches only one level below the CEO. In fact, our data shows that only about 30% of leaders say planning extends two levels down, leaving significant untapped potential throughout the organization.
Surface leaders by combining in-depth interview-based assessments with psychometric tools and structured feedback. These leaders may not self-nominate but possess high potential.
These processes can reveal future capacity, enabling tailored development plans and reducing the risk of overlooking emerging talent. Importantly, they also signal to rising leaders that their growth is being taken seriously, which strengthens retention.
3. Reimagine middle management as a strategic lever
Middle management is under pressure, but that doesn’t make it irrelevant. As administrative tasks are automated, managers are increasingly expected to exercise judgment, orchestrate cross-functional work, and serve as cultural stewards.
Our 2026 CPO Focus report highlighted that organizations should treat this as an opportunity to redesign it deliberately. Organizations can transform middle management into a leadership accelerator by investing in managers’ capabilities and developing qualities such as judgment, cross-functional leadership, and culture-setting.
The moment ahead
Succession planning matters, but success depends on whether leaders are willing to build the assurance systems required for resiliency. Treat leadership pipelines as a continuous strategic priority rather than a periodic board discussion, and you’ll be positioned to navigate disruption, sustain performance, and compete for talent.
Tom Murray is president of Heidrick & Struggles.