Someone reaches out to me, hoping to find more sales leads to grow their business. But that’s not the real, underlying problem, and they don’t need to spend more money on new leads. It’s their sales conversion rate—the process of turning leads into paying clients—that they need to fix.
Every prospect who agrees to a sales conversation with you walks in carrying two versions of their situation. They’ve prepared one of those stories to share with you. The other story, they’re not sure you’ve earned yet.
The prepared version is polished and organized. It covers the headline problem—the one they’re comfortable naming out loud and sounds reasonable to bring to a professional. It protects the parts that feel too vulnerable, too uncertain, or too revealing of the problem’s timeline and the cost of leaving it unresolved.
To shift from one version to the other, you need to understand something prospect picks up on in the first few minutes of your initial sales conversation, before you’ve even said much at all.
Shift the conversation
Early in the conversation, the prospect is testing you—not deliberately, or with a checklist in hand. Something in them is watching carefully, for one thing: Whether you’re genuinely here to understand them or only gathering information to try to make the sale.
Your prospect has had enough sales conversations to sense the direction beneath your words.
They send up something small to share to see what you’ll do with it. If you move quickly to a solution, or nod and pivot toward the next item on your agenda, they read that as a signal.
So they give you enough to keep the conversation moving without anything feeling too exposed.
But if you stay with what they said, if you follow it more deeply instead of redirecting, if you ask the kind of question that says, “I actually want to understand this”—rather than “I’m building toward your recommendation” —something changes on their side of the conversation. Questions like:
- “How long has that been an issue for?”
- “What have you done so far up until now to address it?”
- “How is it impacting your business?”
- “Is it a priority for you to have this solved as soon as possible?”
Your prospect will relax. Most sales conversations never get past the prepared version. Your prospect isn’t trying to be dishonest, but they never felt safe enough to tell the full story.
Earn the real story
The professional version starts to give way. And then the real situation comes out, sometimes slowly, sometimes all at once, in a way that surprises even them.
The real version is messier. It includes the thing your prospect tried 18 months ago that didn’t work and hasn’t told anyone about.
Once, a prospect asked for help to motivate their sales team. I replied, “What exactly is the core problem you’re trying to solve?”
He said, “To have them perform better.”
I asked again. “Let’s go beneath that. What’s the blind spot your team can’t see?”
He finally revealed that the sales team was spending their time following up on leads instead of building trust up front to support decision-making.
Your prospect likely already realizes the problem is bigger than they want to admit, and what’s actually at stake. Not the professional version of the stakes, but the personal version, sitting in the back of their mind.
Why do you need the real story?
Without the real version on the table, you’re working with a partial picture to design a solution for a half-true problem. So proposals that look right on paper—accompanied by recommendations that seem perfectly matched—don’t convert the way they should.
Another potential client said they were really good at relationship building, but couldn’t understand why perfectly qualified leads weren’t converting. I helped him understand that relationship-building isn’t the same as trust-building. Relationships can create a peer-to-peer social structure, preventing us from asking the bold questions that uncover the truth about a situation.
There’s no technique that creates this and cannot be manufactured mid-conversation. It happens when your prospect genuinely senses that you have no destination in mind other than understanding where they are.
When there’s no hidden agenda pulling the conversation in a particular direction, there’s nothing the prospect worries about protecting themselves from.
This is where the real work of trust-based selling happens. Not in the language you’ve prepared or the structure of your process. It happens in a single unrepeatable moment when your prospect decides, quietly and without saying so, that this is a safe conversation.
Ari Galper is the founder and CEO of Unlock The Game.