“The moment you sign them is the moment you begin losing them.”
This poignant insight, shared with me years ago by a CEO friend in the media agency world, rings true for anyone who has worked in an agency. No client is forever. But I’ve found an even sharper way to pinpoint when the countdown truly begins: The moment your team can finish a client’s sentences is the moment you start losing them.
THE HIDDEN THREAT OF COMPLACENCY
As an agency leader and confidant of many CMOs, I’ve witnessed this pattern play out repeatedly. When the agency-client relationship gets too comfortable, too easy—that’s when you should worry. The healthiest agency engagements strike a delicate balance between improving the client’s business and generating a sustainable profit margin for the agency. But this equilibrium is precarious and short-lived.
In the early days, agencies over-invest in learning the intricacies and nuances of the client’s business, people, and preferences. This “getting to know you” phase is taxing for both parties; clients spend extensive time guiding the agency, while agencies funnel significant senior staff time into ensuring the work is on strategy. No one is operating efficiently, but the upside is a rich transfer of knowledge.
Everyone eagerly awaits a more seamless working dynamic. Agency leaders yearn to shift their attention to more pressing challenges. Clients crave an agency team that “gets it” so they can focus elsewhere. And agency staff hunger for a break from the exhausting iterations needed to push work out the door.
Then one day it clicks. The agency morphs into a well-oiled machine that can churn out work with minimal client input. Clients rejoice at this “extension of their team.” Agency leaders celebrate as profit margins inflate. A collective sigh of relief is exhaled. But beware—this is the insidious point where trouble lurks. I’ve watched countless agency leaders make the same critical error by taking their foot off the gas exactly when things seem to be humming along smoothly.
WELCOME TO THE TREADMILL TRAP
The treadmill emerges when an agency becomes so in sync with a client that the relationship runs on autopilot. Work is delivered consistently, client check-ins are predictable, and account dynamics stabilize. But while this continuity feels like a win, it’s actually kryptonite, because the advertising business is anything but stable.
When agencies get lulled by the rhythms of the treadmill, perilous consequences follow. Breakthroughs fade as the “outsider” perspective gives way to insider assumptions. Innovation is displaced by mere optimization as the path of least resistance. Clients detach while falsely believing the agency no longer needs their active engagement and oversight. Meanwhile, agency leaders resist rocking the boat, not wanting to disrupt a “good thing.”
The work itself stagnates into a predictable formula. Account team morale atrophies as the stimulation of tackling new challenges is replaced by a sense of being pigeonholed. Tenured agency staff starts eyeing the exit in search of “something new.” Client anxiety spikes when a longtime account leader departs. Concerns intensify as more turnover follows. The client scrutinizes the relationship and work with fresh eyes—and realizes both have plateaued. The agency is put on notice, a pitch is called, and the business walks out the door in search of “a new direction.”
INOCULATE YOUR AGENCY AGAINST THE TREADMILL TRAP
A few suggestions:
1. Prepare for ongoing change. Embrace the inevitability of change and ready your team to adapt versus coast.
2. Spark fresh thinking. Proactively rotate your account staff to infuse new thinking and keep the work fresh.
3. Uncover hidden issues. Dig beneath “everything is great” to uncover unspoken client frustrations.
4. Focus on priorities. Align on what’s most business-critical each quarter and rally your team to over-deliver.
5. Measure your impact on the client’s business performance, not just the output. When the tangible results are there, the relationship tends to endure.
6. Disrupt yourselves before you get disrupted. Set ambitious goals to solve your client’s biggest challenges in unexpected ways—and involve them in this process.
7. Most importantly, accept that making clients a bit uncomfortable is part of the job. Producing work that makes waves will make clients sweat sometimes—and that’s OK. If they agreed with you on everything, they wouldn’t need you at all.
ESCAPING THE TREADMILL
The inconvenient truth is that great advertising emerges not from cozy convenience but constructive tension. A client should never be able to finish your sentences, because you should always be starting new conversations. Escaping the treadmill requires running in a different direction. That’s what clients hire agencies to do.