At the end of 2022, I went old school and did some of my holiday shopping in physical stores. It was mid-December, but the sales staff I spoke to reported foot traffic was down—the surge they’d been expecting didn’t materialize. The holiday slowdown, however, may have been self-inflicted.
In an attempt to move inventory, retailers like Amazon and Target started sales earlier than usual. These Black Friday-like discounts in October gave consumers a chance to jump-start their seasonal shopping while saving—too good of a deal to pass up, especially amid record inflation and rising interest rates.
More importantly, the slowdown of holiday foot traffic is a sign e-commerce has taken a permanent bite out of in-person shopping. And that’s not a bad thing. With Walmart expanding its digital presence, it’s clear even large retailers see the benefits of providing an omnichannel experience as buyers demand flexibility in how they shop. In fact, there’s evidence shoppers are seeing brick-and-mortar and e-commerce as more complementary than ever post-pandemic. Shoppers are eager to return to stores, but aren’t ready to permanently sway from the digital commerce habits they’ve formed.
As we navigate a down economy, consumer choice is more important than ever. Throughout my career, I’ve worked with thousands of retailers with distinct needs through economic booms and busts. Regardless of the vertical, there are common mistakes to avoid when the economy is unstable:
MISTAKE 1: HOLDING ONTO PRODUCT TOO LONG
Inventory is a retailer’s biggest expense, and when the economy is uncertain, it’s important to have agility in how you deploy capital. Yet, a survey found the 20 biggest U.S. public apparel companies had, on average, 26% more inventory compared to pre-pandemic levels.
Too much inventory can put stores at risk if customers slow their spending. Just consider Lululemon—the company’s stock dropped the most since March 2020 when the athleisure-wear brand reported lower profitability accompanied by an inventory pileup.
Gauging inventory demand can be difficult, but one tactic is to work more closely with local suppliers. This can make retailers less vulnerable to supply chain disruptions and allows them to procure goods more quickly. I saw this trend emerge during the pandemic and it continues to serve many retailers. Sure, there may be a drop in margin, but the benefit of not having to carry more overhead can be worth it in tough economic times.
Other shops have found success with introducing special services or price drops to move stock. Regardless of how it’s done, retailers that shorten the period between paying for goods and selling them can be better positioned to weather the economic storm.
MISTAKE 2: UNDERINVESTING IN CUSTOMER SERVICE
It may seem counterintuitive at a time when businesses are looking to cut costs, but one common mistake I see retailers make when the economy turns is underinvesting in their people.
Nearly 9 million people work in retail in the U.S. and have the ability to make or break the customer experience. When retail workers are undervalued, however, not only can recruitment and retention become an issue, but the customer experience can be greatly affected. And it’s increasingly clear the sector has a problem: Retail job vacancies more than doubled from about 446,000 in April 2020 to more than a million by December 2021. This lack of investment in retail employees doesn’t just affect brick-and-mortar. A survey by Shopify found the in-store shopping experience is greatly influenced by online browsing and vice versa.
While AI chatbots have become a popular customer service option in e-commerce, a recent report says nearly 80% of shoppers still prefer customer service over the phone. Consumers want to feel understood and valued—a tall order for a robot. In fact, 49% of survey respondents said they were more likely to purchase from a brand that provides personalization.
In other words, investing in retail employees can mean a better customer experience—a pillar for success in any economy.
MISTAKE 3: OVER-RELYING ON PAY-PER-CLICK
Laws have changed over the last few years, and so has the advertising landscape. With acquisition costs reaching upwards of $100 per customer, retailers are better off getting back to basics and deploying proven strategies for attracting (and retaining) buyers.
Equally important in a down economy is ensuring your existing shoppers come back. In fact, this is why we’re seeing more and more brands investing in e-commerce and social commerce—they understand the benefit of meeting consumers where they are. Take the time to listen to what the behavior of your customers is telling you and you can have a much better idea of where your marketing dollars would be better spent.
It’s also wise to double down on ensuring your customers are getting an immersive and memorable shopping experience. In fact, it can be a surefire way to build community around your brand. Experiential retail can give shoppers the personalized encounters they expect and make them feel like they’re part of a club. In other words, it can give them unforgettable service they’ll return for.
Whether you’re looking to drive sales online, in-person, or both, doubling down on delighting your customers is key to thriving through economic highs and lows.
When the economy turns, it’s a challenge for any sector, but these hardships don’t come without reward. Retailers are forced to get more creative and change the way they operate. Those that stay agile in their operations and continue to invest in the customer experience with understanding and flexibility can find ways to thrive in any economic climate.
Ben Crudo is CEO of Diff Agency. A retailer-turned-technologist, Ben is an e-commerce expert helping retailers win today and tomorrow.