Hiring feels deceptively simple. Not easy, but straightforward. You identify a gap, fill it, and move forward. But too often, what feels like a remedy is a swing in the wrong direction.
A founder hires a charismatic “player-coach” for their growing sales team. The new leader energizes the team and makes decisions quickly but ignores the importance of data and can’t build a useful report. This becomes a friction point with the CEO. After growing tensions, the sales leader is replaced, this time with a revenue operations leader. Neither lasts. Neither serves the true need.
This is known as pendulum hiring, and some variation of it occurs in nearly every startup. It’s the most common and costly hiring problem we observe. It’s not bad luck. It’s a predictable and avoidable issue that arises when you don’t truly understand the role or build a clear profile of what success requires.
WHY FOUNDERS OVERCORRECT
Founders tend to hire reactively. There’s an itch; they scratch so much that it bleeds. The pendulum swings, from visionary to operator, from motivator to metrics hawk. Each extreme addresses what hurt most last time but introduces new failures.
What’s usually missing isn’t talent. It’s a complete picture of what success looks like in the seat. The founder optimizes for remediation rather than requisitioning all the necessary ingredients to ensure things go right.
Early sales hires are the most challenging hires for a budding startup. A founder brings in someone who considers themselves a coach: people-first, but light on structure. The new leader isn’t data-driven; they can’t forecast or build a scalable system. They fail fast. So, the founder pivots hard, hiring a replacement who’s highly operational, bringing rigor and visibility. But this person can’t close, coach, or lead from the front.
Too often, roles are defined by the individuals who occupy them. The best organizations define roles comprehensively and seek out candidates who check those boxes. This isn’t limited to hard skills; it also applies to personalities and approaches. Consider how the role will connect across functions, how the person should communicate, and how they need to steward your culture.
THE PSYCHOLOGY BEHIND THE PENDULUM
Most founders think they’re good at hiring, but experience, not instinct, builds that skill. Compounding that overconfidence is the baggage that gets brought into the hiring process. Founders bring urgency, bias, and a false belief that they know what they’re looking for. This adds up to what a quarterback calls telegraphing the pass. As a result, they all but coach candidates to say what they want to hear.
Since most candidates can effectively sell themselves, the founder is often “sold” after just one or two conversations. Yet those interviews mostly echoed the gaps you coached the candidate to highlight. It’s not intentional, but it’s common. And extremely costly.
The best early-stage hires are not specialists who fix a single acute pain. They’re what I call comb-shaped generalists. People who can go broad, deep, and thrive in chaos. They’re founders for their function. They think holistically, work autonomously, and enjoy the mess of zero-to-one environments. They’re rare, and they won’t show up from cold inbound applications or scripted interviews.
4 STRATEGIES TO BREAK THE CYCLE
Rapid market shifts and AI adoption are shrinking teams and widening skill gaps. To find leaders who can flex and scale, start with clarity and these four strategies.
- Map the full role, spanning both hard and soft skills. Model the position after leaders who have already succeeded at your current stage of growth. Go beyond a job description and define what the person needs to do, not just what they need to know.
- Ask yourself, what outcomes should they produce in the first 30, 60, 90 days? What does cross-functional success look like? What kind of autonomy will they need? Most founders never put this in writing, and it creates misaligned expectations.
- Build a hiring committee comprised of advisors, operators, or investors who have held the role. Let them pressure-test your candidates. If you don’t have people who can do that, find them. Talk to other founders and build a bench of people who can help evaluate talent. Boards are often unhelpful here because they lack visibility into what the job entails daily.
- Rely on referrals rather than inbound résumés. The best hires often come from trusted referrals. Ask people in your network who they’d hire again. A strong referral is worth ten cold interviews.
USE PRACTICALS TO SURFACE WHAT THE INTERVIEW HIDES
Practicals are underused, especially in sales. But they’re among the most effective tools for exposing how someone works. A practical isn’t about putting someone on the spot. It’s about giving them a realistic exercise that mirrors the role’s requirements. Give them access to your team. Ask them to conduct discovery and produce deliverables. See how they think, how they communicate, and how they handle ambiguity. Remember, how they behave during the exercise is as important as what they produce.
If they don’t dive deep and explore all resources at their disposal, that tells you something. If they treat it like a real deal cycle, that tells you something, too. Practicals create pressure, just like the job will. And pressure reveals patterns.
WHAT THIS ALL COMES DOWN TO
Just because it’s been prevalent, pendulum hiring doesn’t have to be inevitable. It’s just the default when there’s no system in place. Slow the urgent instinct to fix what hurts the most in favor of what’s creating the pain.
The best leaders don’t just patch holes. They balance chaos and clarity. They give the business the strong foundation it needs to grow both today and every other day, at least until your next big inflection point. That’s who you should be hiring. You just need to fully understand who you’re looking for.
Justin Gray is the cofounder and managing director of In Revenue Capital.