The “pink tax” is the phenomenon of higher prices on products developed and marketed for women. It also addresses the additional expenses of existing in a body assigned female at birth, including costs related to reproductive care and cultural expectations around personal maintenance.
It’s time to acknowledge that the pink tax is about more than money. Women pay a massive toll—in time, emotional labor, and physical labor—to stay in the workforce, let alone rise to the C-suite. Here’s why it’s happening and what’s at stake.
Since the women’s liberation movement, there has been a steady rah-rah momentum behind women in the workplace. Climb up that ladder. Break the glass ceiling. Lean in. (As an executive living with a disability, I’ll point out the ableist, physical nature of all these corporate idioms. I suppose “use your cane to walk at a comfortable pace to the C-suite” doesn’t have quite the same ring to it.)
As nearly any woman in a corporate setting can attest, that rah-rah spirit doesn’t always match reality. Inherent biases and obstacles are ubiquitous and that’s exponentially more true for those representing additional marginalized identities.
The gap between ideals and reality is acutely visible at the top, where women are drastically underrepresented. But we’re moving in the right direction, aren’t we?
Not anymore.
An eye-opening report from McKinsey blows a hole in the idea that we’re still making progress. In recent years, particularly since the onset of the pandemic, women have started leaving work at alarming rates.
“Women are demanding more from work, and they’re leaving their companies in unprecedented numbers to get it,” says McKinsey’s coverage of their annual Women in the Workplace 2022 report, conducted in partnership with LeanIn.Org. “Women are switching jobs at the highest rates we’ve ever seen—and at higher rates than men in leadership.”
That last part should give everyone pause. Women leaders are leaving faster than men. That means we’re not only failing to gain ground in the C-suite but we’re actively losing it.
The stakes are astronomical. It’s not just about representation, though that’s a huge part of it because it’s difficult to become—or even aspire to become—what you can’t see. The other element is that, generally speaking, women bring very different and essential skills to the table. Without these skills present, particularly in leadership, the employee experience suffers as does the overall enterprise.
There are two major problems here. First, these essential skills are vastly underrated. They include so-called “soft skills” like empathy and inclusivity. These are no longer soft skills. In the new work landscape, these types of skills are make-or-break for leaders. Managerial success no longer hinges on monitoring inputs and keeping everyone in line. It’s now about empowering people to do their best work while feeling safe and free to work when, how, and where they can achieve optimal outcomes.
The second problem is the skills that make women valuable leaders are incredibly taxing, especially since they’re so underrated. Showing empathy and compassion is often interpreted as weakness. Insisting on an inclusive environment is still (appallingly) deprioritized.
Every day, women endure the emotional labor of constant microaggressions and the need to work harder only to still be viewed as less competent than their male counterparts. They’re left holding the responsibility of emotionally intelligent leadership, mentorship, elevating and inspiring others, a willingness to be humble and learn and other qualities that women leaders have shown to perform better than men, according to the Harvard Business Review. That’d be tough on its own, but it’s even tougher given that the rewards for this work are few and the barriers are many. Again, this is an even bigger problem for women with intersectional, marginalized identities.
As if that’s not enough, as the viral quote says, women are expected to work like they don’t have families and parent like they don’t have jobs. The women’s liberation movement delivered the expectations for women to “have it all” but not the crucial infrastructure and network of support required to do it all.
In the workplace, women must walk the razor’s edge of being coiffed and presentable without appearing high-maintenance, competent and assertive without appearing bossy, and innumerable other dichotomies that are both physically and emotionally taxing. They spend all day masking and code-switching, only to be told it’s not enough. As the McKinsey report points out, women constantly have their judgment questioned or are mistaken for someone more junior. “They’re doing more to support employee well-being and foster inclusion, but this critical work is spreading them thin and going mostly unrewarded.”
The move to the remote workforce presented the possibility of change—after all, we can now wear sweatpants and spend more time with family—but not the reality of change, as is demonstrated by the mass exodus of women in the workplace. Far too many enterprises have simply shifted the old structure and set of expectations to a remote landscape. Only the location has changed, not the microaggressions, not the imbalanced expectations, and not the valuing of essential skills that women bring to the table.
The solution is bigger than one byline, but it starts with reimagining what work should look and feel like. Focus on outcomes, not inputs. Recognize that empathy, inclusivity, and mentorship are nonnegotiable qualities for successful leaders. Leaders, empower employees to set boundaries and insist on boundaries for yourself, too. Let everyone determine how, where, and when they do their best work.
Without making this shift, women will keep leaving. When fewer women are at work, fewer women are in leadership. Fewer women in leadership means fewer of the elements that will enable an enterprise to successfully navigate the future of work.
The pink tax is more than money, and it’s entirely too costly. It’s time for change.
Becca Chambers is SVP of Global Brand and Communications at Alludo. Award-winning tech brand-builder, storyteller, strategist, and advisor.