Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The marketer’s new mandate to build trust everywhere

Four ways to build brand proof across a multi-surface environment.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Stephanie Harris

Founder & CEO · PartnerCentric

I’ve spent much of my career watching brands try to understand how people actually shop. The mistake I see most often is not that marketers lack data. They force messy shopper behavior into a neat, linear journey map.

The traditional map is familiar: awareness, consideration, conversion. But that is not how most people make decisions anymore.

Think about the last time you bought something unfamiliar online. You may have discovered it on social media, compared it through AI, checked reviews and returns, watched a creator’s demo, and bought from the retailer that felt safest. That is a confidence-building process, not a straight line.

The journey is less like a funnel and more like a proof loop. That distinction matters because brands organize around channels, while shoppers organize around confidence. Instead of asking where someone first heard about a product, marketers should ask what the consumer needed to believe before buying it.

AI accelerates that shift, and recommendations don’t make creators, reviews, search, or marketplaces irrelevant. They make those sources more critical because shoppers are learning to cross-check what they see.

When my team recently studied AI-influenced shoppers and creators, one finding stayed with me: People aren’t using AI to replace human input.

Among surveyed AI-influenced shoppers, 61% of those with high trust in AI also trusted creators, compared with 11% of those with low or moderate trust in AI. Shoppers are building confidence across multiple sources, not looking for one source to decide for them.

How brands think about influence

For years, influence was treated largely as an attention mechanism. Could a brand reach the right audience and create enough awareness or urgency to move someone closer to purchase?

Attention still matters, but it’s not enough. When shoppers can verify claims across multiple sources in minutes, influence has to do more than generate interest. It has to help the shopper feel sure.

The most valuable marketing assets make a purchase easier to verify: Reviews that answer objections, creator demonstrations, clear product pages, consistent marketplace listings, and AI-visible content grounded in specific, sourced information.

When those proof points reinforce each other, confidence compounds. When they conflict, the sale becomes fragile.

AI gives shoppers a new way to double-check what they are being told. They may use a recommendation to narrow options, pressure-test a claim, compare products, or identify what to investigate next.

What the data shows

That instinct shows up clearly in the data. Among AI-influenced shoppers we surveyed, 44% wanted reviews before acting on an AI recommendation, and another 33% went directly to reviews after receiving an AI recommendation. If the AI answer is vague, inconsistent, or unsupported by other sources, it can create hesitation instead of confidence.

That requires a multi-surface marketing mindset. AI visibility, creator strategy, affiliate, reviews, product content, and commerce execution cannot operate separately. Shoppers care whether the story holds together across every source. Conflicting claims, unanswered concerns, or missing proof points create friction that may look like a lost sale.

Performance marketers know the last click rarely tells the whole story. A purchase shaped long before checkout can still fall apart over unclear pricing, weak reviews, inconsistent claims, shipping uncertainty, or a return policy that creates doubt.

4 ways to build brand proof

The brands that adapt fastest will be the ones that deliberately build proof.

1. Manage every surface as part of one consistent proof system

That requires tighter coordination between marketing, e-commerce, communications, partnerships, and customer experience. A product benefit should not change depending on whether someone finds it through a creator, a search result, an AI answer, a review site, or a marketplace page.

2. Ask creators to do more than promote

The most effective creator content will increasingly look like useful evidence: demonstrations, comparisons, tutorials, honest context, and answers to the questions shoppers ask before buying. Personality can create discovery, but proof creates confidence.

3. Know your strategic marketing assets

These assets include reviews, product data, shipping information, returns, pricing, and marketplace content.

The details may feel operational, but often carry the trust burden at the moment of decision. A shopper evaluating a product through AI or search may care as much about clarity and verification as the original message.

4. Measure the journey as a system of reinforcing signals

The goal isn’t to crown one channel as the source of truth but to understand how each source helps the shopper move from interest to belief to action.

This is a subtle but important shift. Brands have spent years optimizing for reach, engagement, and conversion. Those metrics still matter, but they don’t fully capture the new shopper behavior. In an AI-mediated buying journey, the critical question is whether shoppers can trust the brand across the places where they look for proof.

That’s the real opportunity. AI doesn’t erase the human elements of influence. It reveals how dependent purchase decisions already are on trust, context, and verification.

My advice: Don’t be the brand that generates the most noise. Be the brand that is easiest to verify.

Stephane Harris is CEO and founder of PartnerCentric.