Business leaders should understand what is really happening with U.S. debt. Not just government debt, which is now over $33 trillion and often discussed in the media, but also personal and household debt.
Why? Because for most retail businesses selling discretionary products and services, the amount of discretionary cash households and individuals have has a direct impact on them.
According to an early August 2023 report released by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s Center for Macroeconomic Data, the total household debt was around $17 trillion.Of this, the biggest component was around $12 trillion in mortgage debt. Auto debt and student debt were almost tied at around $1.58 trillion and $1.57 trillion respectively, while credit card debt recently breached $1 trillion. Other debts filled up the balance, including home equity loans at around $340 billion.
Mortgage debt and home equity loan payment delinquencies were around 0.63% and 0.44% respectively. The fact that these are still below one percent indicates many people still want to keep their homes and try to avoid missing mortgage and home loan payments if they can. But both delinquencies and defaults are expected to grow as economic conditions worsen.
The situation is worse with credit card debt, which had a delinquency/delayed payment rate of around 5.08%, especially since credit card interest rates are now above 20% on average.
Some people may have a sense that just because their home price has risen, they have nothing to worry about. That’s not true. While personal wealth and equity are largely defined by house value, it is not liquid. Unless they are selling or taking out a loan on their home, they are not going to spend the value locked in their house. This lack of liquidity restricts spending options for individuals, which impacts businesses reliant on discretionary spending.
DISCRETIONARY SPENDING
Businesses need to understand the disparity between income, welfare benefits, personal savings, and monthly expenses. Most Americans struggle to save even $500 for emergencies, hindering their capacity for discretionary spending. This financial strain affects various industries, especially those selling non-essential items.
So, no matter how slick the advertisements are for the new iPhone 15, Apple might have a hard time growing in the U.S. Someone who once had that $500 to spare for discretionary purchases might now find it difficult to afford such luxuries when dealing with mortgages, car loans, credit card debt, or student loans.
Not all expensive discretionary products have that problem. For example, luxury goods makers like Louis Vuitton and Hermes produce what are called Veblen goods. Veblen goods do not necessarily follow the typical law of supply and demand, which says that as price increases, demand falls. That’s true for most items, but not luxury goods. This is because people want to advertise their social class distinction through these expensive items. If everyone could afford the items, it wouldn’t set them apart.
SOBERING STATISTICS
Since most companies that sell retail goods aren’t really luxury manufacturers, these numbers are sobering. Prior to the pandemic, personal savings averaged around 7.5% to 9.5% of a person’s monthly income. Now it is hovering around the 3%-4% range. It actually shot up to 33.8% in April 2020 because of the CARES Act and the fact that most people just sat inside their homes and couldn’t really spend.
But after the all-clear sign was given, people tried to make up for lost time and spending. Experts estimate that personal savings will be depleted later this year, especially for those households and persons who will need to resume student loan payments.
While the inflation rate has gone down, the 525 basis point interest rate hikes from last year have also cut back discretionary spending for many Americans, as their loans are much more expensive now. Oil prices are also rising, exacerbated by the recent war in the Middle East, which will drive inflation and the Consumer Price Index up further. Be ready for another rate hike at least.
Some people at this point don’t even have any discretionary spending left, as they are so underwater paying for food, housing, and utility bills, as well as mortgages, student loans, car loans, and credit card loans. At some point, they may have to face a default or foreclosure situation.
A BUMPY RIDE FOR BUSINESSES
Household and personal debt relative to income (debt to income ratio) is such a big factor in determining the health of the economy. Unfortunately, many American consumers and households are in very tight situations right now, and almost every industry and business that produces discretionary products and services should probably expect a rocky ride.
If you are running a consumer retail business, there are a few actions you can take to ride out the storm. Tighten up on unneeded expenses, maybe delay that expansion or hiring for at least a year, and consider lightening up on stocks in your corporate treasury in favor of fixed-yield cash instruments like short-term treasuries.
Maybe you won’t have a record year, but the point is to survive until the situation calms down.
Zain Jaffer is an active Tech & Real Estate investor who sold his last company for $780M in 2019 to Blackstone.