Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The return-to-office resurgence

Returning to the office is trending up, and leadership is not as willing to be as flexible about it as they were a couple of years ago.

The return-to-office resurgence

[Adobe Stock / Krakenimages.com]

Profile photo of Bryan Buck

Return-to-the-office mandates have been ramping up over the last couple of years, and the trend is continuing. Amazon, Dell, AT&T, and WPP are just a few of the companies that have recently upped the in-office requirement for employees who have had more flexible arrangements since the pandemic. And, of course, the new administration has mandated that federal employees return to the office as well.

While the reaction from employees is mixed—and sometimes a cause of friction—CEOs are not backing down. The job market is tighter than it was a few years ago, and companies are no longer afraid of losing employees who want more flexibility. In fact, in a climate in which we are seeing many companies conducting layoffs, a return-to-the-office mandate is seen by some as a way to naturally effect some attrition without having to lay off (and pay severance to) a large number of people.

It’s not just the rank and file who are adjusting to this change. In my role as managing partner at an executive search firm leading searches for C-level roles, we are hearing this requirement more and more as a non-negotiable part of the hiring package.

Since 2020, many of the searches we conducted for top roles have had flexible location terms. Companies didn’t know when—or if—they would be back in the office, and opening up their searches to executives who were entrenched in different cities with no interest in moving opened up the candidate pool exponentially. 

Having teams spread out across the country worked well for many, but we are seeing the pendulum swing back, and it has made recruiting more challenging. Some candidates are in a city they love with a spouse who has a job he/she does not want to leave. Some live near their aging parents and don’t want to move away from them during their golden years. Others have school-age kids and they don’t want to uproot them from their communities. 

Studies on how remote work has affected the financial bottom line are few and far between. But the CEOs we work with see the positives of returning to the office as outweighing the inevitable resignations that will follow.

Here is what we are hearing:

IN-PERSON LEADERSHIP MATTERS

First and foremost, in-person leadership matters. When dealing with C-suite roles like CFO, CMO, and COO, leadership happens in the office. Having visibility with the team, both during in-person meetings and in casual conversations in the elevator or hallways, gives executives more opportunities to inspire, motivate, and build authentic relationships. Sometimes, it is an unscheduled conversation in the hallway that sparks a game-changing idea.

EFFECTIVE MENTORING

Mentoring young and mid-level employees is more effective in person. Those starting out in their careers tend to learn best from watching and listening to their managers and other experienced colleagues. This includes observing their communication styles, how they manage a crisis, and how they go about solving problems that arise day to day. When working remotely, employees generally only see their bosses on camera during meetings and miss out on learning from how their bosses operate outside of those meetings.

COLLABORATION

Collaboration can happen over Zoom, but it’s not as deep or as meaningful as in-person collaboration. Bouncing ideas off one another is more effective in person, as are creative meetings, which can feel stilted with cameras on and everyone waiting their turn to speak.

COMPANY CULTURE

Building and maintaining a company culture that employees value and feel a part of plays a large part in retention. When people are contributing to goals they believe in, they tend to stay at a job longer. An important part of developing a meaningful culture is visibility and transparency of leadership, which works best in person.

TRUST

And finally: trust. People who work together in person, weather storms together, and share in conversations about challenges—both business and personal—tend to build trust, making for stronger and more productive teams.

So much has changed in the workplace since 2020, and the jury is still out on how things will look in five years. What is certain is that for now, returning to the office four or five days a week is trending up, and leadership is not as willing to be as flexible about it as they were a couple of years ago. Our executive search firm is making this expectation known early in our conversations with candidates who can no longer count on flexibility as part of their compensation package.