Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Too many promising startups are floundering: Here’s how venture capital firms can help

With such hurdles in place, only 8% of all funded startups actually return invested capital, leaving a very small cohort of “unicorns” to provide big returns.

Man and woman shaking hands

[Images: Courtney Haas/peopleimages.com/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Justin Gray

Co-Founder / Managing Director · In Revenue Capital

BY Justin Gray

If your doctor touted an 8% success rate for surgeries, you’d likely forgo an operation with them. Yet, these are exactly the numbers founders are faced with when securing funding for a startup. This is abysmal—especially considering that startups are the backbone of the economy and the enterprises of tomorrow. 

Not only have startups been let down by the very people allegedly in place to support them—their investors—but those same shareholders have coerced them into the adoption of “best practice” strategies that are outdated and overly generalized. It’s not surprising that those practices have resulted in dramatically higher customer acquisition costs and more competition over time. 

With such hurdles in place, only 8% of all funded startups actually return invested capital, leaving a very small cohort of “unicorns” to provide big returns. Ultimately, venture capital has been designed to work for the investor, but not so much for the founders. 

This is why a brand-new approach may be required. Operator-immersed capital is expertise coupled with capital. Here’s a look at this model, and not only why it can work—but how it can provide the shock to the system that B2B startups need in today’s efficient, growth-focused markets. 

THE PROS AND CONS OF THE OPERATOR CAPITAL MODEL

In operator capital, a large number of limited partners (LPs) participate in fund syndicates where those LPs are all experts in a respective field. This provides a strong value-add to both the VC firm and the portfolio companies in which they invest. Maintaining close proximity to the market allows VCs to source deals efficiently and make better decisions from a market fit perspective. 

On the portfolio company (PortCo) side, founders and their teams are able to leverage a strong network of right-fit advisors who can help them build their businesses and overcome real challenges. Many VCs are even doubling down and building operating centers within their firms to support PortCos with best practices accumulated and curated by operators. This is a good model, but it carries one major problem: It’s all reactive in nature. 

Expert communities rely on proactivity and engagement, which are difficult to sustain at scale. Because operator capital firms often rely on small checks from their LPs and at a sporadic clip, they need to expand to maintain capital sources. As that community of LPs grows, it loses its connection to its own value-add—which is only exacerbated by the implementation of technology. It’s incredibly difficult to maintain engagement and connection within a circle of hundreds, potentially thousands of LPs. 

Of course, with this disconnect comes the loss of value to the startups within the portfolio. Suddenly, rather than a small circle of active LPs proactively monitoring their business and offering assistance, they are left to attempt to mine the VC and LP base with their questions. This lands everyone back where they started, with VCs ultimately providing capital and not much more.

When you consider the upside of the operator-capital model, as well as its flaws, it becomes clear there can be benefits from embedding true operators directly within portfolio companies. Such an approach means that the VC firm itself is run by executives who have a track record of success in operating and growing businesses. They can provide hands-on strategic guidance and operational expertise to set the course and amplify company performance—all while abiding by founder-friendly terms. 

Startups are clamoring for value-add from their VC backers. It’s time that VCs truly embrace this and act on the extensive ways they can support their portfolio companies beyond capital infusion. This includes both relationship curation as well as actionable tactics to capitalize on these open doors. VC firms should not only provide introductions, but they should also help create repeatable playbooks and reinforce those motions through coaching. Creating a true ecosystem of trust exponentially accelerates the impact of the capital.

FROM INBOUND AND OUTBOUND TO NEARBOUND

With the goal of providing big growth mechanisms for portfolio investments, operator-immersive firms are faced with the same challenges as all VC firms, but even more so due to the increased lift created by both investing in startups and participating in the business. This means that the value-add motion must also be accomplished with a high degree of efficiency to optimize time commitments. The rise of “Nearbound” and the refresh of tired channel sales initiatives as a true partner ecosystem can be a great solution to this problem. 

Historically, partner programs ranged from being a thinly veiled proxy for pay-to-play to being an anemic box-check acquisition channel. In the new world of partner ecosystems, there should be a fundamental strategy for creating and extending value to both B2B organizations and their clients. Experienced go-to-market operators know how to build partner ecosystems, understanding that they are drivers of revenue. 

Case in point: When Satya Nadella took the helm as Microsoft CEO in 2014, he focused on building a culture of empathy focused on a partner-first mentality. This shift required all employees to embrace a growth mindset and prioritize growing and empowering their partner ecosystem. In fact, 95% of all Microsoft’s $200 billion in annual revenue flows directly through partners. Nadella’s partner-led go-to-market strategy has clearly paid off, as the company has continued to grow year over year since his tenure began in 2014. 

If you are a VC, it’s time to reevaluate the value you’re proving to your portfolio companies. If you’re a startup founder who has been failed by the system, know that you’re not alone—and that there are other options available to you. It’s time to ask for more from capital partners and work with those who offer far more value than investment alone, opening up routes to market and maximizing your company’s long-term value. The market demands it, and you—and your business—deserve it. 


Justin Gray is the Co-Founder and Managing Director of In Revenue Capital.